InSpec 1 Ltd & Ors v The Export-Import Bank of China [2026] EWHC 1162 (Comm), the Commercial Court considered how asymmetric jurisdiction clauses operate when both parties have commenced proceedings in different countries. The Court held that where such a clause contemplates the possibility of parallel proceedings, neither set of proceedings should be constrained – even if this means litigation running simultaneously in more than one jurisdiction. The Court therefore refused to stay the English proceedings and refused an anti-suit injunction against the foreign proceedings.
Courts will interpret asymmetric jurisdiction clauses in light of their commercial purpose of enabling the party with the benefit of the clause to pursue claims or enforce security against the counterparty’s assets in multiple jurisdictions. If parties wish to limit the flexibility of such a clause – for example by preventing the party with the benefit of the clause from suing elsewhere once proceedings have been commenced in the agreed forum – this needs to be set out expressly in the drafting.
Background
The claim arose from ship finance arrangements between The Export-Import Bank of China (the Lender) and Spec 1 Limited, Spec 2 Limited and Spec 3 Limited (the Borrowers). The Lender and the Borrowers entered into a group of interlocking finance documents, including a loan agreement (the Loan Agreement), which sat at the commercial centre of the transaction.
The Loan Agreement contained the following asymmetric jurisdiction clause:
18.2 Jurisdiction For the exclusive benefit of the Lender, the parties to this Agreement irrevocably agree that the courts of England are to have exclusive jurisdiction to settle any dispute (a) arising from or in connection with this Agreement or (b) relating to any non-contractual obligations arising from or in connection with this Agreement and that any proceedings may be brought in those courts.
18.3 Alternative jurisdictions Nothing contained in this Clause 18 shall limit the right of the Lender to commence any proceedings against the Borrowers in any other court of competent jurisdiction nor shall the commencement of any proceedings against the Borrowers in one or more jurisdictions preclude the commencement of any proceedings in any other jurisdiction, whether concurrently or not.
Once issues arose under the finance documents, both parties commenced proceedings. The Lender began proceedings in Singapore against the Borrowers, and the Borrowers issued proceedings in England, relying on Clause 18.2.
Issues
- Whether the English proceedings should be stayed in favour of Singapore.
- Whether the Lender should be restrained from pursuing its Singapore proceedings (anti-suit injunction), or alternatively whether the Lender should be restrained from seeking an injunction against the English proceedings (anti-anti-suit injunction).
Decision
The Lender's application
The Court dismissed the Lender’s application for a stay of the English proceedings. The Lender accepted that the English court had jurisdiction in principle under Clause 18.2, but argued that England was not the right forum in practice. Related proceedings were already underway in Singapore, and that a stay would allow all the disputes to be resolved together there.
The Court disagreed. Clause 18 was drafted to let the Lender sue the Borrowers in any court of competent jurisdiction, and expressly provided that proceedings in one jurisdiction would not prevent proceedings in another. The parties must therefore be taken to have accepted, from the outset, that parallel proceedings were a real possibility.
The Court noted that staying the English proceedings would leave the Borrowers with nowhere to sue at all, since they were contractually obliged to bring claims only in England. If either set of proceedings had to be constrained, it would make more sense for it to be the Lender’s foreign proceedings – this would at least leave the Lender able to sue in the designated forum. But ultimately, the Court held that neither set of proceedings should be constrained. The parties agreed to a clause that contemplated parallel proceedings, and the Court should simply hold them to that bargain.
The Borrowers’ application
The Court also dismissed this application. The Borrowers argued that once they had issued their claim in England, the Lender lost the right to bring any further proceedings anywhere else. The Court found nothing in the wording of Clause 18 to support this. Asymmetric jurisdiction clauses are particularly common in ship finance because they enable the lender to take steps against the borrower’s assets, wherever they are situated. The Borrowers’ reading of Clause 18 would have prevented this and defeated the commercial purpose of the clause.
The Borrowers also argued that Singapore was not “a court of competent jurisdiction” within the meaning of Clause 18.3. This turned on whether the Lender could satisfy the procedural requirements under Singapore law for service out of the jurisdiction. The Court rejected this, accepting that the Lender’s claim was made to assert rights of security over moveable property situated in Singapore. Since neither argument succeeded, the Lender’s Singapore proceedings were not a breach of contract and there was no basis for an anti-suit injunction.
Finally, the Borrowers’ fallback request for an anti-anti-suit injunction also failed. There was no real evidence that the Lender was planning such an application, and in any event it would have been bound to fail – the Borrowers had a clear contractual right to sue in England.
Key takeaways
Parties negotiating or operating under finance and other commercial agreements with asymmetric jurisdiction clauses should bear in mind the following:
- Courts will interpret these clauses in light of their commercial purpose – typically to give the option-holder (often a lender) flexibility to pursue claims or enforce security against the counterparty’s assets in multiple jurisdictions. This is especially important in ship finance, where the lender may need to arrest a vessel wherever it happens to be, but the principle applies to any transaction where the option-holder’s ability to act in more than one country is commercially significant. Parties on the non-option-holder side should not expect the courts to read down that flexibility.
- Agreeing to an asymmetric jurisdiction clause means accepting that proceedings may run in parallel in more than one country. This carries real commercial consequences – including the cost of defending or pursuing litigation simultaneously in multiple jurisdictions and the risk of inconsistent judgments.
- If the parties want to limit the option holder’s flexibility – for example by preventing it from suing elsewhere once proceedings have been commenced in the agreed forum – this needs to be spelled out expressly in the drafting. The courts will not read in such a restriction where the words of the clause do not support it.
- Where parallel proceedings do materialise, the Court made clear that it expects the parties to find pragmatic solutions themselves – for example, by agreeing which proceedings are most likely to produce a prompt judgment and staying the other set in the meantime. Common sense is not something the Court will impose, but parties who fail to exercise it risk unnecessary cost and delay.
With thanks to Joe Miley for his assistance in preparing this post.
Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.