Executive summary
The District Court of The Hague (the Court) issued a landmark decision on 28 January 2026 in the case of Greenpeace Netherlands v The State of the Netherlands. The ruling orders the Dutch State to comply with its international emissions reduction targets until 2050 and to implement a coherent climate adaptation plan for Bonaire by 2030.
The decision is the first time that a national court has applied the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) framework established in KlimaSeniorinnen (for more information, see article here) and relied upon the July 2025 International Court of Justice (ICJ) Advisory Opinion (for more information, see article here) to rule not only on a state’s mitigation measures but also its adaptation measures.
Background
Bonaire is the largest of the three special municipalities of the Caribbean Netherlands. It has formally been part of the Netherlands since 2010 and is a “small island” that has been identified by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change as particularly vulnerable to the effects of climate change.
The action was brought in 2024 by Greenpeace on behalf of the residents of Bonaire. Greenpeace alleged that the Dutch State had failed to protect the residents of Bonaire from the impacts of climate change and had therefore failed to fulfil its positive obligations under Article 2 (right to life), Article 8 (right to respect for private and family life) and Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination) of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).
The Court’s reasoning
1. Causation
Applying KlimaSeniorinnen, the Court clarified that, in climate cases, it will assume a causal link between a state’s failure to combat climate change and the consequences that individuals experience as a result of climate change. Claimants must therefore only establish that the State has failed to comply with its obligations relating to climate change adaptation or mitigation and that harm has been suffered by a group of people because of the negative consequences of climate change. The burden then shifts to the State to show that there is “no causal link between the conduct specifically complained of and the consequences known to affect individuals as a result of climate change.”
The judgment also comments that states have a shared responsibility to combat climate change. A state therefore cannot rely on the argument that a reduction in its own emissions would make little difference on a global scale as a defence to climate litigation.
2. Framework for assessment of Articles 2 and 8 in climate litigation
In KlimaSeniorinnen, the ECtHR established an “overall” framework to assess how Articles 2 and 8 of the ECHR should be applied in climate change litigation. This framework imposes a duty on Member States to adopt legislation and take other “measures” to mitigate the effects of climate change, namely:
Mitigation measures: Not only must a state specify a target timeline for achieving carbon neutrality and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reduction targets, but it must also comply with those targets.
Adaptation measures: A state must take adaptation measures “aimed at alleviating the most serious or threatening consequences of climate change”. The Court emphasised that these measures are interconnected with mitigation measures, necessitating an overall assessment of mitigation and adaptation measures.
Procedural safeguards: A state must observe procedural safeguards when taking mitigation and adaptation measures to ensure that (1) the conclusions of studies conducted by public authorities are publicly available, and (2) they take into account the views of the public when making decisions.
We consider the Court’s assessment of the mitigation and adaptation measures taken by the State against Article 8 below.
The Court did not assess the alleged breaches of Article 2 by the State. It noted that there was a lack of clarity in the ECtHR’s approach to Article 2 in KlimaSeniorinnen but provided its own interpretation of the threshold for Article 2 claims. It held that such a claim requires both “a high intensity of exposure” to the effects of climate change and “a pressing need” to ensure the individual’s protection. The Court found that Greenpeace had failed to demonstrate that these requirements were met with respect to the residents of Bonaire, emphasising that the consequences of climate change will vary depending on individual circumstances and the adaptation measures taken in future.
-
Mitigation measures:
The Court found that the Dutch State’s mitigation efforts fail to meet the “minimum standards agreed within the UN context”, including through the UN Climate Convention and other related agreements, relating to mitigation.1 In reaching this conclusion, the Court considered:-
Emissions reduction targets:
The Dutch Climate Act 2023 (the Act) provides that the Netherlands must be carbon neutral by 2050, as required by UN agreements. However, the Court found that the Act’s interim target – which requires the State to strive for a 55% reduction in emissions by 2030 compared to 1990 levels – is not compliant with the State’s mitigation obligations. The reasons for this included that:- - The Act sets a goal rather than a binding intermediate target.
- - The target – like that under European climate law – relates to emissions reductions compared to 1990 levels, rather than 2019 levels as required by current UN standards.
- - The Dutch and European requirements both exclude emissions sources, including aviation and shipping. This is not permitted under the UN standard.
The Court also clarified its approach to assessing whether national climate policy and emissions reductions comply with international law. It explained that a state’s failure to reduce its own GHG emissions more rapidly than the percentage agreed under UN frameworks does not, on its own, amount to a breach of its positive obligations. However, this shortfall becomes a significant factor in assessing compliance with Article 8 ECHR where a state also relies on internationally contested methods - such as grandfathering - to meet its mitigation commitments.
-
Implementation of climate measures:
Noting that there is a “less than 5% chance” of the State achieving its own emissions reduction target for 2030, the Court held that the absence of concrete measures aimed at achieving the reduction target for the period between 2030 and 2050 fails to meet the requirements for clearly defined and credible emissions‑reduction pathways covering the entire period up to the achievement of carbon neutrality. -
Emissions allowance:
In KlimaSeniorinnen, the ECtHR held that Member States must quantify future emissions limits, whether through a carbon budget or otherwise. The Court found that the State had not done so, and that it could not rely on the EU carbon budget as substitute. This is because – contrary to its UN obligations – the EU has not submitted a breakdown of emission budgets per Member States.
-
-
Adaptation measures:
The UN Framework Convention on Climate Change and other agreements, including the Paris Agreement, require Member States to draw up national programmes to facilitate adaptation to climate change. Specific adaptation targets were also agreed in 2023 in the United Arab Emirates Framework for Global Climate Resilience. These targets include, for example, requirements for states to (i) conduct up‑to‑date assessments of climate‑related impacts, risks, and vulnerabilities within their territory, and (ii) develop national adaptation plans, each to be completed by 2030.
The Court found that the State’s climate adaptation policy for Bonaire suffered from significant shortcomings in the past but concluded that recent governmental actions may still allow the adaptation targets to be achieved.2 The Court identified the following factors as relevant to its assessment:-
Climate adaptation plan: Although the State has repeatedly committed itself to protecting vulnerable areas and small islands – a factor which the Court found “influences the content of the duty of care that the State has towards its own citizens living on small islands” - there is currently no climate adaptation plan for Bonaire.
Under its international commitments, the State has until 2030 to develop such a plan, and the process initiated through the “Bonaire Climate Table project group” – which is tasked with proposed mitigation and adaptation measures for Bonaire – may be capable of delivering one. On this basis, the Court held that targets have not yet been breached.
-
Scientific research: The quality and completeness of scientific research available on the development of climate change around Bonaire, and the consequences this will have for its citizens, lags behind that available for the European Netherlands. However, Bonaire has now been included in research programmes to assess climate risks, which will improve the evidence base in future.
-
Funding: No funding has been provided for the adaptation-related nature policy that has been in place in the Caribbean since 2020.
-
State responsibility: The State cannot rely on the autonomous power of the Public Body of Bonaire to develop an adaptation plan. The Court emphasised that it is the State that is responsible for guaranteeing the fundamental rights of the inhabitants of Bonaire.
-
-
Procedural safeguards:
The judgment reinforces the importance of procedural safeguards when assessing whether the State has remained within its margin of appreciation when taking climate measures. These arise from Article 6 of the UN Climate Convention, which sets out obligations to develop and implement programmes aimed at public access to and participation in programmes addressing climate change.
The Court found that the Dutch State had failed to adequately inform Bonaire’s residents about the risks of inundation and heat stress or to provide a framework for public involvement in climate measures. Although measures to improve participation have been introduced since 2023, the Court held that the absence of a clear policy framework prevents citizens and civil society from holding the State to account.
3. Unequal treatment
The Court found that the State had treated the inhabitants of Bonaire differently to those in the European Netherlands when developing climate adaptation measures in circumstances where Bonaire “is at greater risk from climate change more quickly than the European Netherlands”. The State failed to adequately justify this difference in treatment, leading the Court to conclude that the State was in breach of Article 14 and Article 1 of Protocol No. 12 (a general prohibition of discrimination that constitutes an independent right).
4. Decision
The Court found that the State had failed to fulfil its positive obligations under Articles 8 and 14 of the ECHR and that these infringements breached Dutch tort law (Article 6.162 of the Dutch Civil Code). It ordered the State to:
-
Embed absolute economy-wide GHG emission reduction targets in national legislation within eighteen months including:
- Binding interim targets and reduction pathways for the entire period up to 2050.
- Quantifiable alignment with current UN standards, specifically at least a 43% reduction relative to 2019 levels by 2030.
- Comprehensive transparency regarding the national carbon budget on which implementation is based.
-
Draft a national adaptation plan that takes Bonaire into account, to be drafted and implemented by 2030.
The Court rejected Greenpeace’s requests for orders requiring the State to enact specific legislation, emphasising that such orders would infringe on the State’s margin of appreciation and risk interfering with political decision making. The Court confirmed it may compel the State to achieve a specific objective - in this case compliance with human rights and climate obligation - but it may not order it to adopt specific measures to achieve that objective.
The parties have three months to appeal the decision. The Court declared the judgment provisionally enforceable, meaning that the State must comply with the Court’s orders notwithstanding a potential appeal.
Significance and takeaways
The decision follows a line of landmark climate judgments, including the Dutch Supreme Court’s decision in Urgenda (analysed here) and the Grand Chamber of the ECtHR ruling in KlimaSeniorinnen, which established that states have positive obligations under Articles 2 (right to life) and 8 (right to respect for private and family life) of the ECHR to mitigate the impacts of climate change.
However, it also significantly develops these judgments in the following ways:
- The judgment clarifies the principles established in KlimaSeniorinnen regarding the burden of causation. It confirms that a causal link for the purpose of human rights protection is assumed once claimants demonstrate that a state has failed to comply with its climate change obligations. It is therefore incumbent on the State to show that no causal link exists between its conduct (or lack thereof) and the specific climate change consequences affecting individuals. Claimants, by contrast, can focus on demonstrating that the measures taken by states have failed to reasonably mitigate the effects of climate change. It should be noted that, although these principles remain largely untested in other jurisdictions, including England and Wales, they may influence climate litigation elsewhere in the future.
- The decision is one of the first to focus on the adequacy of a state’s adaptation measures, with European climate cases having previously focused on climate mitigation. The judgment also emphasises the link and overlap between adaptation and mitigation, with the Court holding that “the mitigation and adaptation measures cannot be assessed separately from each other”.
- The decision is also the first to rely on the 2025 ICJ Advisory Opinion as guidance to determine the mitigation and adaptation obligations on states. Drawing on the opinion, the Court clarified that these duties encompass both obligations of conduct and obligations of result. An obligation of conduct requires a state to act with "due diligence" by using all means at its disposal to achieve an objective, whereas an obligation of result mandates the achievement of a specific outcome. Crucially, the Court adopted the ICJ’s reasoning that adopting a policy as a "mere formality" is insufficient to discharge an obligation of result; rather, the measures taken must be demonstrably capable of reaching the required goal. On this basis, the Court ordered the State to take concrete steps to align its mitigation measures with international developments.
- The Bonaire judgment presents a novel application of the prohibition of discrimination to state adaptation policies. It is among the first judicial decisions to find that a state violates Article 14 of the ECHR and Article 1 of Protocol 12 by failing to protect a vulnerable overseas territory with the same urgency and systematic planning afforded to its mainland.
- While a matter of Dutch tort law, it is notable that the Court found that the State’s representations on climate change are relevant to defining the scope of its duty to protect citizens from its harmful effects. This approach – which is similar to that taken in cases against private entities where corporate liability was grounded in public commitments – is novel in a state context. It may mark a new development in tort law whereby states can be held liable for their public commitments.
The English translation of the judgment, dated 28 January 2026, can be found here.
With thanks to Frederico Branco for his assistance in preparing this briefing.