On 15 October 2026, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) delivered its judgment in NEO GROUP UAB (C-203/25).
The CJEU held that an EU Member State may deny the withholding tax exemption on dividends paid to a parent company in another EU Member State where the payment forms part of an abusive arrangement, even if that parent company carries out genuine economic activities and is not a mere conduit. In this case, the dividends were passed on through a multi-layered structure, which ultimately produced a tax saving for the ultimate individual shareholder.
Background
The case arose from a dispute involving the Lithuanian plastics manufacturer NEO GROUP UAB, which paid dividends in 2016 and 2017 to its Cypriot parent company, Retal Industries Ltd, and claimed that they were exempt from withholding tax. The Lithuanian tax authorities argued that the funds were then passed up a chain of transactions to an ultimate beneficial owner (UBO) ultimately to avoid tax.
The Core principle
Tax authorities seeking to deny a withholding tax exemption must prove that an abusive, non-genuine arrangement exists. To do so, they must assess all relevant facts and circumstances across the entire chain of transactions, not only the dividend distribution itself.
The CJEU clarified the anti-abuse rules in Article 1(2) and (3) of the Parent-Subsidiary Directive (PSD). The exemption can be denied even if the immediate EU parent company (here, in Cyprus) carries out genuine economic activities and is not a mere conduit. The judgment follows the May 21, 2026 opinion of Advocate General Juliane Kokott, who likewise considered that pass-through or multi-layered dividend structures can be abusive for the purposes of the PSD if they form part of an overall “non-genuine” arrangement.
Our conclusions
The judgment indicates that tax authorities will closely examine beneficial ownership and attributable substance when assessing withholding tax exemptions. Although the burden of proving abuse remains with the tax authorities, multinational groups should be ready to evidence the business rationale for each level of their group structure, as well as for each restructuring and intra-group financing transaction. Robust contracts and supporting documentation will be key.
We can expect continued focus from tax authorities on the commercial justification and substance of holding company structures. Please contact us if you would like to discuss how it may affect your group.