On 28 July 2026, the Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) handed down judgment in R v Osmond [2026] EWCA Crim 979 the first appellate decision on the tipping off offence in section 333A(3) of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (POCA). The judgment clarifies the scope of that offence and confirms important aspects of the forgery offence under the Forgery and Counterfeiting Act 1981 (the 1981 Act).

Background

William Osmond, a solicitor and senior partner at his own firm, acted for a client (James Ramsay) who financed the purchase of a Mayfair property through a British Virgin Islands company, Barrow Management Ltd (Barrow). The transaction came to the attention of the Serious Fraud Office (SFO) during one of their investigations relating to corruption, fraud, and money laundering. Mr Ramsay was not himself a suspect, but had links to a senior figure and suspect in the investigation, whose wife had purchased the Mayfair property using Barrow’s loan.

In June 2018, the SFO contacted Mr Osmond seeking information about his relationship with Mr Ramsay and documents relating to the property purchase, later issuing a formal Section 2 notice under the Criminal Justice Act 1987. The covering letter expressly warned of the tipping off offence. Despite this, Mr Osmond told Mr Ramsay about the SFO’s approach the next day and met him in Malta shortly thereafter. Mr Osmond also had numerous further communications with him over the following weeks. This meant the information Mr Osmond ultimately gave the SFO was shaped by those discussions rather than his own independent recollection. When the SFO also asked for a letter of engagement that Mr Osmond had never prepared, he provided a backdated version and provided it to the investigator, giving rise to the forgery charge.

Mr Osmond was convicted at the Central Criminal Court of tipping off (contrary to section 333A(3) of POCA) and forgery (contrary to section 1 of the 1981 Act), and sentenced to nine months’ imprisonment, suspended for 18 months. The Court of Appeal refused leave to appeal, holding that the trial judge’s pre-trial rulings were correct on all points.

The tipping off offence: three practical confirmations

The Court of Appeal's judgment settles three points of practical significance for businesses and their advisers:

Whether or not the wider investigation is public is not determinative. The defence argued that because the broader SFO investigation was already public knowledge, Mr Osmond's communications with Mr Ramsay could not amount to a "disclosure" under section 333A(3). The Court disagreed: an investigation can be the subject of a disclosure for the purposes of section 333A(3) even where it forms part of, or a strand within, a wider investigation. In practice, it is not safe to discuss a specific, non-public investigative thread merely because the overarching investigation is public knowledge.

What matters is the capacity in which information is received, not its source. The defence argued that because the information came from the SFO itself (received by Mr Osmond as Mr Ramsay’s solicitor rather than in the course of regulated business) it fell outside the offence. The Court rejected this, holding that section 333A(3)(c) is aimed precisely at this scenario, focusing on the capacity in which the professional receives the information, not from where it originates.

Likely prejudice is enough - actual prejudice need not be proved. The prosecution need only show that disclosure was, at the time it was made, likely to prejudice the investigation; it need not prove, nor is it a defence to show, that no prejudice in fact resulted. The Court noted that disclosing an investigation to its target is inherently likely to cause prejudice, given the risk that evidence may be destroyed or the individual may seek to evade justice. In practice, professionals should treat any live investigation as sensitive by default, rather than waiting to assess whether real harm has occurred.

The forgery offence: a practical reminder for fraud cases

Faced with a request for an engagement letter he did not have, Mr Osmond provided a backdated version and provided it to the SFO investigator. The forgery offence requires an intention to induce the recipient to accept the instrument as genuine and thereby act to the recipient or someone else’s prejudice, which arises where the instrument is accepted as genuine in connection with the recipient’s performance of a duty (whether such a duty exists being a question of law). Mr Osmond argued that the SFO investigator was not performing a “duty” because the SFO has only a power, not a duty, to investigate.

The Court rejected that argument, holding that deceiving, or attempting to deceive, a public official carrying out a criminal investigation is necessarily connected to the performance of a duty (owed both to the employer and to the public) regardless of whether the underlying power to investigate is discretionary. Once an investigation is commenced, those conducting it perform a public function and are duty-bound to do so lawfully and in accordance with their employer’s instructions. In practice, this expansive reading of “duty” means that providing false documents to an investigator may satisfy the forgery offence’s prejudice element, whatever the source of the investigator’s authority to investigate.

Practical takeaways

  • The tipping off offence has broad reach, and public knowledge of a wider investigation is no shield. Anyone who receives investigation-related information in the course of a regulated business must not disclose it to clients or others where disclosure is likely to prejudice the investigation. Even where the wider investigation is well-publicised, disclosing non-public details of a specific investigative line / strand of the investigation is still caught.
  • What triggers the offence is the capacity in which you receive information, not its source. A Section 2 notice or a phone call from the SFO seeking further information about a money laundering investigation, received in your capacity as a regulated professional, is enough to engage the offence.
  • Review your procedures for handling regulatory and law enforcement enquiries. Staff who receive such approaches should understand their obligations and seek legal advice before communicating with clients about them.
  • Never fabricate documents. Providing false documents to an investigator may trigger the forgery offence and other regulatory issues, even where the investigator has a power, and not a duty, to investigate.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post