In Moorwand Ltd v Hamblin [2026] EWCA Civ 942, the Court of Appeal considered when a payment services provider will be "put on enquiry" for the purposes of the Quincecare duty in the context of authorised push payment (APP) fraud. Allowing Moorwand Ltd's appeal, the Court reinstated the trial judge's finding that, despite shortcomings in Moorwand's onboarding and anti-money laundering processes, there was insufficient evidence to establish that Moorwand ought to have recognised the payment instructions on the account as an attempt to misappropriate customer funds.

The decision highlights both the limits of the Quincecare duty and the difficulty of overturning a trial judge's evaluative assessment on appeal. The decision is also of interest because the claim was structured as a derivative action. This structure was not challenged on appeal and may provide a route for claimants to expand Quincecare claims, although the Court of Appeal identified a number of outstanding questions that need to be resolved in future cases.

Background

Mr and Mrs Hamblin (the Hamblins) were induced to transfer £160,000 as part of an APP fraud. The funds were paid into an account held with Moorwand Ltd (Moorwand), an FCA-regulated Electronic Money Institution, in the name of RND Global Ltd (RND). RND had been incorporated by fraudsters using the stolen identity of an innocent third party, Mr Stanfield, who had no involvement in the company. The funds were subsequently dissipated, including through purchases of bitcoin and luxury watches.

The Hamblins brought a derivative claim on behalf of RND against Moorwand. This form of derivative action allows the beneficiary under a trust to proceed in the name of the trustee where the trustee is unable or unwilling to take action themselves. Here, the High Court found that the £160,000 was held by RND as constructive trustee in favour of the Hamblins as beneficiaries.  The Hamblins alleged in their derivative action that Moorwand had breached its Quincecare duty to RND, namely the duty to refrain from executing payment instructions from an agent of a customer without first making enquiries where it has reasonable grounds for believing that the instructions are an attempt to misappropriate its customer's funds. Following the Supreme Court's decision in Philipp v Barclays Bank UK plc [2023] UKSC 25, which confirmed that the duty does not arise where a customer personally authorises a payment, the derivative claim provided an alternative route by relying on RND's own Quincecare rights against its payment services provider.

The trial judge accepted that the Hamblins could pursue the claim derivatively but concluded that Moorwand had not been put on enquiry and therefore had not breached its duty. The High Court overturned that decision on appeal and ordered Moorwand to re-credit the account. Moorwand then appealed to the Court of Appeal.

The appeal

The central issue was whether the High Court had been entitled to interfere with the trial judge's conclusion that Moorwand had not been put on enquiry that the payment instructions were being used to misappropriate RND's funds. The Court of Appeal held that it had not; the trial judge had not made the errors of law identified by the High Court and the high threshold for revisiting the trial judge’s evaluative findings had not been met.

The Court of Appeal rejected Moorwand's argument that the Hamblins' case was confined to whether the real Mr Stanfield had authorised the transactions. Instead, it held that the Hamblins had pleaded a broader case, namely that Moorwand should have recognised from the onboarding information and operation of the account that it was not being used for legitimate business purposes.

Turning to the substance of the appeal, the Court emphasised that regulatory failings and Quincecare liability are distinct questions. While the facts underpinning regulatory shortcomings may be relevant to whether a provider was put on enquiry, the existence of regulatory failings does not, as of itself, establish a breach of the Quincecare duty. The relevant question remained whether the information available to Moorwand gave it reasonable grounds for believing there was an attempted misappropriation of the customer’s funds.

In reaching that conclusion, the Court of Appeal placed considerable weight on the trial judge's assessment of the evidence, including the evidence of the single joint expert, who considered that, despite deficiencies in Moorwand's onboarding and compliance processes, there was no reason to suspect an attempted misappropriation of funds. The trial judge had been entitled to accept that evidence.

The Court of Appeal also rejected the High Court's conclusion that the trial judge had treated regulatory failings as irrelevant. Properly understood, the trial judge had recognised those failings but concluded that they did not justify the inference that Moorwand should have suspected misappropriation. That evaluative assessment was open to him on the evidence and should not have been disturbed on appeal.

Key takeaways

  • Regulatory failings and Quincecare liability are distinct concepts. Although the same underlying facts may be relevant to both, deficient onboarding processes or anti-money laundering systems will not, of themselves, establish a breach of the Quincecare duty. The focus remains on whether there were reasonable grounds to suspect misappropriation of the customer’s funds. However, this should not be read as suggesting that such deficiencies are without consequence.

  • Appeal courts will be slow to interfere with evaluative findings. Considerable weight will be given to a trial judge’s assessment of whether a provider was put on enquiry, and the high threshold for appellate intervention applies.

  • Causation may not be required for account restoration claims. Following Philipp, where the claim is for restoration of the account balance rather than consequential damages, the claimant need not prove that enquiries would have revealed the fraud.

  • Inadequate onboarding and anti-money laundering processes carry risks beyond civil liability. Even where deficiencies do not give rise to a Quincecare breach, they may attract FCA scrutiny, regulatory sanctions, and reputational damage.

  • Derivative claims remain a potentially viable route for APP fraud victims. The derivative mechanism (based here on a finding of constructive trust) was not challenged on appeal and it may enable some victims of APP fraud to avoid the limitations on the Quincecare duty. The Court of Appeal noted that it could also offer victims a better outcome than a direct tort claim by avoiding contributory negligence defences (as the claimant’s own conduct is irrelevant to the company’s claim in debt) and not requiring proof that the bank knew that it had received trust assets.

  • Important questions remain unresolved. The Court identified a number of issues which may require consideration in future cases involving the Quincecare duty and derivative actions:

    • Automated payment processing: whether the Quincecare duty applies where transfer instructions are processed without human intervention;
    • Fraud vehicle companies: whether directors of a company established solely for fraud lack actual authority to give transfer instructions; and
    • Contractual warranty defences: whether a bank can rely on breach of customer warranties as to the legitimacy of its business as a defence to such a claim, and whether the fraudster’s knowledge is attributable to the company.

With thanks to Humza Nadeem for his assistance in preparing this post.

Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post