In Federal Government of Nigeria & Anor v Williams [2025] EWHC 2217 (Comm), the Commercial Court granted a rare anti-enforcement injunction (AEI) to restrain the enforcement of an English court judgment in the United States on the basis that the judgment had allegedly been obtained by fraud. This is thought to be the first AEI granted by an English court to restrain enforcement of an English judgment abroad (as opposed to restraining enforcement of a foreign court judgment). The case highlights the Court’s willingness to intervene in order to protect the integrity of its own processes.
Background
- This case involved a dispute between the Federal Government of Nigeria (FGN) and Dr Williams, during which Dr Williams obtained default judgment in England for appoximately US$14.9 million against both the Federal Government of Nigeria and its Attorney General.
- FGN sought to set aside this judgment in the English courts, alleging it was obtained dishonestly and based on forged documents. However, in the meantime, Dr Williams had commenced proceedings in the US District Court (Southern District of New York) to enforce this judgment against FGN, the Attorney General, the Central Bank of Nigeria and others.
- FGN responded to the US enforcement proceedings with a defence on similar grounds (of fraud and dishonesty) and sovereign immunity. The US court rejected this defence but did stay further proceedings pending the English court’s decision on whether the default judgment should be set aside.
- FGN applied to the English court for an AEI to restrain the US enforcement proceedings.
The decision
The Judge encapsulated the central issue when he stated, “the court here is being invited to grant an injunction designed to protect the integrity of the English court’s own processes, and to prevent a risk of its own judgment from being used as an instrument of fraud.”
The Judge granted the AEI, restraining Dr Williams from enforcing the English judgment until the fraud claim was resolved or a further order was made.
Jurisdiction to grant AEI
The Court confirmed it has jurisdiction under section 37(1) of the Senior Courts Act 1981 to grant an AEI, even where the injunction restrains enforcement of an English judgment outside England.
The Court relied on Google v Tsargrad [2025] EWHC 94 (Comm) as authority that an AEI is not an order against the foreign court, but rather operates in personam and thus is directed at the party.
While this case “was squarely based on alleged fraud”, the Judge held that jurisdiction to grant an AEI was not only limited to cases involving actual or alleged fraud.
Applicable test
The Judge clarified that, where AEIs are sought, applicants must demonstrate a “high probability” that they would succeed in obtaining a final injunction at trial (citing Joint Stock Asset Management Company Ingosstrakh Investments v BNP Paribas SA [2012] EWCA Civ 644), rather than merely showing a “serious issue to be tried”. The Court found that the claimants had a strong prima facie case of fraud and a compelling case that for Dr Williams to enforce the judgment before the fraud proceedings would be “vexatious and oppressive”. The Judge concluded that it was highly likely that the claimants would succeed at a trial in establishing that an AEI should be granted.
The balance of justice
The Court weighed the risk of irreparable harm to FGN if enforcement proceeded before the fraud claim was resolved, against the risk of prejudice to Dr Williams. Although Dr Williams cited age and poor health, the Court found that any delay in enforcement was outweighed by the strength of the fraud claim and the public interest in preventing misuse of the court’s processes. In addition, he could be compensated under the cross-undertaking in damages given by the claimants.
Protection of the Court’s process
The Court noted that AEIs are rarely granted and usually inappropriate, due to concerns around delay and comity (which requires courts to respect and enforce the decisions of other courts). Here the case was sufficiently compelling that the AEI was necessary in order to uphold the integrity of the English court’s process.
Any potential concerns about the AEI and comity were ameliorated given the US court had already stayed proceedings in anticipation of the English decision, demonstrating comity between the jurisdictions.
Key takeaways
This case confirms that AEIs are available under English law, but will only be granted in compelling circumstances. The judgment clarifies that AEIs are not limited to cases involving a breach of jurisdiction clause or actual fraud. Alleged fraud, particularly where it threatens the integrity of the court’s own processes, may also justify relief. The court emphasised its cautious approach to interfering with foreign proceedings, but made clear it will act where necessary to prevent misuse of its judgments.
The decision reinforces the English courts’ willingness to intervene even where enforcement is sought abroad. Parties seeking to enforce English judgments in foreign jurisdictions should be aware that enforcement may be restrained if the judgment is challenged on credible grounds.
For those wanting to challenge enforcement of suspect judgments, timing and evidence are critical. Prompt action and a well-supported application can be decisive. Both sovereign entities and commercial parties can take comfort in the English court’s readiness to safeguard its processes.
With thanks to Humza Nadeem for his assistance in preparing this post.