In Chubb Bermuda Insurance Ltd v Fertitta Entertainment Inc & Ors [2026] EWHC 1392 (Comm), the English court granted a final anti-suit injunction (ASI) to enforce a London-seated, English law arbitration agreement contained in an insurance policy, and awarded the claimant insurer damages for breach of the agreement.

The decision reaffirms that English courts will enforce arbitration agreements governed by English law even where mandatory foreign laws may prohibit arbitration.

The decision also illustrates the potential financial consequences of a party seeking to litigate in a preferred jurisdiction in breach of an arbitration agreement – here, the claimant was awarded significant damages in respect of the legal costs it incurred in resisting US court proceedings.

Background

The Claimant, Chubb Bermuda Insurance Ltd, issued a property insurance policy (the Policy) to the Defendants (associated US companies in the hospitality sector).

The Policy was governed by New York law, but where New York law did not apply, by English law. The Policy also contained an arbitration agreement, governed by English law, which provided that any dispute was to be “fully and finally determined in London, England under the provisions of the Arbitration Act 1996” and “All matters relating to the existence of the agreement to arbitrate and the selection of arbitrators shall be determined under the law of England and Wales” (the Arbitration Agreement).

The Policy also expressly deleted a service of suit clause in the precedent Policy Form, which would otherwise have provided for the Claimant to submit to a US court’s jurisdiction.

The Louisiana proceedings and the interim ASI proceedings

In summary, the Claimant sought to resist the Defendants’ attempts to join it to proceedings in the Louisiana courts on the basis that the dispute fell within the Arbitration Agreement. The procedural history was as follows:

  1. In July 2020, several Defendants sued excess insurers, including the Claimant, in Louisiana for alleged COVID-19 business interruption losses. This was dismissed without prejudice.
  2. Later that month, the Defendants claimed against several insurers, including the Claimant, in different divisions of the Louisiana courts, alleging physical loss, damage and denial of coverage (the Second Louisiana Proceedings).
  3. The Claimant obtained an interim ASI in the English courts restraining the Defendants from pursuing the Second Louisiana Proceedings so far as they concerned the Policy. After settlement discussions failed, the Claimant sought a final ASI and damages for breach of the Arbitration Agreement from the English court. The Defendants challenged the English court’s jurisdiction and applied to set aside the interim ASI. The current decision deals with this claim and application.
  4. Meanwhile, despite agreeing to await the English court’s decision, the Defendants obtained a temporary restraining order in Louisiana to prevent the Claimant pursuing its action in the English court or any arbitration under the Policy.
  5. The Defendants then obtained a preliminary injunction in the Louisiana courts (the Louisiana Injunction) further restraining proceedings in the English courts, arguing that the only link to England – the Arbitration Agreement – was void under Louisiana law.
  6. The US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit allowed the Claimants’ appeal against the Louisiana Injunction and dismissed the case against the Claimant for lack of personal jurisdiction.
  7. In February 2026, the Defendants began fresh proceedings in Louisiana, contending that the Arbitration Agreement was invalid under Louisiana law and that the Claimant had waived its right to invoke the Arbitration Agreement by choosing to litigate in a non-arbitral forum, the English court. These proceedings were dismissed in April 2026, and the Defendants appealed in May 2026.

The English court’s decision

The Defendants’ jurisdictional challenge

The Defendants challenged the jurisdiction of the English courts on three grounds:

  1. The Arbitration Agreement was invalid under Louisiana law.
  2. There was no connection to England and the Defendants had not submitted to the jurisdiction of the English court.
  3. Louisiana was the most suitable forum.

The Judge noted that the key question was whether the Arbitration Agreement was valid; if so, grounds 2 and 3 did not matter. By agreeing to London-seated arbitration, the parties had agreed to the supervisory jurisdiction of the English court under the Arbitration Act 1996. A further connection to England beyond the Arbitration Agreement was not needed. Further, it was not open to the Defendants to contend that the Louisiana Court was the more suitable forum.

In challenging the validity of the Arbitration Agreement, the Defendants relied on a Louisiana statutory provision which prohibited arbitration clauses in insurance policies. However, the Court held that the Arbitration Agreement was governed by English law; the clause stated that all matters relating to the existence of the agreement to arbitrate shall be determined under the laws of England and Wales. Questions of validity therefore fell to be determined by English law, and Louisiana’s statutory provisions were irrelevant. The Defendants’ application to challenge the jurisdiction of the English courts had been based on a false premise, i.e. that the Arbitration Agreement was invalid under Louisiana law.

The Claimant’s application for a final ASI

The Court granted the final ASI. The Court was satisfied there was a valid arbitration agreement which extended to all matters the Defendants sought to litigate in Louisiana. The Judge noted that in such circumstances, the Court will ordinarily exercise its discretion to restrain proceedings brought in breach of an arbitration agreement, unless the defendant can show strong reasons to refuse the relief. The only reason advanced by the Defendants was that the disputes were more closely connected with Louisiana. The Court held this was not a sufficient reason – arbitration clauses are often agreed precisely because parties have chosen a neutral forum, so giving overriding weight to forum conveniens arguments would defeat the parties’ intention. The ASI granted included a mandatory injunction requiring the Defendants to procure dismissal of the ongoing Louisiana proceedings – the Judge considered this a necessary corollary of the obligation not to litigate outside the arbitral forum.

Damages for breach of the Arbitration Agreement

The Court awarded the Claimant damages for breach of the Arbitration Agreement comprising the Claimants’ legal costs of resisting the Second Louisiana Proceedings, and awarded an indemnity for future US legal costs. The Claimant was also awarded its costs of the English proceedings on an indemnity basis.

Key takeaways

This decision reinforces that where an arbitration agreement is governed by English law, foreign mandatory rules prohibiting arbitration will not prevent the English court from enforcing the arbitration agreement. The judgment is a neat reminder that when asked to uphold an arbitration agreement, English courts will give primacy to the parties’ contractual choice of forum over arguments about the most appropriate forum. Parties should therefore consider which forum is most appropriate at the drafting stage, not once a dispute arises.

Furthermore, parties should consider the governing law of the arbitration agreement at the time of drafting. The doctrine of separability provides that an arbitration agreement’s validity is tested under its own governing law. Where that law is not expressly stated, there is room for a counterparty to rely on a foreign law that is hostile to arbitration. An express choice of governing law within the arbitration agreement gives certainty about which law decides its validity, and may prove decisive when the clause is challenged.

Finally, the judgment shows that the consequences of breaching an arbitration agreement may not only be an award of damages for breach, but also expensive and protracted proceedings in multiple jurisdictions even before the underlying substantive dispute is considered.

With thanks to Lucy Reynolds for her assistance in preparing this post.

Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post