The Court of Appeal of the Unified Patent Court (UPC) has, for the first time, referred several fundamental questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) concerning the international jurisdiction of the UPC and the patent law liability of so called product compliance authorised representatives. The reference is of considerable significance for the territorial scope of patent enforcement in Europe, the allocation of liability risks along regulatory supply chains, and, consequently, for the strategic conduct of patent litigation in Europe.

Background

The reference to the CJEU arises in the context of a series of recent decisions by European patent courts concerning so called “long arm jurisdiction”, under which courts have assumed jurisdiction beyond the limits of strictly national or contractually defined territories.

As early as the beginning of 2025, the CJEU in BSH Hausgeräte v Electrolux (Case C 339/22) recognised that national courts in the defendant’s domicile retain jurisdiction over cross border patent infringement actions, even where the validity of the national parts of the patent at issue – including those of third countries – is raised as a defence in the infringement proceedings, as the exclusive jurisdiction under Article 24(4) of Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 (Brussels Ia Regulation) must be interpreted narrowly. Decisions of the local divisions of the UPC similarly indicate an increasing willingness, at least in principle, to adjudicate rights extending beyond their core territorial jurisdiction.

Facts

The proceedings originate from an application for a preliminary injunction before the Hamburg Local Division. The applicant alleges infringement of European Patent EP 3 119 235, which relates to a portable hair care device. The contested products are hairdryers marketed via various European websites operated by a Chinese manufacturer.

In addition to the manufacturer, the other defendant is a company established in Germany in its capacity as an “EU authorised representative for product safety”, which does not itself offer infringing products.

By way of interim relief, the Hamburg Local Division ordered the defendants to cease and desist throughout the territory of the UPC. Furthermore, it ordered the Chinese manufacturer to cease and desist from the contested acts in Spain, although Spain is not a contracting member state of the UPC. The defendants lodged an appeal against that decision.

The Court of Appeal of the UPC (Cases UPC_CoA_789/2025, UPC_CoA_813/2025) suspended the preliminary injunction entirely in respect of the German authorised representative and, in respect of the Chinese manufacturer, insofar as it concerned Spain. At the same time, the Court seized the opportunity to refer several questions to the CJEU for a preliminary ruling on fundamental issues of EU law.

The reference focuses, first, on the as yet unresolved question of the extent of the international jurisdiction of the UPC, in particular where alleged acts of infringement occur in EU Member States that have not acceded to the UPC regime. Secondly, it raises the issue of liability, namely whether companies acting solely as EU based authorised representatives may be held liable under patent law, despite neither manufacturing nor distributing the contested products.

Overview of the questions referred

Jurisdiction in respect of non‑UPC states (Questions 1 to 3)

The international jurisdiction of the UPC is governed by the Brussels Ia Regulation. As a general rule, actions must be brought before the courts of the Member State in which the defendant is domiciled. In cases involving multiple defendants, the so called “anchor defendant” principle under Article 8(1) of the Brussels Ia Regulation may permit all defendants to be sued before a single court, provided that the claims are so closely connected that it is expedient to hear and determine them together to avoid the risk of irreconcilable judgments.

In the context of interim relief, there is the additional feature that courts with Union wide jurisdiction, such as the UPC, may act even where the defendant is not domiciled within the EU, provided that there is a sufficient connecting factor (Article 71b(2) Brussels Ia Regulation).

Against this background, the Court of Appeal seeks clarification as to whether these principles allow the jurisdiction of the UPC to be extended to acts of patent infringement in non UPC contracting states – here, Spain. In particular, it asks whether such jurisdiction may be based on the anchor defendant rule and whether the German authorised representative can serve as such an anchor defendant.

The Court further raises the question whether, in proceedings for interim relief, the UPC may assume jurisdiction where the alleged infringing acts occur outside the UPC territory - but within the EU - while the contested products are offered throughout the Union via largely identical websites (differing essentially only in language).

In addition, the Court seeks clarification as to whether the fact that a manufacturer established outside the EU makes use of the services of an authorised representative established within the EU - here, the defendant German company - is relevant for the purposes of jurisdiction.

Liability of the product safety authorised representative (Question 4)

The fourth question concerns a particularly sensitive issue of liability in practice.

Manufacturers from third countries are required under the EU Product Safety Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2023/988) and the EU Market Surveillance Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2019/1020) to designate, for certain products, an economic operator established within the EU. This may take the form of an authorised representative responsible for compliance with product safety obligations and serving as a point of contact for market surveillance authorities, without assuming responsibility for the marketing or distribution of the products.

The CJEU is now called upon to determine whether a preliminary injunction for patent infringement may be issued against such an authorised representative who performs exclusively tasks under the EU Product Safety Regulation and the EU Market Surveillance Regulation. At its core, the CJEU must decide whether such an authorised representative constitutes an intermediary liable under patent law.

Implications for businesses

The CJEU’s decision is likely to have a significant impact on the strategy of future patent infringement litigation. Should the CJEU answer the jurisdictional questions in the affirmative, patentees may be able to consolidate proceedings to a greater extent. In particular, interim relief could be deployed more strategically, and disputes outside the UPC territory could be pursued efficiently before a single court. Such centralisation would further enhance the attractiveness of the UPC as a forum for enforcement.

Moreover, the mere designation of an authorised representative solely responsible for product safety could serve as a connecting factor for establishing jurisdiction before a single court. This would be of considerable importance, as market participants from third countries are frequently required to designate such a representative when operating within the EU internal market, particularly where no importer or distributor within the Union exists.

Finally, manufacturers from third countries could thereby be exposed to a consistently available jurisdiction under EU law, irrespective of whether the authorised representative has any influence over manufacturing, offering, or distribution. At the same time, recognising patent law liability of product compliance authorised representatives would entail significant additional risks for such entities. Given that third country manufacturers are typically required under EU product safety law to appoint such representatives, these may in future function as a de facto jurisdictional anchor for patent litigation.

Final observations

The CJEU’s decision is expected to have a lasting influence on the strategic conduct of patent litigation within the European Union. Irrespective of the outcome of the reference, it is already apparent that companies - particularly those operating global supply and distribution chains - should reassess their compliance models, their role within European value chains, and their procedural risk exposure in light of the potential developments.

Contact