The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) issued its long-awaited final rule, effective April 3, 2026, ushering in changes to Medicaid provider taxes and closing a “loophole” in the provider tax waiver process that CMS estimates totals approximately US$20.5 billion annually (Final Rule). According to CMS, seven states have “existing loophole waivers” that disproportionately tax Medicaid providers and managed care organizations (MCOs) and “effectively reimburse these entities” in violation of Medicaid’s hold harmless requirement under 42 U.S.C. § 1396b(w)(4). As noted in the preamble to the Final Rule, CMS has already notified the affected states of these violations.
Provider taxes
A large majority of states fund a portion of their state share of Medicaid matching dollars through valid mechanisms under the Medicaid statute that allow for taxing healthcare providers. Under federal law, states may impose provider taxes that are both “broad-based” (all providers are taxed) and “uniform” (providers are taxed at the same rate).
Section 1903(w)(3)(E) of the Social Security Act authorizes CMS to approve a waiver of the broad-based and/or uniformity requirements when the state demonstrates that:
- The net impact of the tax and related expenditures is “generally redistributive” across both Medicaid and non-Medicaid providers that pay the tax.
- The amount of the tax is not directly correlated to Medicaid payments for the items and services for which the tax is imposed.
Additionally, providers may not be “held harmless” through any direct or indirect guarantee that they will be repaid for all or part of the taxes they pay. The “hold harmless” provision has drawn significant attention in recent years, and several Medicaid Bulletins and regulations addressing them have been the subject of significant litigation. The statistical analysis underlying the broad-based and uniformity requirements is the specific focus of this Final Rule.
States seeking broad-based and uniformity waivers must demonstrate that provider tax structures are generally redistributive under a “P1/P2” statistical test (for broad-based waivers) and a B1/B2 statistical test (for uniformity waivers).
Increased scrutiny of “generally redistributive” tax structures
CMS and Congress have begun to scrutinize whether certain states have provider taxes that are truly “generally redistributive.” Section 71117 of the Working Families Tax Cut Legislation (Pub. L. 119-21, also known as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act), CMS guidance and the Final Rule all limit the ability for states to shift Medicaid’s non-federal share onto entities with a high percentage of Medicaid business. CMS has focused on states that “have attempted to impose [provider] taxes using variable rates or provider exclusions to increase the tax burden” on Medicaid providers and MCOs, which affects the B1/B2 test.
In the Final Rule, CMS highlights examples of states taxing Medicaid business at US$300 per member per month while taxing non-Medicaid business at only US$3 per member per month. CMS interprets these differential tax structures as effectively, and unlawfully, increasing the federal share.
By adding 42 CFR § 433.68(e)(3)(i), (ii) and (iii), the Final Rule sets out attributes that disqualify a tax from being “generally redistributive,” even if it would otherwise satisfy the P1/P2 and B1/B2 tests.
The updated regulations:
- Prohibit states from taxing Medicaid businesses at higher rates than comparable non-Medicaid businesses.
- Prevent states from using proxy, vague or ambiguous language to impose higher effective tax rates on non-Medicaid businesses.
- Maintain the existing P1/P2 and B1/B2 statistical tests and add an independent generally‑redistributive requirement at § 433.68(e)(3) that can bar approval even if those tests are met.
Transition timelines and enforcement
In the Final Rule, CMS highlights its authority to “reduce a State’s medical assistance expenditures, prior to calculating [Federal financial participation], by the sum of any revenues from health-care related taxes that do not meet the requirements under section 1903(w) of the [Social Security] Act.”
The Final Rule details a three-year transition timeline for compliance:
- For taxes on MCO services with waivers approved within two years of April 3, 2026 – through the end of calendar year 2026.
- For taxes on MCO services with waiver approvals two years or more before April 3, 2026 – through the end of the state’s fiscal year 2027.
- For taxes on other permissible classes – through the end of the state’s fiscal year 2028.
Implications for healthcare providers
Healthcare providers should carefully review their state’s Medicaid waivers and directed payment provider tax programs to assess whether they may be vulnerable to an adverse interpretation under the Final Rule. It also reflects the agency’s increasing scrutiny and tightening of the bounds of provider taxes and state directed payments, a trend we have highlighted in prior client alerts, "Medicaid Managed Care Final Rule: Long-awaited pronouncement on permitted uses of state directed payments" and "The budget reconciliation bill reshapes US healthcare." These changes will unquestionably lead to reduced federal Medicaid funds to state Medicaid programs.
Our team of experienced lawyers and professionals at Norton Rose Fulbright closely watch the development of new Medicaid regulations. If you have any questions related to Medicaid state directed payment provider tax programs, please do not hesitate to contact us.