Variable annuities have long been a regulatory flashpoint (for both federal and state regulators), but recent enforcement activity sends an unmistakable signal: FINRA is backing up its words with significant fines and restitution orders.

Since late 2025, FINRA has settled with four broker-dealers and two individual representatives, imposing fines, suspensions and customer restitution for supervisory and suitability failures in their variable annuity (VA) businesses. Further, both the SEC’s Fiscal Year 2026 Examination Priorities and FINRA’s December 2025 Annual Regulatory Oversight Report single out variable annuity exchanges and sales practices, and Reg BI compliance, as key focus areas. The message is clear: if your supervisory systems are not purpose-built for annuity transactions, enforcement risk is not hypothetical—it is indeed quite possible.

FINRA matter No. 1 – April 2, 2026

On April 2, 2026, FINRA accepted an AWC settling allegations that between January 2015 and December 2018, Ameriprise Financial Services, LLC failed to maintain a supervisory system—including written supervisory procedures (WSPs)—reasonably designed to supervise variable annuity exchanges involving Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit (GLWB) riders. These riders guarantee annual withdrawals for the customer’s lifetime once a certain age is attained, for an additional fee. FINRA found the firm did not give registered principals sufficient guidance for evaluating whether customers would benefit from a newer rider’s growth credit feature enough to justify the higher fees over the life of the contract. FINRA found that: 114 customers were exchanging their legacy VAs into more expensive VAs with a GLWB rider, when they were already eligible to begin lifetime withdrawals, at an average incremental cost of US$8,718.86 per customer. Ameriprise was censured, fined US$450,000 and ordered to pay US$993,950.47 in restitution.

FINRA matter No. 2 – April 1, 2026

On April 1, 2026, FINRA accepted an AWC settling charges that from at least January 2018 to February 2025, an independent broker-dealer lacked an appropriate system to surveil its representatives’ VA exchange rates. This matter focused on the activities of a single representative. The AWC stated that the firm’s WSPs lacked appropriate procedures to identify “inappropriate exchanges” under FINRA Rule 2330(d), and appropriate corrective-measures were not taken. As a result, FINRA found that, with respect to this single representative, the firm failed to detect 22 inappropriate exchanges, causing 14 customers to incur US$129,938.79 in surrender fees. The firm was censured, fined US$150,000 and ordered to pay restitution of US$129,938.79 plus interest. The AWC explicitly recited that the firm revised its WSPs in February 2025 to implement surveillance procedures and enhanced supervision for VA surrenders.

FINRA matter No. 3 – October 31, 2025

FINRA’s recent enforcement efforts have not been limited to large firms. On October 31, 2025, FINRA accepted an AWC with Supreme Alliance LLC, a Charlotte, North Carolina-based firm with roughly 40 registered representatives. FINRA found that, between September 2019 and May 2022, the firm failed to maintain WSPs reasonably designed to supervise variable annuity purchases and exchanges. In particular, its WSPs lacked: (1) Reg BI provisions from June 30, 2020 through April 25, 2022, and (2) surveillance procedures to flag inappropriate exchange rates. Further, the firm failed to document principal review of multiple variable annuity applications as required by FINRA Rule 2330(c). Supreme Alliance was censured and fined US$80,000. This was the firm’s second FINRA action on annuity issues—it had entered into a prior AWC in February 2018 for related annuity supervisory failures.

FINRA matter No. 4 – November 13, 2025

On November 13, 2025, FINRA accepted an AWC from Oakwood Capital Securities, Inc. (formerly Gardner Financial Services, Inc.), a firm with approximately 80 registered representatives. This matter also related largely to the actions of a single representative, and while the firm operated under a predecessor name and management structure. The underlying facts are quite dated: between October 2019 and December 2020, Oakwood’s had a general surveillance requirement for VAs, the firm relied on a manual, transaction-by-transaction, review of VAs. The most problematic part was that the firm conducted no particularized monitoring of VA exchange rates over time. As a result, the firm failed to detect a series of short-term variable annuity exchanges, including multiple unsuitable transactions, by one of its representatives. Oakwood was censured and fined US$20,000.

Key takeaways

These recent FINRA settlements underscore a renewed regulatory focus on VA sales practices, and provide several critical lessons.

First

Reg BI and FINRA Rule 2330 impose overlapping but with certain distinct supervisory obligations on VA recommendations—and both the SEC and FINRA are actively looking for deficiencies. The SEC’s FY2026 Examination Priorities explicitly identifies variable and registered index-linked annuities as products of particular focus, and FINRA’s Annual Regulatory Oversight Report devotes an entire section to annuity-related findings.

Second

VA surveillance is not optional. To the contrary, FINRA Rule 2330(d) explicitly requires firms to implement procedures to identify inappropriate VA exchange rates. All four firms referenced above were cited with varying failures in this area.

Third

Although the underlying facts in certain of these matters are quite dated, FINRA nevertheless brought a formal enforcement case. Consequently, firms should not assume that historical supervisory gaps and dated VA transactions are beyond a regulator’s gaze.

Fourth and finally

Now is the time to act. Broker-dealers should review and strengthen their WSPs, surveillance tools, exchange-rate monitoring and registered principal guidance before regulators come knocking.

Practical steps for in-house counsel and compliance officers

In light of these enforcement actions and separate regulatory pronouncements, in-house counsel and compliance teams should consider the following steps to mitigate risk:

  • Audit your WSPs for variable annuity-specific provisions. Confirm that your written supervisory procedures address FINRA Rule 2330 requirements separately and explicitly—including principal review and approval, documentation standards and suitability determinations for purchases and exchanges. Ensure your WSPs also reflect Reg BI’s best-interest standard for any conduct postdating June 30, 2020.
  • Implement or upgrade exchange-rate surveillance. Deploy automated tools or exception reports to monitor representatives’ rates of variable annuity exchanges over time. Transaction-by-transaction review alone is insufficient—FINRA expects systemic surveillance that can flag patterns of potentially inappropriate exchanges.
  • Obtain an understanding of any concentration of any unique types of VAs among: (1) representatives, (2) branches or (3) geographic areas. For instance, this could include isolating GLWB rider transactions to a particular branch or part of the country. Above all, any representative who use a “one size fits all” approach to VA transactions and sales practices should be identified.
  • Develop clear guidance for registered principals on rider comparisons. Provide principals with specific criteria for evaluating whether an exchange involving living benefit riders is in the customer’s best interest.
  • Establish corrective-action policies for inappropriate exchanges. Your procedures should specify escalation steps when surveillance detects potential issues—including mandatory retraining, heightened supervision and disciplinary measures for repeat offenders.

Contact