Bloomberg is reporting that federal prosecutors with the US Department of Justice Antitrust Division (DOJ) have obtained court authorization to review privileged communications between a major private equity company and its lawyers as part of a criminal investigation into whether the private equity company deliberately withheld material information from its merger filings with antitrust regulators. The ruling, issued by Judge Boasberg of the US District Court for the District of Columbia, remains sealed. This criminal investigation runs parallel to the DOJ’s ongoing civil lawsuit against the private equity company for similar conduct.
Where certain thresholds are met1, parties seeking to consummate reportable transactions must submit a Hart-Scott-Rodino (HSR) filing to both the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the DOJ (together, the “Agencies”). The parties must observe a 30-day statutory waiting period before closing, during which the Agencies decide whether there are competitive concerns based on information regarding the parties’ business and the transaction submitted in the filing.2 One component of the filing that is often critical to forming the Agencies’ initial impression of the likely competitive effects of a transaction is the Item 4(c) and (d) documents that must be included with the filing. These items require filing parties to produce all documents prepared by or for officers or directors that analyze the transaction with respect to certain competition-related topics. The DOJ’s civil complaint alleges that the private equity company “systematically” altered and failed to produce Item 4 documents across multiple transactions.
Communications between an attorney and a client are typically protected under the attorney-client privilege. However, under the crime-fraud exception, if a prosecutor can establish (1) that the client was committing or intending to commit a fraud or crime, and (2) that the attorney-client communications were made in furtherance of that alleged crime or fraud,3 then the prosecutor can ask a court to compel the disclosure of those communications. The attorney does not have to be aware of the client's criminal or fraudulent intent.4 Judge Boasberg’s order is significant because it means the DOJ has obtained evidence that the private equity company used legal advice in furtherance of the alleged crime. This is an aggressive investigative step that highlights the seriousness with which the DOJ is treating this investigation.
Key takeaways
Clear communication is key
DOJ’s request to Judge Boasberg was made on an ex parte basis, meaning the judge heard only one interpretation of the communications and the private equity company had no opportunity to respond, clarify or provide context. While the exact communications that convinced Judge Boasberg to waive the attorney-client privilege are unknown, prosecutors can often point to carelessly worded text messages or out-of-context missives as evidence of wrongdoing where none exists. Clients and counsel should ensure that their communications are clear, concise and drafted to avoid ambiguity or any misimpression of wrongdoing.
Merger risks
Companies engaged in merger and acquisition activity should treat Hart-Scott-Rodino (HSR) filing obligations with the utmost seriousness. This matter demonstrates that alleged inaccuracies or omissions in merger filings can lead to civil or criminal investigations. Regulators share information, and referrals to the DOJ can lead to costly and burdensome investigations.
State level enforcement
DOJ is no longer the only enforcement authority companies need to consider. With the rise of state-level merger control and antitrust enforcement, companies should expect state enforcers to be equally aggressive when reviewing and investigating merger filings for alleged inaccuracies or omissions.
Footnotes
-
Old HSR form back in effect after Fifth Circuit refuses to rescue FTC's overhaul.
-
United States v. Doe, 429 F.3d 450, 454 (3d Cir. 2005).
-
In re Napster Copyright Litig., 479 F.3d 1078, 1090 (9th Cir. 2007).