Until relatively recently, executing documents to be enforceable under New York law typically required an ink signature on a paper copy of the document. Where the document also had to be notarized, such as an affidavit, the signer or principal, had to physically appear before a notary in the State of New York who could witness the signing. Over time, these practices caused significant headaches (and costs) for signers, lawyers and notaries alike – particularly in cross-border transactions and litigation with tight deadlines.

Thankfully, the landscape has significantly changed over the past few decades (accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic), with the advent of laws that allow electronic signatures and, more recently, electronic notarization and sworn affirmations. This article explores the use of electronic signatures and electronic notarization under New York law and identifies important considerations when engaging in complex transactions. For prudence sake, we would recommend always checking with legal counsel to confirm whether electronic signatures and notarizations are advisable for each particular matter, considering the courts and jurisdiction(s) in which the documents may need to be enforced.

Electronic signatures may be acceptable

Pursuant to New York's Electronic Signatures and Records Act (ESRA) (N.Y. State Tech. Law § 301 et seq.), electronic signatures have the same force and effect as handwritten signatures for many documents.1 Thus, electronic signatures and electronic records may be admitted into evidence in legal proceedings in New York state courts so long as they comply with New York’s evidentiary rules.

Importantly, electronic signatures are not approved for all document types. For example, wills, trusts, powers of attorney, healthcare proxies, orders not to resuscitate and certain negotiable instruments may not be electronically signed.

Under the ESRA, an electronic signature is “an electronic sound, symbol, or process, attached to or logically associated with an electronic record and executed or adopted by a person with the intent to sign the record.” A range of digital objects may serve as an electronic signature, and can be as simple as typing one's name or as sophisticated as an encrypted hash of a document's contents. The signer can show their intent to sign electronically by typing their name, drawing a signature with a mouse or simply marking a checkbox, among other actions indicating that the signer understands that using the digital object has the same import as applying a handwritten signature.

An electronic signature needs to be appropriately “attached” or “associated” with the document, which means that it must be linked with the record during transmission and storage. For example, an electronic signature is attached or associated when it is embedded on the face of a document like a handwritten signature or available through an embedded link. A signature object can also be maintained separately, but it needs to be logically associated through a database, index or other means.

Note, however, that New York state courts have found typed signatures insufficient in some circumstances; for example, where the document being signed was a scanned attachment to an email and the signature was typed in the body of an email, but the signature could have (and should have) been added to the scanned attachment.

Best practices when considering whether an electronic signature is appropriate, especially in the context of international transactions

  • Determine what law governs the contract(s) and whether that type of agreement may be signed electronically under the law of that jurisdiction.
  • Identify the location of the parties signing the contract, the location where performance will occur and any other jurisdictions where litigation relating to or enforcement of the contract might occur. Determine if the laws in those locations impact the use of electronic signatures.
  • The use or acceptance of electronic signatures and records is voluntary. Therefore, include language in the contract indicating that it will be signed electronically and the manner of signature, and that all parties agree that such methods shall have the same legal and evidentiary effect as a handwritten signature.
  • It is prudent for the electronic signature to be embedded in the document so that it is clear to the signer what content is being signed and so the electronic signature cannot be separated from the contract.
  • Circulate executed copies of electronically signed documents to the parties.
  • Consider whether using an electronic signature platform, such as DocuSign or Adobe Sign, is appropriate for your transaction. One benefit of platforms such as these is that they are useful in preventing manipulation of the contract after execution. Unscrupulous parties to a contract have been known to insert pages or content into a contract and these platforms offer one method to guard against this type of manipulation.
  • Consider whether it is possible to execute a contract in counterparts and use a handwritten signature which is scanned along with the contract. Many jurisdictions, including New York state courts, will accept scanned copies of contracts as originals in court proceedings provided that there are no authenticity issues. Should the contract need to be litigated in a foreign jurisdiction that does not recognize electronic signatures, this method may be preferable (especially if originals may be exchanged at a later date).
  • When in doubt, consult with legal counsel to determine what is required for your specific transaction to help ensure that the use of an electronic signature will not impact the enforceability of the contract.

Electronic notarization may be acceptable

The key difference between electronic and traditional notarization is that electronic notarization occurs completely virtually. With traditional notarization, the principal must be physically present in the State of New York and appear before the notary public. The principal presents proof of identity in person and signs the document in ink.

After the COVID-19 pandemic, New York permanently legalized electronic notarization, presenting an appealing and efficient alternative to traditional notarization. Laws and regulations application to electronic notarization include New York Executive Law section 135-c (the New York electronic notarization law), N.Y. State Tech. Law §§ 301 to 309 and related regulations in 9 NYCRR §§ 540.1 to 540.7 (New York Electronic Signatures and Records Act) and 19 NYCRR § 182.1 to 182.11 (notary public regulations).

During electronic notarization, the notary and principal are located remotely from each other, but they must be able to see and interact with each other in real time over a video conference. The principal does not need to be physically present in New York. The notary uploads the document to an online platform and joins a conference with the principal.  The notary must identify the principal as who they claim to be, whether by having personal knowledge of the identity of the principal or through review of proof of identify in compliance with applicable regulations. The notary administers the oath virtually, and the principal and notary must both sign the document electronically. The notary must keep a “journal” of all electronic notarial acts the notary performs.

If the notarial process complies with New York law, electronic notarization has the same force and effect in New York as traditional notarization. However, there are important exceptions and considerations to keep in mind, including whether electronic notarization is acceptable in the jurisdiction(s) in which the notarized document will be submitted or enforced. When in doubt, traditional notarization may still be the best option.

Important considerations when using electronic notarization

These are some important points to consider when using electronic notarization, including differences in the notarial process between traditional and electronic notarization.

The document being notarized must be electronically signed

If a document requires an ink signature under New York law – like a power of attorney – it cannot be electronically notarized, because electronic notarization requires an electronic signature.On the other hand, an electronic signature on such a document may be acceptable in another jurisdiction.

The electronic notary must use approved video software to perform the notarial act

A simple video call is not sufficient to facilitate the notarial act. Among other requirements, New York regulations require that the technology include a secure signal transmission, sufficient visual clarity to enable the notary to read and capture the front and back of an identification card, and a process of reproducing documents that does not permit changes without leaving a record of such changes. The notary must describe the software they are going to use when they register with the New York Secretary of State, described below.

A notary public needs a special commission to perform electronic notarizations

The notary must “register” their capability to perform electronic notarial acts with the New York Secretary of State, which includes providing a description of the software they will use and a sample of the notary’s electronic signature. Upon receipt of an electronic notary license, a notary can perform both traditional and electronic notarizations. Note that notary licensing is public information, and whether a notary is commissioned as an electronic notary can be verified online: Commissioned NYS Notaries Public.

The electronic notary must be physically present in New York State when performing the notarial act

The principal does not need to be present in New York.

If the principal is not present in the United States, the document must relate to a matter in the US

If the principal is not present in the US, he or she must verify that the instrument to be notarized either (1) is to be filed with, or relates to, a matter before a court or other entity subject to the jurisdiction of the US; or (2) involves property located in the territorial jurisdiction of the US or involves a transaction substantially connected with the US.

If the principal is not personally known to the notary, the notary must take extra steps to verify the principal’s identity

The notary must verify the principal’s identity through traditional means (for example, a government-issued identification card or oath of witnesses), as well as through credential analysis by a third-party service provider and “identity proofing,” per applicable regulations. For example, the principal may be required to take a photo of themselves and upload a photo of a government ID, which will be compared by computer software to ensure that the principal is the same person as reflected on the ID.

The audio and video conference must be recorded

The notary needs to record the conference, including the identity verification component, and keep the record for at least ten years from the date of the notarization.

Err on the side of caution

If it is not clear that an electronic notary, or the proposed notarization process, meets the legal requirements for electronic notarization, strongly consider insisting on traditional notarization. Failure to follow New York’s notarization rules could result in ineffective or unenforceable documents, delays and future disputes.Likewise, it is important to consider whether electronic notarization is acceptable in the jurisdiction(s) in which the notarized document will be submitted or enforced. For example, while electronically notarized documents may be submitted for Apostille (authentication) to the New York Department of State, the foreign jurisdiction in which the authenticated document is being used may not recognize electronic notarization, thereby jeopardizing enforcement of the document. When in doubt, it is prudent to use traditional notarization.

Sworn affirmations in lieu of notarized affidavits

Changes to New York’s laws regarding notarized affidavits have also streamlined commercial transactions and litigation. Until relatively recently, if a party to litigation needed to submit a sworn affidavit, the affidavit had to be signed in ink before a notary public. This requirement often created significant logistical hurdles for what should otherwise be routine submissions. In contrast, lawyers and certain medical professionals could make affirmations sworn under penalty of perjury, and those affirmations did not need to be notarized.

Effective on January 1, 2024, the New York legislature amended CPLR 2106 and removed the restriction on who could make affirmations. As a result, any person, regardless of party status or physical location, can submit an affirmation as to the truth of a statement, “under the penalties of perjury,” and the affirmation does not need to be notarized. Such affirmations may also be signed electronically, consistent with the provisions described earlier in this article. In November 2025, CPLR 2106 was further amended to allow affirmations to be used not only in lieu of affidavits, but other “sworn statements,” such as litigation discovery responses. The statute provides uniform language to use in the affirmation, which must be used to ensure acceptance of the affirmation. These welcome changes have significantly eased burdens on litigants, counsel and the courts.

Conclusion

In conclusion, electronic signatures, electronic notarization and sworn affirmations can all streamline the transaction of business and litigation in New York, saving time and cost. Norton Rose Fulbright would be happy to assist your company in navigating signature, notarization and other commercial issues with respect to particular transactions or other business needs.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    While this article focuses on New York law, there is a Federal statute that governs electronic signatures, the Electronic Signature in Global and National Commerce Act (ESIGN), which also provides a framework for permitting electronic signatures. In addition, many states have adopted the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act (UETA) or their own electronic signature legislation, which also provides an avenue for electronically signing documents. It is important to check the law of any jurisdiction in which the document may be used, submitted or enforced.

Contact