As part of Norton Rose Fulbright’s monitoring of nuclear verdicts, we are providing regular updates regarding recent jury verdicts involving individual plaintiffs against corporate defendants. Below are four such cases from August:
Patterson, et al. v. Covidien LP, et. al
On August 7, 2026, a Massachusetts Federal Court judge entered a final judgment for a US$88 million jury verdict related to a hernia mesh product liability suit. The verdict, awarding US$77 million to the man who had the hernia mesh surgically implanted and US$11 million to his wife, served as the first bellwether in related MDL regarding the mesh product. One of the defendants has stated its intent to challenge the verdict.
Connolly, as Special Administrator of the Estate of Michael Ryan v The Boeing Company
On August 25, 2026, a judge in the Northern District of Illinois granted motion for entry of judgment for a US$37.7 million verdict to the estate of an individual killed in a Boeing aircraft crash from March 10, 2019. Boeing attempted to mitigate its damages by arguing that neither Michael Ryan nor any of the other passengers experienced fear for their lives or pain during the flight. The final judgment included the US$29 million in damages assigned by the jury plus an additional US$8.7 million in prejudgment interest.
Paulding v. Progressive Direct Ins.
On August 7, 2026, a jury in the Northern District of Oklahoma assessed a US$40 million award against Progressive to pay to one of its customers. The plaintiff had been injured in an accident with an uninsured driver and sought damages related to Progressive’s alleged breach of its contract and duty of good faith and fair dealing for its handling of and delays in responding to her uninsured motorist claim. The plaintiff ultimately won on her claim for bad faith and received US$20 million in actual damages and US$20 million in punitive damages.
White v. Powell et al
On August 17, 2026, a jury in the Northern District of Illinois awarded US$30 million to the mother of an individual killed in an auto accident involving a semi-truck driven by an individual working for an independent contractor providing services for FedEx Ground Package Systems, Inc. In reaching its verdict, the jury rejected claims by defendants that the driver killed in the accident was contributorily negligent for parking the vehicle in the right travel lane of the interstate at night with no hazards on. On August 31, 2026, the court entered an amended judgment for an additional US$9 million in pre-judgment interest, bringing the total award to US$39 million. Defendants have since sought a new trial or, in the alternative, remittitur.