As part of Norton Rose Fulbright’s monitoring of nuclear verdicts, we are providing regular updates regarding recent jury verdicts involving individual plaintiffs against corporate defendants. Below are five such cases from September:

Owens v. PruittHealth-Fitzgerald LLC et al.

Three corporate defendants asked on September 4, 2026, to set aside a US$23.6 million verdict against them related to the death of a man in a nursing home. A jury had awarded the verdict on August 21, 2026, to two sons of a man who allegedly died after being administered unprescribed medication. The three corporate defendants argued the verdict should be set aside for a number of reasons, including because

  1. the jury found that neither of the treating nurses had administered the deceased unprescribed medicine and
  2. if the medication had been administered, the nurses acted outside the scope of their employment, and therefore the companies could not be held vicariously liable.

Murphy et al. v. Clallam County

On September 17, 2026, a jury in Kitsap County, Washington awarded a US$30.2 million verdict in favor of sheriff’s deputy Matthew Murphy related to the loss of his right leg. The injury occurred at a March 2020 mandatory firearms training and led to 10 surgeries prior to the amputation of the leg below the knee. The verdict was broken down into approximately US$20 million for the deputy’s pain, disability and other noneconomic damages, US$5 million to his wife for loss of consortium and US$5.1 million in economic damages.

Christianson and Williams, as guardians and conservators of Joe Brian Duenas, v. Import Auto

On September 21, 2026, a jury ruled against the driver and his employer and awarded US$65 million to an orphaned boy whose mother was killed when the defendant driver, who had allegedly improperly loaded an excavator for towing, struck a bridge and caused debris to fall onto her vehicle. The son was also in the vehicle with his mother at the time of the crash.

J.R. v. Lincoln Bancorp, LLC

On September 23, 2026, a jury awarded US$164 million in damages (US$44 million in compensatory and US$120 million in punitive) to a woman who alleged she was sexually trafficked at a Super 8 hotel as a teenager. The plaintiff alleged some of the staff were aware of the unusual behavior in the rooms where the trafficking occurred, and that one front desk employee refused to help her when she tried to escape.

Lioudmila Pyleva v. Yale New Haven Hospital et al.

On September 29, 2026, a jury awarded US$15.1 million to a woman allegedly blinded following brain surgery when an antiseptic dripped into her eye. The defendants had denied that any of the antiseptic had entered her eye, arguing precautions had been taken to prevent such an occurrence.

card-grid-item, aem-sourced
Nuclear verdicts: Recent cases and emerging trends archive
Follow recent nuclear verdicts, including significant cases across industries.
/content/nrf-eds/en-us/insights/publications/2026/10/nuclear-verdicts-archive

Contact