In 2025, the USPTO updated its computer-implemented invention guidance on assessing subject matter eligibility, which has practical impacts particularly on machine learning or artificial intelligence innovations.
In short, the updates incorporate positive guidance from a recent precedential Appeals Review Panel decision where a technical improvement to address catastrophic forgetting in machine learning was found to be patent-eligible subject matter.
CIPO also released proposed updates in 2025 to its guidance on subject matter eligibility for computer-implemented inventions. While both guidance updates are helpful, it is important to note similarities and differences in approach.
Patent-eligible subject matter in the US – MPEP updates
In the US, computer-implemented inventions face not only prior art rejections based on anticipation and obviousness, but also patent-eligible subject matter rejections under 35 U.S.C. § 101.
The Manual of Patent Examining Procedure (MPEP), and in particular, MPEP §§ 2106, governs examination of patent applications in respect of subject matter eligibility, and the updates can be summarized as:
-
The guidance was updated to explicitly incorporate the precedential September 2025 Appeals Review Panel (ARP) decision Ex Parte Desjardins [Desjardins]. Paragraphs to MPEP § 2106.04(d) were added referring to the ARP’s analysis in accordance with the two-step Alice framework.
- These amendments can be used to make useful analogies during examination, especially where an analogy can be drawn to specific machine learning problems, such as catastrophic forgetting in continual learning systems and the applicant’s proposed technical solution.
-
Additional emphasis was also placed on evaluating the specification, noting that (emphasis original) “first the specification should be evaluated to determine if the disclosure provides sufficient details such that one of ordinary skill in the art would recognize the claimed invention as providing an improvement in the functioning of a computer, or an improvement to other technology or a technical field.”
- These amendments highlight the importance of the specification as a mechanism not only to support the interpretation of the claims, but also to support argumentation.
- A nuanced change in this section limits the ability of the examiner to indicate that the specification is directed to a bare assertion without the necessary detail. In particular, the examiner can only make this assertion (emphasis original) “if the specification explicitly sets forth an improvement
butonly in a conclusory manner […]”
-
Additional amendments were made to reflect that the improvement can be (emphasis original) “in technology or a technical field.”
-
The reference to Enfish LLC v Microsoft Corp., 822 F.3d 1327 (Fed. Cir. 2016) [Enfish] in MPEP was also amended.
- In particular, the amendments clarified that Enfish was directed to (emphasis original): data structure claims to a self-referential table for a computer database were directed to an improvement in computer capabilities and not directed to an abstract idea. From a practical perspective, applicants should consider increasing emphasis on data structures in both the specification and the claims in view of this change.
-
Ex Parte Desjardins ARP was further cited to support reminding examiners to be “careful to avoid oversimplifying the claims,” following McRO CAFC. In particular, the following section was added: (emphasis original) “Examiners and panels should not evaluate claims at such a high level of generality that potentially meaningful technical limitations are dismissed without adequate explanation).”
-
Concerning the specificity at which machine components are claimed, the guidance was also updated to reflect that (emphasis original): “[w]hen evaluating a claim as a whole, examiners should not dismiss additional elements as mere ‘generic computer components’ without considering whether such elements confer a technological improvement to a technical problem, especially as to improvements to computer components or the computer system.”
-
Two explicit examples were added to MPEP § 2106.05(a), namely an improved way of training a machine learning model, and improvements to computer component or system performance.
-
Regarding addressing a technical problem with a “technology based solution” (referring to BASCOM CAFC and Thales Visionix CAFC), MPEP § 2106.05(f) was amended to include technical effects such as (emphasis original): optimiz[ing] system performance, us[ing] less storage capacity and reduc[ing] system complexity.
While the USPTO has specified that incorporating Desjardins into MPEP is not an announcement of new policy, but rather incorporating an example in line with existing policy and precedent, it is important to note these nuanced changes in examination practice.
Patentable subject matter in Canada – draft MOPOP updates
Similarly, there are patentable subject matter prohibitions in Canada to take into consideration, prohibiting the patenting of “mere scientific principle[s] or abstract theorem[s].”
Canadian Intellectual Property Office (CIPO) examiners are guided by the Manual of Patent Office Practice (MOPOP). In 2025, CIPO also proposed revisions to its guidelines to clarify the approach to patentable subject matter in the context of computer-implemented inventions that will impact inventions relating to machine learning and AI. These revisions incorporate into MOPOP the guidance from PN2020-04 (Patentable Subject-Matter under the Patent Act) and reflect the Federal Court of Appeal’s decision in Canada (Attorney General) v Benjamin Moore & Co 2023 FCA 168 [Benjamin Moore FCA].1
It is important to note that software and computer-implemented inventions are still potentially patentable in Canada as the Federal Court of Appeal noted (emphasis added): "[...] the Commissioner should keep an open mind and not hastily conclude that the subject matter claimed is not patentable simply because it involves the use of conventional computer technology.”
- In Benjamin Moore FCA, the FCA made specific reference to the complexity of inventions in quantum technology and [with] the advent of artificial intelligence.
In Canada, a difference is that there is an increased emphasis on whether the “actual invention” has “physicality”; having a physical existence or manifesting a discernible physical effect or change.2
The author would like to thank Beatrice Kaiser, articling student, for her contribution to preparing this article.