Two decisions from the Alberta Court of King’s Bench in 2025 offer guidance on the enforceability of personal guarantees under the province’s Guarantees Acknowledgment Act (GAA). With opposite holdings concerning the necessity of formal compliance of the Alberta law, the role of public policy, overarching principles of justice, and comity of nations are revealed to be essential for guarantor enforcement.
Professional Bull Riders: Foreign law’s relationship to the GAA
In Professional Bull Riders, LLC v Australis Capital Inc, 2025 ABKB 122, Norton Rose Fulbright litigation partner Joshua Sadovnick was successful in an application to enforce a foreign arbitral award despite the absence of strict adherence to GAA requirements.
Professional Bull Riders, LLC (PBR), sought to enforce an arbitral award issued in Colorado against Australis Capital Inc. The settlement agreement under Colorado law saw the CEO of Australis, Terrence Booth, signing the agreement, which included a Colorado choice of law clause both on behalf of Australis and in his personal capacity as guarantor.
He argued the guarantee was unenforceable in Alberta because it lacked the guarantor-specific certificate required under s.3 of the GAA. He also claimed that enforcing the award would violate Alberta public policy by “explicitly defy[ing] Alberta legislation” (at para 43).
The court rejected these arguments. It held that the guarantee was governed by Colorado law and Booth had voluntarily submitted to arbitration. The GAA did not apply to a foreign guarantee governed by foreign law. Nor does, as Justice Gaston wrote, “enforcement of an unacknowledged guarantee which accords with Colorado law [violate Alberta] public policy” (at para 54).
Justice Gaston also noted the interests of judicial comity and the enforceability of international arbitral awards, even where local statutory formalities are not met.
Diamond-Dun Properties: Fraud vetoes formal compliance
In Diamond-Dun Properties Ltd. v 2138809 Alberta Ltd, 2025 ABKB 143, the court faced a different scenario. The plaintiff sought to enforce a personal guarantee against Yinan Zhao, one of the defendants. It relied on a certificate issued under section 5 of the GAA, which provides that, if the certificate is complete and regular on its face, that is conclusive proof the GAA has been complied with. Zhao, it argued, was therefore bound by the guarantee and liable. The certificate appeared regular on its face and was attached to an indemnity agreement signed in Zhao’s name.
But there was a twist: Zhao denied ever signing the document or appearing before the certifying lawyer. He claimed his business associate, Xu, had orchestrated a fraud by sending a look-alike to impersonate him at the signing. Xu later admitted to the scheme, which included forging Zhao’s signature and finding a third party to impersonate him for the purpose of obtaining a guarantee.
Justice Malik found that the guarantee was obtained through fraud and Zhao had no knowledge of or participation in its execution. While the certificate was “valid” on its face as it complied with section 5, the court held the GAA could not be used to enforce a contract that was never knowingly entered. The court emphasized the consumer protection purpose of the GAA over strict compliance with its sections and concluded that enforcing the guarantee would undermine that objective. The court was “not unsympathetic” to the plaintiff given it reasonably relied on the guarantee; however, it was still declared a nullity, and Zhao’s application for summary dismissal was granted.
Distinguishing – and reconciling – the two cases
While both cases involved personal guarantees and the GAA, their outcomes were markedly different.
In Bull Riders, the guarantee was knowingly signed by a sophisticated party under foreign law, and the issue was one of statutory non-compliance. The court prioritized the parties’ choice of law and the principles of enforcement of international arbitration awards.
In Diamond-Dun, the guarantee was fraudulently executed without the guarantor’s knowledge or consent, and the subsequent issue was a complete absence of agreement regardless of formal statutory compliance. The court refused to allow the GAA’s formalities to override the fundamental requirement of consent in contract law.
Both cases show that formal compliance with the GAA is not determinative as courts can and will look beyond the face of the certificate to assess whether the guarantor truly understood and agreed to the obligation. Where fraud is involved, even a seemingly valid certificate cannot cure the defect.
Takeaways
Parties dealing with guarantees in Alberta should be vigilant about both the form and substance of compliance with guarantees. Where they are governed by foreign law and arise from international arbitration, parties should ensure the governing law and jurisdiction clauses are clear and enforceable, as Alberta courts will defer to those choices even if the GAA is not followed. Legal advisors should also caution clients that Alberta’s consumer protection legislation offers limited shelter to sophisticated parties who knowingly assume obligations under foreign law.
Above all, however, lenders must perform the basic duty of verifying and identifying signatories. Both cases remind us that enforceability hinges on informed, voluntary consent rather than strict compliance with legislation.