2025 marked a turning point for digital asset disputes worldwide, as courts and regulators across major jurisdictions grappled with the complexities of crypto and tokenized assets. From landmark legislation in the US and the UK to evolving judicial approaches in Australia and Singapore, the past year saw significant strides in defining property rights, clarifying regulatory perimeters and testing traditional legal doctrines against new technologies.
As we look ahead, the pace of change shows no sign of slowing. Key themes include the implementation of bespoke regulatory frameworks, heightened enforcement activity and continued litigation around fraud, insolvency and consumer protection. At the same time, courts are refining legal principles on trust, possession and contractual obligations in the digital asset context—developments that will shape the global legal landscape for years to come.
In our review, we examine the most notable disputes and regulatory milestones of 2025 and offer insights into what businesses, investors and practitioners should expect in 2026 across the US, UK, Singapore and Australia.
The US
2025 was a critical year in crypto’s development into an institutional-level asset. Between the GENIUS Act’s mid-year passing, significant regulatory shifts across agencies and even banks recommending crypto portfolio holdings, the outlook for crypto appears bright. Litigation played a slightly quieter role given the dismissal of regulatory enforcement actions against a number of crypto exchanges and issuers—but even so, those dismissals, alongside other decisions, carried a significant impact on the industry. Taken together, however, these developments do raise a number of questions: How should GENIUS be implemented? What is the best regulatory framework for crypto? Is market structure possible? What role do courts play in deciding crypto’s legal frameworks? Hopefully, these questions will be answered in 2026.
2025 Retrospective: Courts, legislation and agencies brought much crypto change
Courts supplied important guardrails
On decentralized protocol liability, appellate guidance in 2025’s Risley v. Universal Navigation out of the Second Circuit reinforced the trend toward limiting primary liability for open source protocol developers where third party token issuances and trading occur without custodial control or direct solicitation—an outcome aligned with the district court approach in the Uniswap litigation and influential in ongoing exchange and DeFi cases nationwide. Although plaintiffs continue to refine theories around control, solicitation and aiding and abetting, the emerging doctrine narrows pathways for class claims premised on mere publication of protocol code and listing functionality on decentralized venues, while leaving room for individualized misrepresentation or control based claims to proceed where well pled.
GENIUS becomes law
The most consequential US development in 2025 was the enactment of the GENIUS Act, the country’s first federal digital asset statute, which created a comprehensive framework for “payment stablecoins,” including licensure pathways, 1:1 reserve, segregation, audit and disclosure requirements and explicit exclusion of permitted payment stablecoins from the definitions of “security” and “commodity.” Signed on July 18, 2025, after bipartisan votes in both chambers, the law places bank affiliate issuers under their primary prudential supervisors and federally licensed nonbanks under the OCC, while allowing sub $10 billion issuers to operate under qualifying “substantially similar” state regimes; implementing regulations are due by July 18, 2026 and the Act becomes effective on the earlier of January 2027 or 120 days after final rules are issued. In practical terms, the statute unlocks integration of compliant stablecoins into traditional payment rails but simultaneously removes SEC and CFTC jurisdiction over those instruments, with ramifications for secondary market oversight and private remedies sounding in federal securities or commodities law.
Agency posture transformed in parallel
A reoriented SEC under Chair Paul Atkins, launched “Project Crypto,” convened public roundtables on tokenization and privacy, moved to generic listing standards for certain crypto ETPs and stood up a crypto task force that examined privacy preserving compliance architectures; Commissioners emphasized that privacy tools should not be presumed illicit and that software developers without custodial control should not bear Bank Secrecy Act obligations by default. The SEC also, notably, dismissed all of its enforcement actions against crypto exchanges, companies, and issuers, resulting in a massive change regarding potential court decisions on securities law and more. Further, banking regulators reversed or rescinded prior constraints, clarified permissible safekeeping of digital assets for banks and began proposing GENIUS implementation rules—signals that banks may now build stablecoin issuance, custody and tokenized asset services on a clearer prudential footing.
2026 Outlook: Litigation inflection points, market structure, GENIUS implementation and SEC/CFTC coordination
Litigation trends toward consumers, prediction markets, and privacy
On the litigation front, several vectors are salient. First, as GENIUS forecloses securities and commodities theories for permitted payment stablecoins, expect plaintiffs to pivot to consumer protection statutes. Second, private actions against centralized platforms will continue to test Howey-based token classifications pending market structure legislation, while protocol level suits probe the boundaries of control, solicitation, and aiding and abetting after Uniswap related rulings narrowed exposure for passive code publication; courts are increasingly requiring concrete allegations of managerial control, direct statements, or custodial functionality to survive dismissal. Third, expect event market and prediction market litigation to expand alongside CFTC activity on retail DCO models, with private and public challenges converging on whether and how such markets fit within the commodities and gaming perimeters. Finally, privacy tool litigation may accelerate following the SEC’s 2025 roundtable rhetoric emphasizing the legitimacy of privacy preserving compliance.
2026 is filled with policy questions
First, all eyes are on market structure. Senate Banking and Agriculture Committees signaled early year activity on the CLARITY package, with advocates forecasting markup and floor movement; if enacted, the bill would settle jurisdictional lines, create CFTC registered digital commodity venues and intermediaries, and codify transition criteria—catalyzing a multi year rulemaking cycle at both agencies. Even absent passage, the SEC and CFTC are expected to continue harmonization via joint statements and roundtables on spot products and clearing models. Relatedly, the GENIUS Act provides that federal and state regulators must promulgate final rules by July 18, 2026 to stand up licensure, capital, liquidity, reserve, segregation and AML/CFT standards; FDIC and OCC proposals previewed the supervisory emphasis on safety and soundness, reserve custody segregation, and yield prohibitions, while banks press to narrow perceived loopholes on issuer yield and distribution. Expect intense industry engagement on reserve compositions, cross chain operational risk, redemption mechanics, and foreign issuer access criteria—areas that will determine whether stablecoin issuance scales inside banking perimeters or concentrates in a small cohort of federally licensed nonbanks.
Regulatory posture becomes even more critical
The SEC’s crypto task force and Project Crypto are poised to mature from convenings to concrete policy. Prior public fora previewed near term steps on custody for crypto asset securities, on chain settlement mechanics for broker dealers, innovation exemptions for early stage experimentation, and privacy preserving compliance models using selective disclosure and zero knowledge proofs—topics the Commission has already begun to address through staff statements and cross market roundtables. The Commission’s 2025 move to generic ETP listing standards and tokenization roundtables also suggests continued normalization of exchange traded access and careful calibration of on chain securities plumbing in 2026. The same can be said for the CFTC. With the agency’s new leadership under Chair Michael Selig and recent targeting of spot market guardrails, tokenized collateral acceptance, and hybrid clearing structures, finalization of DCO expectations and collateral policies in 2026 would materially affect derivatives venues and DeFi adjacent event markets. The staff’s request for comment on direct retail clearing foreshadowed more permissive—but risk aware—models that could emerge over the year, though these are subject to change based on the CFTC’s new leadership.
Conclusion
Taken together, 2026 is poised to translate 2025’s legislative and policy resets into operational rulebooks and supervisory practice. Market structure legislation, even if enacted mid year, would launch multi year implementation across the SEC and CFTC. GENIUS will harden the stablecoin perimeter and force business model choices for banks and FinTechs. Regardless, however, the SEC’s task force will likely move from listening to proposing. And on the civil litigation front, we will likely see plaintiffs adapt to narrower federal theories by targeting consumer protection, competition, and control based claims.
The UK
Law reform and the Property (Digital Assets etc) Act 2025
On December 2, 2025, the Property (Digital Assets etc) Act 2025 became law – this is a significant step towards cementing the UK as the leading legal jurisdiction to underpin the digital asset economy. The Act is the culmination of an extensive law reform project led by the Law Commission, involving a number of consultations and extensive reports leading to the recommendation for new legislation. With the support of industry and successive governments and despite the opposition of a small group of law firms and academics, the legislation was successfully steered through parliament.
The Act itself contains only a single technical change to the law: it provides that digital assets are not prevented from being treated as property merely because they do not fall within the two existing legal categories of property (‘choses in possession’ and ‘choses in action’). Previous English caselaw classified property into these two exhaustive categories – either tangible objects capable of being possessed or legal rights of action against specific persons – which hindered the development of property law in respect of digital assets as they did not fit into either category.
With this change, there will no longer be an impediment to courts treating digital assets as property. This means not only that they can create rules dealing with creation of security, recovery of fraudulently transferred assets and trust and custody arrangements, but that these rules may be fashioned to suit the unique characteristics of digital assets. The incremental approach to development taken by the English common law is well-suited to the novel and complex fact-situations thrown up by disputes involving digital assets. The Act removes an impediment to this approach.
Following the Act, efforts to reform digital assets law will turn to cross-border issues. Here, the Law Commission has already issued one consultation but there is not yet a consensus as to how best to proceed.
Digital assets in the courts
Disputes reaching the courts that concerned or were relevant to digital assets primarily concerned the retrieval of assets following fraud. Authorized push payment (APP) fraud remains the primary risk for digital asset account holders.
Most APP fraud cases involve the victim seeking redress against their own bank for making the initial transfer out of the victim’s account. An important extension of the scope of liability is a duty of retrieval imposed on a bank that receives the funds and pays them out to a fraudster or to an intermediate bank. There have been conflicting recent decisions as to whether such a duty exists: in Barclay-Ross v Starling Bank Ltd [2025] EWHC 2158 (KB), the Court held that it was arguable that such a duty existed, but in Santander UK PLC v CCP Graduate School Ltd [2025] EWHC 667 (KB), the Court held that it did not. Resolution of this conflict will require the intervention of the appellate courts.
Another novelty is the increased use of applications to obtain information from banks and payment services providers (PSPs) located inside and outside the jurisdiction which will then be used to trace assets or to support action against the fraudster. In Babco Chemicals Inc v HSBC UK Bank PLC [2025] EWHC 1749 (Comm), the court allowed a claimant to use documents it received from a bank to found a claim against that same bank as the receiving party in an APP fraud.
The basis of most APP fraud claims is the ‘Quincecare duty’: the duty on a bank to make enquiries before effecting a transfer instruction given by an agent of the accountholder in circumstances that arouse suspicion. In Hamblin v Moorwand [2025] EWHC 817 (Ch), a PSP was found liable to return a payment debited from its customer’s account due to a breach of its Quincecare duty. This is a rare example of a successful Quincecare claim but it is notable for several other reasons: it confirms that PSPs owe Quincecare duties as well as banks, the claim was a derivative action brought by investors in a company rather than the company itself and an exclusion clause was not effective to prevent the claim.
Meanwhile, the English courts continue to elucidate causes of action that may be available to claimants. In recent cases, they have considered duties of care owed by receiving PSPs and claims based on unjust enrichment and dishonest assistance involving intermediaries.
Conclusion
The targeted legislative reform of the Act aims to unlock the creativity of the English courts in fashioning appropriate rules to govern the operation of the digital assets economy. Disputes before the courts continue to show that this process is vital to enable the protection of users of digital assets and customers of digital exchanges.
Australia
In 2025, crypto-related disputes in Australia shifted decisively from the legal periphery to the mainstream of commercial, regulatory and criminal litigation, with significant cases heard across all superior Australian courts. While a wide array of issues came before the courts, two key themes emerged. First, Australian courts are increasingly willing to recognize digital assets as “property,” applying established legal principles to resolve disputes and grant remedies. Secondly, regulators have intensified enforcement action against crypto businesses, actively testing the boundaries of existing financial services legislation ahead of anticipated bespoke statutory reforms, expected to take effect in 2026. This update highlights notable matters from 2025 and offers insight into the types of proceedings likely to shape the Australian crypto legal landscape in the year ahead.
The crypto is “property” cases
Australian courts continue to wrestle with first principles: including is cryptocurrency property and how should it be mapped onto traditional doctrines and statutes.
In Yeates (a pseudonym) v The King, the Victorian Court of Appeal addressed the issue in determining whether theft of Bitcoin had occurred under the Crimes Act. The case arose from the prosecution of a former Federal Police officer who appropriated 81.6 BTC. Drawing on domestic and comparative authorities, the Court held that Bitcoin bears the indicia of property: it is definable, identifiable, capable of assumption by third parties, and possesses a degree of permanence. It therefore falls within the legislative definition of “theft” of property. The Court rejected the contention that Bitcoin is neither money nor property but mere information.
The Poulton v Conrad litigation considered the property character of Bitcoin in the context of detinue and conversion, where Mr Poulton was alleged to have wrongfully retained Bitcoin acquired for Mr Conrad. Across the Tasmanian courts, the claim succeeded, with particular focus on whether cryptocurrency can be “possessed” for tortious purposes. At first instance, control of the asset through the wallet and private keys was held sufficient to constitute possession. The Full Court affirmed that conclusion, expressly revisiting the issue in the absence of prior Australian authority. In doing so, Estcourt J respectfully departed from Attiwill J’s view in Re Blockchain Tech Pty Ltd that, while Bitcoin is intangible property, it cannot be possessed or made the subject of bailment. Estcourt J considered that approach insufficient for the digital age and confirmed that control of the private key provides the requisite factual control and intention to possess for conversion and detinue.
Cryptocurrency in insolvency proceedings
Australian courts are increasingly encountering insolvency proceedings where cryptocurrency plays a central role, as demonstrated in recent cases such as Mirror Trading International (Pty) Ltd (in liq) v Went and Ex NF Pty Ltd (in liq) v Munneke. These decisions confirm that Australian courts are willing to apply established legal principles and remedies to disputes involving digital assets.
In the ongoing liquidation of Mirror Trading International (MTI), a South African crypto-Ponzi scheme, the Federal Court granted default judgment against an Australian investor who had received 4.9 BTC from MTI in an allegedly uncommercial transaction during the relevant clawback period. The defendant was among over 300,000 investors worldwide who received Bitcoin to the detriment of other creditors. The court accepted the liquidators’ evidence that the Bitcoin transfer constituted an insolvent and uncommercial transaction, rendering it voidable. Notably, the court ordered the return of the Bitcoin, valuing the repayment obligation in Australian dollars at the conversion rate on the date of judgment. This sets an important precedent for future cryptocurrency clawback actions in insolvency contexts.
Similarly, in Ex NF Pty Ltd (in liq) v Munneke, the Supreme Court of South Australia found that a director breached his statutory and fiduciary duties by using company-owned cryptocurrency proceeds to purchase real property while the company was in financial distress. The director’s argument that he personally owned the cryptocurrency, based on his exclusive control of the private keys and account credentials, was rejected. The court traced the source of the funds, determining that the Bitcoin was purchased with company money, converted to Ethereum, and ultimately to fiat currency used for the property purchase. The court held that these assets remained company property, and the director’s actions amounted to a breach of duty, with no available defenses. These cases illustrate the courts’ readiness to adapt traditional insolvency and fiduciary principles to the evolving landscape of digital assets.
The regulatory proceedings
The regulatory landscape for digital assets in Australia continues to evolve in 2026, building on the NGS decisions of 2025. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) initially secured orders for receivers to take control of the assets of a cryptocurrency mining business, and by the end of 2026, the Federal Court had converted that receivership into a winding-up of the entities behind the “NGS Digital Mining Scheme”. ASIC’s action was based on findings that the NGS entities operated an unregistered managed investment scheme—comparable to a collective investment scheme or managed fund—without the necessary Australian financial services license. The scheme had attracted over 450 investors, who collectively contributed more than AU$58 million to a pooled “Blockchain Mining Product” that promised monthly returns from crypto-mining operations.
This judgment underscores the effectiveness of existing financial services legislation in regulating digital asset businesses and demonstrates the courts’ readiness to wind-up entities whose activities endanger consumer interests.
Further clarity also came through a series of 2025 appeals to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia, which addressed the application of traditional financial services law to digital products. Notably:
- ASIC v Web3 Ventures (the Block Earner litigation) is set to become the first cryptocurrency case before the High Court of Australia, following the grant of special leave for ASIC to appeal the Full Court’s decision that Block Earner’s “Earner” product was neither a managed investment scheme nor a derivative requiring a licence.
- ASIC v Wallet Ventures (formerly Finder Wallet), examined whether a product involving the conversion of fiat currency into the TrueAUD stablecoin, which was then transferred to Wallet Ventures for a variable return, constituted a debenture. The Full Court found that, once fiat currency was converted to TrueAUD, the transaction involved the transfer of property rather than money, placing it outside the legislative regime. The Full Court emphasized that regulatory characterization depends on both the form of consideration (fiat versus digital assets) and the rights conferred, providing valuable guidance for structuring stablecoin products.
These developments reflect the increasing sophistication of Australian courts in addressing the complexities of digital assets and signal that further legal clarity is imminent.
The other proceedings: Crypto in contractual disputes and class actions
In Chen v Blockchain Global Ltd (in liq) Mr Chen sought enforcement of a 2018 settlement deed under which 117.33 BTC was payable to him and pursuant to which the same amount of BTC was transferred to a multi-signature wallet as security for the payment. After default, Mr Chen sought to enforce the security by relying upon a term being implied into the deed requiring release of the security. The defendant denied the implied term and alleged that on a proper construction of the deed there was no obligation to release the BTC.
The court held that business efficacy required the term to be implied as the BTC had been provided as security for the obligations under the deed. In the absence of the term the security would be worthless. Although Mr Chen succeeded a competing parallel proceeding issued prevented access to the BTC, which is held pursuant to freezing orders until the competing proceeding is determined.
An interesting aspect of this case is the viability of enforcing such orders where the private keys are held in multi-sig custody. In this instance, the seed phrase was delivered up in accordance with court order however, what should happen if a party to a multi sig wallet refuses to provide the relevant information?
Utilizing tokens in place of fiat currency was the context for Federal Court Judge Downes approving a class-action settlement against BPS Financial over the promotion of its “Qoin Tokens” (Its Eco Pty Ltd v BPS Financial Ltd (Settlement Approval). The Qoin tokens were likely to be of limited value but the proceeding was sought to be abandoned by both the applicant and the funder as there was no realistic prospect that the respondent could make a material contribution to any settlement or meet any judgment debt. In considering the jurisdiction to make further orders the Court confirmed that Qoin tokens were not “money” in light of the Oxford English Dictionary definition of money and the application of that to the functional aspects of Qoin tokens.
Conclusion
The new year is shaping up to continue the evolution of cryptocurrency jurisprudence in Australia especially with the hearing of the High Court appeal in Web 3 Ventures. With specific legislation for digital assets just around the corner in Australia, it also remains to be seen whether such regulation will create increased activity in the country’s superior courts either with regulatory enforcement or commercial disputes seeking the same remedies as are available in traditional business. What is certain is that Australia’s judiciary is ready for digital asset disputes and have proven adept at navigating any novel issues arising to date.
Singapore
The digital asset dispute landscape in Singapore continued to develop in 2025 with a significant judgment by the High Court in Re Taylor, Joshua James and another (Official Receiver, non-party) [2025] SGHC 104 (Re Taylor). Building on key decisions by the Singapore Courts in recent years recognizing cryptocurrency as property capable of being held on trust, Re Taylor considered the issue of trust creation in the context of unclaimed cryptocurrencies held by a digital asset exchange operator in liquidation.
In rejecting the liquidators’ bid to distribute unclaimed customer cryptocurrencies which were said to be held on trust by the exchange operator, the High Court applied traditional principles of trust law and found that there was no trust arrangement—whether an express trust or, in the alternative, a resulting trust or Quistclose trust.
Notably, in examining whether an express trust had arisen, the Court found that there was a lack of certainty of intention to create a trust as, amongst other things, this was insufficiently clear from the terms and conditions in the digital asset exchange’s user arrangement. The Court first noted that there was ambiguity in the clause purporting to be a declaration of trust by the customers. While the clause stated that the digital assets are custodial assets held for the benefit of the account holders (that is, the customers), the Court was not persuaded that this necessarily amounted to a declaration of trust by the customers; the phrase “custodial assets” has not been interpreted judicially in Singapore, and it is possible that the digital assets were only held on a pledge. There were additionally clauses providing indications to the contrary—for example, a clause suggesting that legal title was held by the customer.
The Court further noted that operational arrangements such as customers’ ownership of individual digital asset wallets did not demonstrate the requisite intention to create a trust (for example, storage of digital assets in individual wallets could simply have been for security and accounting purposes). Re Taylor therefore reinforces the importance of clear contractual terms and other documentation evidencing the underlying legal arrangement; where customer assets are intended to be held on trust, unambiguous language must be used.
Conclusion
Singapore continues to be a leading hub for digital asset activity in Asia and we expect the disputes landscape in Singapore to further mature as more cases come to the courts. There are also likely to be more enforcement touchpoints as the Singapore authorities maintain a close watch over digital payment token services and capital markets products. Businesses should therefore be mindful of evolving supervisory expectations relating to various aspects such as governance, anti-money laundering, technology and operational risk.