The First tier Tribunal Property Chamber (Residential Property) (the FTT) has recently handed down its Decision on a preliminary issue concerning what constitutes a “relevant defect” for the purposes of section 120(2) the Building Safety Act 2022 (the BSA) in the context of an application for a Remediation/Remediation Contribution Order. In particular, the FTT clarified to what extent the risk posed by a defect is relevant to the definition of a “relevant defect”.

General background

Following the Grenfell Tower tragedy in 2017, the government enacted the BSA in 2022. Part 4 of the BSA includes a new safety risk management scheme in relation to “higher-risk buildings” (buildings that are at least 18 metres high or have at least 7 storeys and contain at least 2 “residential units”). It imposes wide ranging duties on every “Accountable Person” (AP) and the “Principal Accountable Person” (PAP) in respect of such buildings, particularly in respect of fire safety. The duties include carrying out building safety assessments and managing building safety risks (which may necessitate remedial works, such as cladding replacement). Breach of these serious obligations, which are regulated and enforced by a newly appointed Building Safety Regulator (the Regulator), carry criminal sanctions.

The party with the primary responsibility under the BSA to identify and remedy building safety risks in respect of a “higher-risk building”, is the PAP. You can search the online “high-rise residential building register” to identify the PAP in respect of any higher-risk building registered with the Regulator. Pursuant to the definition in s.72 of the BSA, that person or company is likely to be the entity with legal responsibility to repair and maintain the external and structural parts of the building, which is frequently the freeholder. In practice, however, it might well be that the PAP can pursue other parties to carry out the works and/or contribute to the costs thereof.

Where the PAP lacks the funds to carry out the works it can apply to the government’s Building Safety Fund to contribute towards the costs, although the Secretary of State for Housing and Communities (the SoS) may well seek repayment from others in due course. The PAP or other “interested party” such as the SoS might also apply to the FTT for a Remediation Order and/or a Remediation Contribution Order against other parties, such as the developer or other parties with proprietary interests in the building under sections 123 and 124 of the BSA requiring that party to carry out specified remedial works and/or contribute towards the cost of such works.

However, it is necessary to establish that there are “relevant defects” in the building to initiate an application for both a Remediation Order and/or a Remediation Contribution Order.

What constitutes a "relevant defect" is defined by section 120(2) BSA 2022 as "a defect … that (a) arises as a result of anything done (or not done), or anything used (or not used), in connection with relevant works, and (b) causes a building safety risk".

The dispute

The case arose in respect of applications made by the SoS for a Remediation Order and/or Remediation Contribution Order against the company owning the freehold interest, and three other related companies owning leasehold interests (the Respondents), in a mixed use estate known as Canary Riverside, Westferry Circus, London E14, which includes four residential towers constituting “higher-risk buildings” for the purposes of the BSA.

There was a dispute between the parties as to whether certain of the “defects” in the 7 different external wall types in the residential towers identified by the parties’ experts constituted a “relevant defect” for the purposes of the BSA and the FTT ordered that this issue should be determined as a preliminary issue. The hearing of that issue took place in late October 2025 and the FTT issued its Decision on 6 January 2026.

The arguments

The Respondents argued, partly in reliance on the FTT’s previous decision in Vista Tower CAM/26UH/HYI/2023/0003, that for the purposes of s120(2)(b) there is a threshold below which a risk should be considered as tolerable, or as an ordinary, unavoidable risk present in residential buildings of this type and therefore should not constitute “…a building safety risk“. On that basis, they argued that several of the wall types should not be classified as “relevant defects” at all in the light of the Respondents’ recent PAS9980 risk assessments suggesting that they presented a low risk not requiring any remedial works.

The SoS argued that for the purposes of determining the preliminary issue the FTT should confine itself to the existence of fire safety risks rather than their severity and the reference to “building safety risk” in s.120 is to any risk, however small, to the safety of people in or about the building arising from the spread of fire, or the collapse of the building or any part of it.

The decision

The FTT agreed with the SoS that for the purposes of determining whether a defect amounts to a “relevant defect” the threshold is a low one (and if Vista Tower suggested otherwise, it was wrongly decided). Accordingly, it decided, preferring the SoS’ expert evidence, that all but one of the defects constituted a relevant defect, principally on the basis that the particular wall types breached current Building Regulations.

However, the FTT made clear that, whilst the identification of a relevant defect opens up the possibility of an application for a Remediation Order/Remediation Contribution Order, the subsequent making of such an order by the FTT is a matter of discretion. A tribunal may decide that it is inappropriate to order remediation if it considers that the level of risk posed by a relevant defect does not warrant it. Similarly, on an application for a Remediation Contribution Order, a tribunal may decide that it is not just and equitable to make such an order in respect of costs incurred in remedying a relevant defect where it considers those costs were unnecessarily incurred.

The conclusion

Whilst the FTT agreed with the SoS that the threshold for establishing the presence of a relevant defect is a low one, this does not necessarily mean that steps will need to be taken to remediate a defect identified as a building safety risk. It is at that point, once the risks have been identified, that an assessment of those risks, such as in a PAS9980 assessment, will be relevant. As expressed in the PAS Code of Practice, for example in the commentary to clause 6, circumstances may exist in which, “notwithstanding the presence of combustible material in the external walls and cladding, there is no need to take remedial action as the risk is low”. Therefore what, if any, remedial works are required will be determined at the subsequent final hearing of the SoS’ applications in due course.

Contact