Introduction
In December 2025, the staff of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC or Commission) issued critical guidance on the use of digital assets as collateral for derivatives transactions across three different letters:
- CFTC Letter No. 25-39 (the Tokenized Collateral Advisory) permits the use of tokenized assets, defined as digital representations of real-world assets like US Treasuries or money market funds recorded on a blockchain, as collateral for futures and swaps transactions subject to conditions as to eligibility, enforceability, segregation, custody, haircuts and valuation requirements and operational risks.1
- CFTC Letter No. 25-40 (the Digital Assets Collateral Letter) permits CFTC-registered futures commission merchants (FCMs) to accept certain non-securities digital assets, including payment stablecoins, Bitcoin and Ether, as margin for derivatives transactions, and to deposit proprietary payment stablecoins as residual interest, subject to conditions regarding valuation and haircuts, regulatory reporting and adherence to risk management requirements.2
- CFTC Letter No. 25-41 withdrew Staff Advisory 20-34 (issued in 2020),3 declaring it outdated in light of the GENIUS Act and the new initiatives regarding tokenized collateral.
Taken together, these CFTC Letters provide a framework for derivatives market participants to use tokenized versions of securities, and digital assets other than securities, including payment stablecoins, Bitcoin and Ether, as collateral for futures and swaps transactions. These CFTC Letters are part of ongoing legislative and regulatory initiatives to establish a framework for the integration of digital assets into the financial markets, including Treasury rulemaking to implement the regulation of payment stablecoins under the GENIUS Act,4 ongoing Congressional initiatives to adopt a digital market structure and the SEC’s “Project Crypto.”5
A brief regulatory history
In November 2024, the Digital Asset Markets Subcommittee (DAMS) of the CFTC’s Global Markets Advisory Committee (GMAC) released Recommendations To Expand Use Of Non-Cash Collateral Through Use Of Distributed Ledger Technology.6
In July 2025, the President’s Working Group on Digital Asset Markets issued a report on Strengthening American Leadership in Digital Financial Technology (the PWG Report).7 The PWG Report directed the CFTC to “provide guidance on the adoption of tokenized non-cash collateral as regulatory margin to implement the CFTC’s GMAC DAMS recommendation.”8
In August 2025, the CFTC, under the leadership of Acting Chairman Caroline D. Pham, launched “Crypto Sprint.”9 Crypto Sprint is a 12-month initiative designed to implement the recommendations of the PWG Report and to foster a “Golden Age of Crypto” through regulatory clarity and innovation.10
In September 2025, CFTC Acting Chairman Pham launched the CFTC’s Tokenized Collateral and Stablecoins Initiative, and issued a Request for Information (RFI) on the Use of Tokenized and Digital Assets in Derivatives Markets. The Comment Period on the RFI ended on November 28, 2025. Norton Rose Fulbright submitted a response to the RFI on behalf of The Digital Chamber.11
On December 8, 2025, the CFTC Staff issued the Tokenized Collateral Advisory, the Digital Assets Collateral Letter and CFTC Letter No. 25-41, withdrawing outdated guidance.12 Together, these actions reflect the CFTC’s effort to establish a unified supervisory framework for tokenized instruments and digital asset collateral, while aligning its oversight with emerging statutory developments such as the GENIUS Act.
CFTC Letter No. 25-39: Tokenized Collateral Advisory
Technology-neutral framework
The Tokenized Collateral Advisory establishes a technology-neutral approach to the use of “tokenized assets” as collateral for CFTC-regulated derivatives, including futures and swaps. For this purpose, the Tokenized Collateral Advisory defines a “tokenized asset” as a digital representation of a real‑world asset, such as a US Treasury, agency security, corporate bond, money market fund share or equity security, recorded on a blockchain. The Tokenized Collateral Advisory acknowledges that the use of digital ledger technology to tokenize an asset does not, by itself, change the fundamental characteristics of that asset; nor do any CFTC Regulations mandate the use of any particular technology to transfer or hold collateral. Under this approach, firms may use tokenized collateral subject to compliance with the existing requirements applicable to traditional collateral.
However, the Tokenized Collateral Advisory acknowledges that “different tokenization methods may provide different rights to token‑holders or different levels of protection” and cautions market participants that “any tokenized asset or tokenization structure must be analyzed on an individual basis to ensure it meets all requisite regulatory requirements and registrant policies and procedures.”
Eligible tokenized assets
The Tokenized Collateral Advisory recommends that market participants initially limit tokenized collateral to those assets currently eligible to serve as regulatory margin, specifically liquid assets that have established haircuts and hold their value in periods of financial stress.13
Under current CFTC Regulations, (i) CFTC-registered derivatives clearing organizations (DCOs) may accept only assets with “minimal credit, market, and liquidity risks,” as initial margin and must apply appropriate haircuts and concentration limits to provide for rapid liquidation;14 and (ii) CFTC-registered swap dealers must limit assets posted or collected as margin for uncleared swaps to the currencies and securities set forth in CFTC Regulation 23.156.15 In order to confirm that tokenized collateral meets these requirements, “[m]arket participants should consider whether a tokenized form of an asset provides a holder with legal and economic rights that are the same or functionally equivalent to the rights of the asset in traditional form.”
Legal enforceability requirements
CFTC-registered firms that collect tokenized assets as regulatory margin must be able to demonstrate that those assets meet existing requirements for legal enforceability. The Tokenized Collateral Advisory notes that under current CFTC Regulations, DCOs must operate pursuant to an enforceable legal framework that addresses netting arrangements, the DCO’s interest in collateral and settlement finality. CFTC-registered swap dealers are required to hold initial margin under a legal, valid, binding and enforceable custodial agreement.16 The Tokenized Collateral Advisory encourages firms to engage with CFTC Staff in developing best practices for assessing tokenized collateral within existing legal and risk management frameworks.
Haircuts and valuation
DCOs are required to (i) apply appropriate reductions in value to reflect credit, market and liquidity risks (haircuts) to the assets they accept as initial margin, taking into account stressed market conditions, and (ii) evaluate the appropriateness of the haircuts on at least a monthly basis.17 CFTC-registered swap dealers are also subject to haircuts on eligible collateral.18
The Tokenized Collateral Advisory states that “[h]aircuts for tokenized assets can utilize the same risk-based approach already applied to underlying assets,” subject to adjustments for “any settlement-time differences or other differences in credit, market, or liquidity risks.” This two-step framework involves: (1) starting with the baseline haircut for the underlying non-tokenized asset, and (2) adjusting that haircut for tokenization-specific risks.
Custody and risk management
The Tokenized Collateral Advisory notes that CFTC-registered firms remain subject to all existing regulatory requirements for liquidity, custody, segregation and risk management with respect to tokenized assets held as margin.19 The Tokenized Collateral Advisory encourages market participants to address how legal requirements apply to tokenized collateral and how existing policies and procedures should be adapted to address tokenized collateral. In addition, the Tokenized Collateral Advisory notes that the CFTC Staff will continue to evaluate industry comments, including those responding to recommendations in the PWG Report on separate accounts of the same customer under CFTC Regulation 1.44 and eligible depositories under CFTC Regulation 1.49.
Operational risks
The Tokenized Collateral Advisory encourages entities considering holding or transferring tokenized assets as collateral to address operational risks in accordance with current risk management requirements, including cybersecurity, access/authorization or network-wide threats.
In addition, the Tokenized Collateral Advisory notes the importance of interoperability “as a factor to achieve benefits related to tokenization related to liquidity, collateral management, and other operational risks,” and acknowledges that the extent to which common standards develop to allow seamless movement of collateral may impact the analysis of some of these factors.
CFTC Letter No. 25-40: The Digital Assets Collateral Letter
The Digital Assets Collateral Letter establishes a framework for FCMs to accept digital assets, including payment stablecoins,20 Bitcoin and Ether as margin collateral for transactions in futures and cleared swaps transactions. The Digital Assets Collateral Letter permits FCMs to (i) use digital assets in margin and segregation calculations for customer futures and cleared swap accounts21 and (ii) deposit proprietary payment stablecoins into customer accounts as residual interest, in each case subject to specified conditions.
Use of digital assets in margin and segregation calculations
The Digital Assets Collateral Letter permits FCMs to recognize the value of digital assets when (i) determining whether, and to what extent, a customer account is undermargined for purposes of CFTC margin and capital requirements22 and (ii) performing customer account segregation calculations in accordance with CFTC custody account requirements.23 Under this relief, digital assets may be treated in a manner analogous to marketable securities once appropriate valuation methodologies and haircuts are applied. Subject to required valuation and haircuts, the described digital assets may be included on the asset side of segregation computations, offsetting customer deficits to the extent permitted by the applicable rules.
Acceptable collateral and applicable haircuts
- US futures and cleared swaps: for digital assets posted as collateral in US futures customer accounts and cleared swaps customer accounts, an FCM must rely on the valuation and haircut assigned by the registered DCO that accepts the asset for margin or settlement purposes. To promote consistency across clearing venues, when a digital asset is accepted by more than one DCO, the FCM must apply the highest haircut imposed by any such DCO.
- Non-US futures accounts: for digital assets posted as collateral in non-US futures accounts,24 an FCM may use the haircut established by a DCO or by a non-US clearing organization subject to the CPSS-IOSCO Recommendations for Central Counterparties. If multiple qualifying clearing organizations accept the asset, the FCM must apply the highest applicable haircut. In addition, a digital asset may be accepted in a non-US futures account if it is payment stablecoin or an underlying commodity of a futures contract listed on a CFTC-registered designated contract market.
- Digital assets not accepted by clearing organizations: for digital assets other than stablecoins that are not accepted by any registered DCO or qualifying non-US clearing organization, an FCM must apply a minimum 20 percent haircut consistent with SEC’s treatment of proprietary broker-dealer positions in Bitcoin or Ether. 25
- Inverse contracts: for contracts that are both based on and settled in a digital asset (for example, Bitcoin futures in which settlement payments are made in Bitcoin), an FCM must apply the haircut for that digital asset established by the applicable DCO or foreign clearing organization to the extent the digital asset is used to offset an undermargined amount or a customer deficit in that contract. This recognizes the natural hedge when collateral is denominated in the same digital asset as the related derivatives contract.26
Depositing proprietary payment stablecoins as residual interest:
The Digital Assets Collateral Letter permits FCMs to deposit proprietary payment stablecoins into customer accounts as residual interest, notwithstanding restrictions on permissible assets under CFTC Regulations.27 The letter thereby addresses concerns that existing restrictions “impose substantial operational frictions on FCMs accepting digital asset collateral by preventing them from topping up customer accounts that hold payment stablecoins with in-kind residual interest.” Firms should note that:
- Relief limited to payment stablecoins: only payment stablecoins—not Bitcoin or Ether—may be deposited as residual interest. This asymmetry reflects the lower volatility risk profile and cash-like design of payment stablecoins compared to other digital assets.
- Capital charge requirement: when an FCM deposits payment stablecoins as residual interest, it must apply a capital charge against the value of the payment stablecoins consistent with CFTC Regulation 1.17(c)(5) computed based on the firm’s liquidity and price volatility assessment under its risk management program.
Risk management requirements
Under CFTC Regulation 1.11, FCMs must maintain a risk management program that includes policies and procedures for assessing the liquidity, marketability and mark‑to‑market valuation of all non-cash assets held in customer accounts. In addition, the risk management policy must verify that all non-cash assets held in customer accounts are readily marketable and highly liquid.
In accordance with these requirements, an FCM may only accept a digital asset as collateral following a determination that the digital asset is readily marketable and highly liquid. In addition, FCMs must monitor digital asset collateral on an ongoing basis, including by daily measurement of customer liquidity needs, assessment of procedures to liquidate digital assets in a timely manner and without significant effect on price and application of appropriate haircuts to reflect market and credit risk. In addition, FCMs must include any digital asset collateral in (i) periodic risk exposure reports issued to senior management and the CFTC and (ii) risk management program reviews conducted at least annually or upon material change in the FCM’s business.
For digital assets that are not accepted by a DCO or qualifying foreign clearing organization, an FCM must implement a “robust process” for assessing the volatility and other risks of those assets and to adopt policies and procedures to determine their fair market value.
Permitted depositories and investment of customer funds
FCMs that accept digital assets as collateral remain subject to the requirements of CFTC Regulation 1.49, governing permitted depositories of customer funds and CFTC Regulation 1.25 with respect to permitted investments of customer funds.
Implementation, notice and reporting requirements
Notice filing
Prior to relying on the relief in the Digital Assets Collateral Letter, an FCM must file a notice with the CFTC’s Market Participant Division,28 identifying its intent to rely on the relief and the date it will begin accepting digital assets as collateral.
Phased implementation
Initial three-month period: for the first three months following the notice filing:
- Permitted assets: an FCM may accept only payment stablecoins, Bitcoin and Ether as margin collateral, and may deposit only proprietary payment stablecoins as residual interest.
- Weekly reports: an FCM must file a weekly report detailing the total amount of digital assets held in each of the futures, cleared swaps and 30.7 customer funds accounts, listing each asset type separately.
- Incident reports: an FCM must provide prompt written notice of any “significant operation or system issue, disruption, or failure, including any cybersecurity incident,” that affects the use of digital assets as collateral.
Subsequent expansion of digital assets: After the initial three‑month period, an FCM may accept additional digital assets only after submitting revised risk management policies to the CFTC’s Market Participant Division demonstrating how the firm will manage the risks of those other assets.
Conclusion and considerations
The Tokenized Collateral Advisory and Digital Assets Collateral Letter establish an initial framework for the use of tokenized and digital asset collateral in connection with derivatives transactions. Even as agencies begin rolling out regulations related to GENIUS Act implementation and Congress considers digital market structure legislation, these letters will nevertheless have an impact on tokenized collateral policy. To that end, here are some of our main takeaways for consideration:
- Tokenized collateral can fit within existing CFTC frameworks, with some guardrails. The CFTC Letters provide that tokenized versions of already‑eligible assets (for example, Treasuries or money market fund shares) may be used as collateral so long as firms can show legal enforceability, proper segregation/custody and control, appropriate haircuts and valuation and operational resilience. Haircuts can follow the same risk‑based approach used for the underlying asset, adjusted for any settlement‑time or liquidity differences, but these tokenization structures must be assessed on case‑by‑case basis under existing risk management programs. The core idea, then, is that current CFTC frameworks can accommodate tokenized collateral, but that collateral needs to be carefully evaluated for compliance with applicable regulatory requirements.
- Practical points for FCMs to consider. FCMs that intend to accept digital asset collateral should address the following requirements: file a Notice of Intent with the Market Participants Division via WinJammer before accepting digital assets as collateral; limit initial asset acceptance of digital assets to Bitcoin, Ether and payment stablecoins; confirm that payment stablecoins meet eligibility criteria both pre- and post-implementation of the GENIUS Act; implement weekly reporting of digital asset holdings by asset type and account category during the initial three-month period; and establish incident reporting procedures for prompt notification of significant operational issues affecting digital asset collateral.
- Opening the door to digital asset integration. For some time, regulators and market participants have contemplated how best to integrate digital assets and tokenization into financial markets. The CFTC’s letters establish a preliminary framework for derivatives market participants to use digital assets—both tokenized versions of securities and non-securities digital assets—as collateral. With clearer guidance on the application of current regulatory requirements to digital asset collateral, the CFTC has taken a significant step towards integrating digital assets into the financial markets.
Special thanks to law clerk Carson King for assisting in the preparation of this article.
Footnotes
-
See CFTC Letter 25-39, Tokenized Collateral Guidance (Dec. 8, 2025).
-
See CFTC Letter 25-40, Staff No-Action Position Regarding Digital Assets Accepted as Margin Collateral (Dec. 8, 2025).
-
See CFTC Letter No. 25-41, Withdrawal of CFTC Staff Advisory 20-34 on Accepting Virtual Currencies from Customers into Segregation (Dec. 8, 2025); CFTC Letter No. 20-34, Accepting Virtual Currencies from Customers into Segregation (Oct. 21, 2020).
-
See Treasury Department GENIUS Act Implementation: Advance notice of proposed rulemaking, 90 FR 45159 (Sept. 19, 2025).
-
See Speech of SEC Chair Paul Atkins, American Leadership in the Digital Finance Revolution (July 31, 2025); Speech of SEC Chair Paul Atkins, The SEC’s Approach to Digital Assets: Inside “Project Crypto” (Nov. 12, 2025).
-
See CFTC Press Release, dated Nov. 21.2025: CFTC’s Global Markets Advisory Committee Advances Recommendation on Tokenized Non-Cash Collateral.
-
See Presidential Working Group on Digital Asset Markets, Strengthening American Leadership in Digital Financial Technology (July 30, 2025).
-
See CFTC Press Release, Acting Chairman Pham Announces CFTC Crypto Sprint (Aug. 1, 2025).
-
**See generally PWG Report.
-
See NRF Letter to CFTC re. Input on Tokenized Collateral and Stablecoins (Release No. 9130-25), dated Nov. 26, 2025.
-
The Tokenized Collateral Guidance was issued jointly by the CFTC’s Market Participants Division, Division of Market Oversight, and Division of Clearing and Risk (collectively, the “CFTC Staff”). The Market Participants Division issued the Digital Asset Collateral Letter.
-
The Tokenized Collateral Advisory “recommend[s]” and “encourage[s]” firms to focus on these categories of collateral.
-
See CFTC Regulation 39.13(g)(10) and CFTC Regulation 39.13(g)(12).
-
CFTC Regulation 23.156(a)(1)(x) also includes gold as permitted collateral.
-
See Regulation 23.157(c)(2).
-
See CFTC Regulation 39.13(g)(12).
-
See CFTC Regulation 23.156(a)(3) (haircuts on initial margin); CFTC Regulation 23.156(b)(2) (haircuts on variation margin).
-
See CFTC’s Regulation 23.157(c) for uncleared swap initial margin; see also CFTC Regulations 1.20-30, 22.1-22.17, and 30.7 for segregation requirements for futures, foreign futures, and cleared swaps. For permissible depositories, see, e.g., CFTC Regulations 1.20(b), 22.7, and 30.7.
-
Under the Digital Assets Collateral Letter, a “payment stablecoin” means:
“(i) prior to the effective date of the GENIUS Act, a USD-denominated stablecoin that is issued by a state regulated money transmitter or trust company; maintains reserve assets limited to direct or indirect investments in cash, U.S. Treasury securities or overnight U.S. Treasury repurchase agreements; and publishes monthly attestations regarding the composition of the reserve assets and whether the fair value of the assets held in reserve is equal to the amount of stablecoins in circulation; and
(ii) following the effective date of the GENIUS Act, a stablecoin that meets the requirements contained in the GENIUS Act’s definition of “payment stablecoin” and is issued by a “permitted payment stablecoin issuer” or a “foreign payment stablecoin issuer” that complies with the GENIUS Act’s requirements applicable to such issuers.”
-
For purposes of this memorandum, Customer Accounts refers collectively to FCM accounts holding customer assets as margin for transactions in (i) futures traded on CFTC-designated contract markets (i.e., CFTC-regulated derivatives exchanges), (ii) futures traded on non-U.S. exchanges, and (iii) cleared swaps (i.e., swaps submitted for clearing by a CFTC derivatives clearing organization.
-
See CFTC Regulations 1.17(c)(5)(viii) and 1.44. CFTC Regulation 1.44(a) defines an “undermargined amount” as “the amount by which customer margin requirements for all products in that account exceed the net liquidating value plus margin deposits currently remaining in that account.”
-
See Regulations 1.20(i)(5), 1.32(b), 22.2(f)(5), and 30.7(f)(2).
-
CFTC Regulation 30.7.
-
See SEC Rule 15c3-1.
-
The Digital Assets Collateral Letter notes that the primary purpose of a haircut is to account for market risk when the collateral and the underlying liability are denominated in different assets, because the value of the collateral (e.g., USD or a stablecoin) and the value of the liability (e.g., Bitcoin) may move differently. In the case of a BTC inverse contract position collateralized by Bitcoin, both sides of the exposure are denominated in the same base asset. Accordingly, if the USD price of Bitcoin drops, the value of the Bitcoin collateral decreases and the USD value of the margin requirement for the BTC contract decreases as well. The two values move “in lockstep,” and the FCM does not face the market‑risk mismatch that haircuts are designed to address. See the Digital Assets Collateral Letter at Footnote 38.
-
See Regulations 1.23(a)(1), 22.2(e)(3)(i), 22.17, and 30.7(g)(6).
-
The Notice is filed via the WinJammer electronic filing system.