On January 13, Justice Little rendered his much-anticipated decision in the first application for leave to bring a private application on public interest grounds under the Competition Act’s (the Act) expanded private access regime. The decision sets out a clear roadmap for future applications seeking leave on public interest grounds.

The private access regime

Under the Act’s expanded private access regime, which came into force in June 2025, private applicants can seek leave to bring an application before the Competition Tribunal (the Tribunal) under certain civil provisions of the Act, including deceptive marketing, abuse of dominance, and civil anti-competitive agreements. Remedies available to private parties include remedial orders, administrative monetary penalties and, in some cases, a class action-style disgorgement remedy.

The leave test

Before a private enforcement action can proceed, leave must be obtained from the Tribunal. Under this test, the Tribunal can grant private applicants leave if the applicants establish they have been directly and substantially affected in the whole or part of their business by the alleged conduct or if the Tribunal determines it would be in the public interest to do so. This is the first time the Tribunal has applied the new public interest leave test.

The Tribunal held that it should be guided by the public interest standing test set by the Supreme Court of Canada in British Columbia (Attorney General) v Council of Canadians with Disabilities, 2022 SCC 27 and Canada (Attorney General) v Downtown Eastside Sex Workers United Against Violence Society, 2012 SCC 45, but that the test should be adapted for the competition context.

When considering whether leave should be granted on public interest grounds, the Tribunal will consider the following three questions cumulatively, while taking a flexible approach and relying on its expertise in competition matters:

  • Is the proposed application a substantial and genuine competition law dispute that warrants resolution by the Tribunal under the provision for which leave is requested? To meet this step of the test, the applicant must provide a sufficient factual basis for each of the elements of the provisions at issue, but the Tribunal will not weigh competing evidence or resolve complex factual issues at this stage.
  • Does the applicant have a genuine interest in the proposed application? Applicants will have a genuine interest if they can prove they have a real stake in the proposed proceeding, prior engagement with the issues, relevant reputation, and a real and continuing interest in the matter at issue.
  • Is the proposed proceeding a reasonable and effective means to determine the competition issues raised? This question considers (i) whether the applicant has the capacity (resources, expertise, and a litigation plan) to present the issues in a sufficiently concrete and well developed factual setting, (ii) whether the question of public interest transcends the interests of those most directly affected, (iii) whether there are realistic alternative means to resolve the issues in a more efficient and effective context (importantly, the Tribunal is the only forum for private applications brought under the relevant provisions of the Act), and (iv) whether the proceeding would impact the rights of others who are equally or more directly affected by the conduct.

The Tribunal held that the threshold for public interest leave should not be difficult to meet, but the applicant must adduce “sufficient evidence” related to the three questions set out above. The Tribunal will also “be alert for possible strategic litigation” and to applications that ought to have been brought under the “directly and substantially affected” branch of the leave test.

The Martin application for leave

This application was brought by a video game developer against Google and Apple. He alleged Google is dominant in the search engine market and maintains that dominance through exclusionary practices and anti-competitive revenue-sharing agreements that impede other search engines from entering the market or expanding. He also alleged Google entered into such a revenue-sharing agreement with Apple to prevent Apple from launching a competing search engine and to make Google the default search engine for all Apple devices worldwide.

In denying leave, the Tribunal applied the public interest leave test to the facts of this case as follows:

  • On the first step, it held that the “essential character of [the] proposed application concerns true competition issues suitable for the Tribunal” and raises “genuine competition law issues.” This step weighed in favour of granting leave, though not strongly due to evidentiary shortcomings in the applicant’s materials.
  • On the second step, it held that the applicant failed to lead evidence demonstrating he had real competition concerns or a genuine interest in the market beyond saying he uses Google search for his business and is concerned about a market “in which one player dominates.” He also failed to lead any evidence of a prior interest or involvement in the issues raised in the proposed application prior to filing this leave application. This step militated against granting leave.
  • On the third step, the Tribunal held that the applicant failed to show that the case was likely to be presented in a sufficiently concrete and well developed factual setting. The Tribunal found that there was no evidence of the applicant’s capacity to bring the case, as he did not lead evidence regarding his resources, his counsel’s plan to advance the merits proceedings, or his own expertise, nor material first hand evidence he could give at a hearing. This step weighed “heavily against granting leave.”

The applicant has 30 days to appeal this decision to the Federal Court of Appeal.

Takeaway

While leave was denied in this case, this decision sets out a clear roadmap for future applications where leave is sought on public interest grounds. It is a mistake for companies to view this case as setting a high bar for obtaining leave on a public interest basis—if anything, this decision provides a guide for plaintiff’s counsel seeking to bring these types of applications, particularly in the context of customer or consumer class action-style cases.

Contact