Mrs N asked for a statutory transfer to a Maltese pension scheme. The trustee said it could only consider the request if she provided two legal opinions, one on English law and one on Maltese law, confirming that the Maltese arrangement was a Qualifying Recognised Overseas Pension Scheme. Mrs N did not provide the opinions and instead transferred her benefits to a Self Invested Personal Pension and then on to the same Maltese scheme.

Mrs N later complained that the trustee had blocked her statutory transfer by requiring two legal opinions, even though there was no legal requirement for the trustee to get them.

The Deputy Ombudsman rejected Mrs N’s complaint. She found that for transfers made before 2021, trustees were required to be satisfied that any overseas scheme met the conditions in the Occupational Pension Schemes Transfer Values Regulations 1996. This included confirming that the receiving arrangement was a Qualified Recognised Overseas Pension Scheme under the Finance Act 2004. Trustees therefore had to form their own view on the overseas scheme’s status. The Ombudsman held that working out whether an overseas pension arrangement satisfied foreign pensions and tax rules was beyond what trustees could reasonably be expected to judge themselves. Requiring specialist legal opinions was therefore a legitimate and proportionate way for the trustee to meet its statutory duties.

Commentary

For trustees this decision reinforces that, where an overseas scheme’s status cannot be verified without expert input, it remains reasonable to ask the member to provide appropriate legal evidence.

Although the case related to a pre-2021 transfer (before the introduction of the statutory transfers regime in the Occupational and Personal Pension Schemes Conditions for Transfers Regulations 2021), it is helpful for all transfer cases where trustees are considering whether a scheme qualifies as a Qualified Recognised Overseas Pension Scheme under the Finance Act 2004.

Contact