Three recent determinations from the Pensions Ombudsman confirm a marked shift in the approach to pre-2021 transfer complaints. Taken together, Mr D, Mrs T and Mr S reinforce a consistent message: trustees had no statutory duty to carry out broader due diligence checks or issue scam warnings when processing pre-2021 transfer requests (both statutory and discretionary transfer requests). The cases make clear that recommendations in TPR’s Scorpion leaflet or 2013 and 2014 Action Packs are to be treated as non-binding guidance only.
However, all three decisions do emphasise that a trustee can still become responsible for undertaking wider due diligence if it voluntarily assumes that responsibility. The Mr S determination provides the clearest guidance on this point with some helpful considerations:
- Routine questions by a trustee needed to confirm statutory or scheme conditions do not amount to an assumption of responsibility.
- An assumption of responsibility only arises where the trustee tells the member it is carrying out due diligence for their benefit, and it is reasonable and foreseeable that the member will rely on this.
- Certain factors point against any assumption, including where the member has an IFA and the trustee is aware of this and where the member has been sent, and has acknowledged reading, the Scorpion leaflet.
Note: the position is different for transfers made after the Occupational and Personal Pension Schemes (Conditions for Transfers) Regulations 2021 (Transfer Regulations) came into force on November 30, 2021. This is because the Transfer Regulations introduced a statutory due diligence regime which trustees must comply with.
NRF Commentary
These determinations will be welcome news for schemes and will assist trustees and advisers in responding to complaints regarding pre-2021 transfers. In particular, TPR guidance materials, even when widely followed in practice, did not create additional legal duties for trustees to comply with, and trustees were only required to ensure statutory and scheme transfer requirements were met.
Trustees should nevertheless remain alert to the risk that they may have voluntarily assumed responsibility. Communications that stated or implied that the trustee is performing checks for the member’s protection should be considered. Written confirmation that the member has received warnings (e.g. Scorpion leaflet) and is taking advice from an IFA can assist in demonstrating that no assumption has occurred.
It is worth noting that while these determinations are fact specific, the Ombudsman’s reasoning is presented as having general application to pre-2021 transfers. However, the suggestion that trustees never owe a duty to conduct further due diligence or to alert members to obvious scam indicators for pre-2021 transfers is not beyond challenge, and the Ombudsman’s approach (which itself has evolved over time) ultimately remains a matter for the High Court to assess, if presented with the opportunity.