Local agencies have long used pension obligation bonds to finance unfunded retirement fund liabilities when market conditions are favorable. However, local agencies would seek court validation to confirm that voter approval was not needed—a process that often took months or years and sometimes resulted in missed financial opportunities due to market changes.
Recent actions by the California Supreme Court have clarified that voter approval is not required in connection with certain pension obligation bonds. In a pivotal decision issued on December 18, 2025 (City of San José v. Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association et al. (S285426)), the Supreme Court held that issuance of pension obligation bonds by the City of San Jose to fund an unfunded actuarial liability in the City’s pension system did not require voter approval.
Following its City of San Jose decision, the California Supreme Court dismissed review and let stand the Court of Appeal Second Appellate District decision in City of Oxnard v. Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association et al. (S287599) (with the City of Oxnard represented by Norton Rose Fulbright US LLP), as well as the Court of Appeal Fourth Appellate District decision in City of Escondido v. Fawcett (S286239). Both cases had held that local public employers in the California Public Employees Retirement System (CalPERS) can issue pension obligation bonds without voter approval.
Local public employers can now rely on these three new pension obligation bond cases to forgo judicial validation proceedings and take advantage of favorable market conditions without delay.