Overview
Actuaries are being encouraged to take a very pragmatic and relaxed approach to certifying legacy rule changes as compliant. The Pension Schemes Bill offers a fix for historic changes identified as invalid by judgments in the Virgin Media case in 2023 and 2024, but it requires an actuarial certificate. Guidance now issued by the Financial Reporting Council encourages actuaries to take a practical and proportionate approach to that certificate. We expect many schemes to be able to remove the ambiguity created by the Virgin Media case, even where complete records are not available.
Context refresher
The Court of Appeal in the Virgin Media case confirmed that amendments to contracted-out DB pension schemes had required written actuarial confirmation that the changes had been considered by the scheme actuary, and that the statutory reference scheme test continued to be satisfied (this only applies to changes between 1997 and 2016). Without that confirmation, the change was invalid. This created significant uncertainty about the validity of many historical amendments where no such actuarial confirmation was received, or where schemes are unable to provide evidence of a confirmation. Our digest of the Virgin Media judgment is here.
The Government’s fix
To reduce the uncertainty created by the Virgin Media case, the Pension Schemes Bill introduces a legislative remedy. If the Bill is passed in its current form, trustees will be able to validate most historical amendments that needed, but didn’t have, actuarial confirmation by getting a retrospective confirmation of compliance from the scheme’s appointed actuary. To give that confirmation, the Bill would require the actuary to be satisfied that it is “reasonable to conclude” that the change would not have stopped the scheme from “continuing to satisfy” the reference scheme test in place at the time of the amendment.
The Bill will not let trustees treat the retrospective confirmation as a wider sign-off on historic contracting-out compliance, for example if changes to pay structures undermined the scheme’s benefit structure, but it will clear amendments to the scheme’s rules.
The FRC has now published some helpful guidance for actuaries asked to give a retrospective actuarial confirmation.
What does the guidance say?
The guidance adopts a very pragmatic approach:
- Certainty is not required: actuaries do not need to be certain that the scheme would still have satisfied the reference scheme test after the amendment. It is enough for the actuary to reasonably conclude that the test would still have been met after the amendment. In drawing this conclusion, actuaries are encouraged to take a proportionate approach and to reach a reasoned and justifiable conclusion taking into account all relevant factors.
- Sufficient data is required, complete data is not required: actuaries only need sufficient, not complete evidence, and can make assumptions and presumptions based on the data available to them in deciding whether it is reasonable to conclude the scheme would continue to satisfy the reference scheme test after the amendment. The guidance recognises that data gaps are to be expected and encourages actuaries to consider indirect evidence such as legal advice, trustee minutes and member communications.
- Presumption the reference scheme test was satisfied: the presumption is that the reference scheme test was satisfied immediately before the amendment took effect. The actuary only needs to assess the impact of the amendment itself, and not any changes (for example, changes to pay structures) over time which would affect whether the reference scheme test was met.
The guidance offers clear and practical steers on the completeness of data and the degree of certainty an actuary needs when deciding whether to provide a retrospective confirmation. The guidance also includes sample scenarios, helpfully setting out what data is required in each scenario to enable the actuary to provide a retrospective confirmation.
Where things may get tricky
The guidance makes clear that where the actuary considers an amendment to fall outside the scope of the reference scheme test but the trustees disagree, the burden shifts to the trustees to show that a retrospective confirmation is required. In this scenario, we expect trustees will benefit from legal advice on the scope and necessity of seeking a retrospective confirmation.
Where an actuary requests evidence that could be time-consuming and/or costly to provide, the trustees will need to balance the cost and timing implications of seeking this evidence against proceeding on the basis the amendment was invalid. If the change is treated as invalid it could have knock-on implications on future transactions, including risk transfer transactions such as buy-ins, and the affordability of running the scheme on. The scheme employer may also take an interest in this process, given it will ultimately be on risk for any increased costs.
Delivering the evidence required by the actuary may not be completely straightforward. There is a risk of losing legal privilege in advice if it is shared with the scheme actuary. Trustees should be mindful of that risk when sharing historic documents and correspondence with the actuary and should consider alternatives, such as providing a summary of the amendment’s effect instead.
Action points
While the Pension Schemes Bill has not yet received Royal Assent, it’s unlikely the legislative remedy for the Virgin Media issue will change materially. That means we have a green light to start the work, so that actuarial confirmations can be given as soon as the Bill becomes law. Trustees and employers should now start considering next steps with their advisers, e.g.:
- Identify any amendments that require, or potentially require, a retrospective confirmation.
- Locate the historic documentation and correspondence surrounding the changes.
- Work with the scheme actuary to confirm the data and evidence the actuary could need to provide the relevant retrospective confirmations.
- Identify any gaps, and agree a solution in line with the FRC guidance.
Comment
The guidance is sensible, pragmatic and sufficiently flexible. It should provide scheme actuaries the comfort to form reasonable conclusions on a proportionate basis, which in turn allows trustees and employers to remove uncertainty created by Virgin Media.
The presumption that the scheme satisfied the reference scheme test immediately prior to the amendment is helpful, particularly with consolidating deeds as it removes the need to trace earlier versions of the rules. We expect that this presumption will also work where not all deeds from the period in question can be located, but all the deeds that are found would have satisfied the reference scheme test.
There could still be areas that won’t be straightforward. There may be disagreement between trustees and the actuary about whether or not particular amendments actually require confirmation. There was fierce debate in the industry when the first Virgin Media judgment came out on what amendments were and were not caught by the old contracting-out requirements and the reference scheme test itself. This debate may be played out further when the Verity decision is available. Our hope is that the actuarial profession will take an equally pragmatic approach to giving confirmations where there might be differing views as to whether confirmation is actually needed.