The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has published supplementary guidance to its Green Claims Code, providing greater clarity on how responsibility for environmental claims is allocated between businesses operating at different points in a supply chain.

The guidance responds to questions raised by businesses since the Green Claims Code was introduced in 2021, particularly in relation to claims that rely on information originating upstream but are communicated to consumers by brands or retailers.

The guidance does not change the underlying legal framework but provides further explanation of how the CMA expects consumer protection law to apply in practice where environmental claims are made across complex supply chains. We summarise the key points below.

Green Claims Code: supply-chain responsibility

The Green Claims Code sets out principles designed to ensure that environmental and sustainability‑related claims made to consumers are truthful, clear, accurate and capable of substantiation. The new guidance emphasises that responsibility for compliance with these principles may extend beyond the business that directly presents a claim to consumers.

In particular, the CMA explains that responsibility for an environmental claim may arise where a business plays a role in creating, substantiating or communicating that claim, even if it did not originate the underlying information.

Shared responsibility and enforcement considerations

Where an environmental claim depends on information provided by another business in the supply chain, responsibility for ensuring the accuracy of the claim may be shared between the business supplying the information and the business communicating the claim to consumers.

The guidance confirms that, when assessing compliance and enforcement priorities, the CMA will consider:

  • the role each business plays in creating or communicating the claim;
  • the information held by each business; and
  • the steps that it would have been reasonable for that business to take to ensure the claim was accurate and not misleading.

This reflects a case‑specific approach rather than a presumption that liability rests solely with the retailer or brand.

The guidance also states that the CMA is more likely to view practices as egregious where there is clear guidance in place and where businesses do not have appropriate internal processes in place to ensure their environmental claims are accurate.

Evidence and access to data

All green claims must be supported by appropriate evidence before they are made. The guidance makes clear that practical difficulties in accessing upstream information do not remove the obligation to substantiate claims.

Businesses may therefore need to take proactive steps to obtain sufficient comfort in the accuracy of environmental information relied upon, for example through assurances, contractual commitments or supporting documentation from suppliers or manufacturers.

Repeating and promoting third-party claims

The CMA also clarifies that a business may be treated as “making” a green claim where it repeats or promotes a claim that originated with another party. This may include, for example, the use of third‑party claims in product descriptions, online listings, marketing materials or imagery.

Businesses should therefore exercise caution when relying on environmental claims provided by others and ensure that such claims can be properly supported.

Takeaways

The guidance underlines that environmental claims raise broader compliance considerations and should not be viewed solely as a marketing issue. Businesses that make or repeat green claims may wish to review their internal governance, contractual arrangements and verification processes to ensure that claims made across their supply chains can be substantiated and are not misleading.

Contact