The Texas Business Court recently issued summary judgment opinions in two cases relating to the internal affairs of limited liability companies—Quintero v. Urban Infraconstruction, LLC and Crain v. Northern. In these cases, the Texas Business Court enforced LLC agreements and statutory requirements as written, rejecting attempts to circumvent their plain language.
Adherence to the statutory framework for LLCs
In Quintero, the First Division of the Texas Business Court applied the plain language of the Texas Business Organizations Code (the Code) in interpreting allegations related to partnership and membership in an LLC. 2026 Tex. Bus. 3, Cause No. 25-BC01A-0022. The Texas Business Court rejected the claim of the individual plaintiff, Quintero, that he was a member in the defendant LLC.
The Texas Business Court examined the three statutory pathways to LLC membership:
- being named an initial member in the certificate of formation
- being admitted as a member in connection with formation or
- being admitted with all members’ consent after formation. See Tex. Bus. Org. Code §101.103.
The Texas Business Court found that Quintero was not listed as a member in the LLC’s certificate of formation. The Texas Business Court also noted that Quintero argued he was a partner—not that he was admitted as a member of the LLC nor that he had obtained any consent after the LLC’s formation.
The Texas Business Court was unpersuaded by the LLC’s balance sheet, which allegedly evidenced Quintero’s capital contribution. The balance sheet was not “written evidence or records of the [company] demonstrating his contributions.” The Texas Business Court noted that the list of company records in the Code does not include balance sheets. See Tex. Bus. Org. Code §101.501.
The Texas Business Court found that evidence of a deposit, on its own, did not evidence admission as an LLC member. The Code does not require a capital contribution for membership in an LLC, so the Texas Business Court held that “membership is not contingent upon—or proven by—evidence of a capital contribution to the company.” See Tex. Bus. Org. Code §101.102.
For these reasons, the Texas Business Court rejected all of Quintero’s claims based on his alleged membership in the defendant LLC. In doing so, the Texas Business Court rejected any attempt to circumvent the Texas Business Organizations Code’s statutory framework for limited liability companies.
Enforcement of company agreements’ “Buy-Sell Option” clauses
In Crain v. Northern, the Eighth Division addressed a dispute between the two founders and equal owners (Crain and Northern) of three LLCs. 2026 Tex. Bus. 4, Cause No. 25-BC08A-0014. Crain alleged that Northern breached its fiduciary duties to Crain and the LLCs. Northern sought a declaratory judgment and specific performance requiring Crain to sell his membership interests to Northern.
Pursuant to the company agreements’ “Buy-Sell Option” clauses, Northern had initiated a mandatory buy-sell option by providing written notice to Crain. The clauses required Crain to elect, within 30 days, whether to buy Northern’s interest or sell his own interest to Northern.
Crain did not make an election and, per the agreements, he was “conclusively deemed” to have elected a sale of his interest. But Crain challenged the validity of the company agreements and alleged Northern’s prior breaches and unclean hands precluded enforcement of the “Buy-Sell Option” clauses. The Texas Business Court rejected these arguments, ruling Crain failed to produce evidence to support them.
The Texas Business Court also enforced the plain language of the “Buy-Sell Option” clauses, finding the language was “definite, unwavering, and agreed by both parties,” and “le[ft] little room for interpretation.” The Texas Business Court also stated that “contractual buy-sell mechanisms . . . must be exercised or timely challenged in the manner the agreement prescribes . . . .”
The Texas Business Court ordered Crain to assign his interests effective as of the date required by the “Buy-Sell Options” clause. The Texas Business Court also awarded Northern his attorneys’ fees requested pursuant to Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 38.001(8).**
Conclusion
In Quintero v. Urban Infraconstruction, LLC and Crain v. Northern, the Texas Business Court adhered to the language of valid agreements and relevant statutes. Practitioners before the Texas Business Court who seek to avoid the plain language of a statute or agreement should be prepared with admissible evidence and supporting case law to avoid summary judgment on their claims.
Tracking activities of the Texas Business Court and beyond