On March 4, 2026, the US Court of International Trade (CIT) issued a sweeping order in Atmus Filtration, Inc. v. United States (Case Number: 1:26-cv-01259) directing US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) to liquidate and, where appropriate, reliquidate entries without regard to duties imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA). The court ordered refunds for all unliquidated entries and liquidated entries that have not yet become final. The order did not address entries that have already liquidated and become final. The Department of Justice is likely to appeal the order.

Key takeaways

The order follows the Supreme Court’s decision in  Learning Resources v. Trump  holding that IEEPA does not authorize the imposition of tariffs. Key takeaways from this new order include:

  • Broad refund directive: The order directs CBP to liquidate “any and all” unliquidated entries subject to IEEPA duties without those duties, and to reliquidate any entries for which liquidation is not yet final. The order emphasizes that all importers of record with such entries are entitled to the benefit of the Supreme Court's ruling.
  • Judge assignment and national reach: The CIT confirmed that one judge will preside over all IEEPA refund cases, minimizing the risk of inconsistent outcomes. The court also pre-empted arguments that its order amounts to an improper "universal injunction," noting that the CIT has exclusive nationwide jurisdiction over customs matters by design – implying that the court is not overreaching, but rather exercising the authority it was specifically established to have.
  • Open questions on interest and finality: The order does not decide whether CBP must pay interest on refunds, nor does it address entries that have liquidated and become final. Refund eligibility for such entries remains uncertain and may depend on protest posture, timing and future guidance or rulings.
  • Accelerated posture: The case moved from complaint to order within days, with the court posing specific operational questions to the government on refund administration, post-decision liquidation practices and whether CBP will pay refunds with interest. A closed conference at which CBP is expected to provide an update on its refund plans is scheduled for March 6, 2026.

Likely appeal and next steps

The Department of Justice is likely to appeal this order to the Federal Circuit and will likely seek a stay of the CIT's order pending appeal. If granted, a stay could pause CBP's obligation to issue refunds while the appeal is litigated. Importers should therefore keep in mind that this order, while significant, may not be the final word.

If the order stands, it represents an encouraging step toward cash recovery, as it gives CBP a clear mandate to remove IEEPA duties from all unliquidated and not-yet-final entries, seemingly without the need for further legal action by individual importers. However, the order does not provide a timeline or mechanism for CBP to administer such refunds, and the government is likely to contend that doing so at this scale will require considerable time.

Implications for importers

While the order is a significant development, it leaves a number of practical questions unresolved. The order does not establish a timeline or detailed mechanism for CBP to administer refunds on a nationwide basis, and the potential for a government appeal introduces further uncertainty.

Importers should therefore continue to assess the status of their entries and file post-summary corrections (PSCs) for unliquidated entries and protests for liquidated entries as deadlines approach, as needed. These remain important tools for preserving refund rights regardless of the ultimate shape of the court-ordered refund process. If the order stands as issued, such actions may not ultimately be necessary. However, given the uncertainty surrounding a potential appeal, taking such protective steps may still provide importers with a measure of assurance that their refund rights are being preserved.

Refund eligibility for entries that have liquidated and become final remains uncertain. Importers with such entries should carefully evaluate their protest posture and monitor for CBP guidance or further court rulings that may clarify the path to recovery for those entries.

Some importers may still choose to file suit at the CIT to protect their individual refund rights, particularly where entries are approaching finality or where interest is at issue. While the order states that importers who did not file suit are entitled to the benefits of the Supreme Court's decision, there may be strategic reasons to file, including to address interest, finality disputes or other case-specific issues.

We will continue to monitor the court’s proceedings, any government appeals and CBP’s operational guidance on implementing refunds. If you have questions about how the order applies to your entries or how best to position refund claims, please contact the Norton Rose Fulbright trade team.

card-grid-item, aem-sourced
Navigating international trade
and tariffs

Impacts of evolving trade regulations and compliance risks

/en/insights/publications/navigating-international-trade-and-tariffs

Contact