This article was co-authored with Eloise Cook.

Introduction

On 27 February 2026, the Federal Court handed down the long-awaited Davey Davey on behalf of the Gudanji, Yanyuwa and Yanyuwa-Marra Peoples v Northern Territory of Australia (No 5) (McArthur River Project Compensation Claim) [2026] FCA 15. decision, ordering the Northern Territory Government to pay over $54.7 million to the Gudanji, Yanyuwa and Yanyuwa-Marra Traditional Owners as compensation for economic, cultural and spiritual losses suffered due to the expansion of McArthur River Mine.

This decision is significant, as it is only the second instance of a superior court quantifying Native Title compensation, and the first to apply the framework established by the High Court in Timber Creek. Northern Territory of Australia v Griffiths[2017] FCAFC 106. Unlike Timber Creek, the compensation claim in the Davey case was not brought under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (NTA), but under the McArthur River Project Agreement Ratification Act 1992 (NT). The Court nevertheless applied the Timber Creek principles by analogy, holding that the purpose and objects of both statutes are “so closely aligned”Davey, [558]. that a different methodology would be inappropriate.

The $54 million awarded for cultural and spiritual loss in Davey also dwarfs the High Court's award of $1.3 million for the same category of loss in Timber Creek, recognising the scale of non-economic harm suffered by the Traditional Owners. In particular, Justice Banks-Smith affirmed the High Court's methodology, applying it to harm of a greater scale.

The Davey decision therefore builds on the compensation principles established in Timber Creek, but applies them in a larger-scale mining context. It recognises that native title compensation must account for intangible losses, including grief, distress, and the disruption to cultural responsibilities causing profound cultural and spiritual harm.

Native title and compensable acts

Native Title is a bundle of rights held by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in relation to land and waters according to their traditional law and customs.Native Title Act 1993(Cth), s 223(1) Native Title rights were first recognized in the pivotal Mabo (No 2) Mabo v Queensland (No 2) [1992] HCA 23; (1992) 175 CLR 1. decision which the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (NTA) now legislates. Where an act, such as a grant of freehold land or the construction of public works, extinguishes or is otherwise inconsistent with Native Title rights and interests, it constitutes a "compensable act" under the NTA, giving rise to that compensatory entitlement. Native Title Act 1993(Cth), ss 22, 226, & 227.

The NTA frames Native Title as a dual concept, encompassing both a physical right to perform activities on the land, and a cultural or spiritual connection with the land.Ibid, s 223(1). It is this dual nature that underpins the Court’s approach to compensation, providing for both economic and non-economic loss.

Davey confirmed that the dual-limbed approach is supported by the breadth of the language in the NTA’s mandate, that Native Title holders must be compensated for “any loss, diminution, impairment or other effect.” Native Title Act 1993(Cth), s 51(1). While s 51A of the NTA imposes a cap on compensation linked to freehold land value, Timber Creek confirmed that this cap does not limit the cultural loss component. This distinction proved decisive in Davey where the cultural loss award alone vastly exceeded the freehold value of the affected land.

The Davey decision

Until Davey, the High Court's 2019 decision in Timber Creek was the only precedent on the assessment of Native Title compensation. Timber Creek established the bifurcated approach to compensation, and it is this framework that Justice Banks-Smith drew upon in Davey.

Davey provides the first opportunity to see that framework applied to a greater scale of cultural loss. Justice Banks-Smith awarded Gudanji, Yanyuwa and Yanyuwa-Marra traditional owners $54 million for non-economic, cultural and spiritual losses and $743,408 plus interest for economic loss.

The McArthur River mine sits on one of the world's largest zinc and lead deposits. The mine, and its associated port operations at Bing Bong are located within the McArthur River perpetual pastoral lease, which covers approximately 7,225 square kilometres in the northeast of the Northern Territory.Davey, [48]. The compensation claim area comprised approximately 130.7 square kilometres. The compensable acts included the grant of mineral leases in 1993, retrospective legislative validation of the conversion from underground to open-cut mining in 2007, non-pastoral use permits for the port, a connecting road, and a gas pipeline licence.Ibid, [3]. Critically, the conversion to open-cut mining required the diversion of 5.5 kilometres of the McArthur River, an act described by witnesses as “cutting the Snake,”Ibid, [1056]. a reference to the two Walungudara (Rainbow Snake) Dreamings of profound spiritual significance associated with the river and the mine area.

The trial proceeded with an on-country hearing in June 2023, followed by expert evidence and closing submissions in November 2023. In December 2025, after the trial but before judgment, the Claim Group and McArthur River Mining Pty Ltd executed an Indigenous Land Use Agreement (ILUA), which became relevant to the assessment of cultural loss.

Cultural and spiritual loss

Justice Banks-Smith held that there “is no doubt that the impact of the mine and port on the rights and interests of the Claim Group is felt beyond those particular sites, is intergenerational and is enduring.”Davey, [10]. In a striking aphorism, her Honour observed that “sometimes the site of the pain is not the site of the injury.”Ibid. Cultural loss, her Honour held, encompasses the full breadth of that impact, including:

“the irreversible disturbance of Dreaming sites and routes; the inability of the Claim Group to stop that disturbance or to continue to protect the Dreamings; the inability to access areas in a manner that permits the continuation of knowledge and customs between generations; the attenuation of such knowledge and customs over time; the inability to access sacred sites; the limitation on caring for country; and the cultural sensitivities that flow from what is regarded by some as a failure to care for country.”Ibid.

This “diminution of traditional connection to country - to receive from country and to take care of country is compensable loss.”Ibid.

The Court received extensive lay and expert anthropological evidence about the Claim Group's connection to country. Justice Banks-Smith described the nature of their connection in detail, in particular the Dreamings “give meaning to each area, give rights and responsibilities, and are pervasive.”Ibid, [1401]. People “share an internal spiritual essence with the land and its Dreamings.”Ibid. There are reciprocal obligations: “the native title holders look after the land, and the land feeds them and the spirits keep them safe. If country is harmed, people feel a sense of unease, or binji, and spiritual sanctions may follow.”Ibid.

Her Honour found that the impact of the compensable acts was “not confined to the area or areas covered by particular or individual compensable acts” but must “be understood in a wider setting informed by the laws and customs, and cultural beliefs and practices, of the native title holders.”Ibid, [943].The harm to Country had “…a ‘flow on effect' due to the pervasiveness of the Dreamings.”Ibid, [1407].

In powerful testimony, Billy Coolibah (deceased) said in his affidavit:

“When that open cut mine happened, it destroyed the country real bad. They cut open the country and they moved the river. Now when I see that mine, it make me feel no good. That feeling you get when you‘re worried about country, it‘s called gurunulu. It means your heart is no good and you‘re feeling sad. And my mind is really sad too because I'm worried for my people because that country is hurt by the mine. The country been damaged up, they gone in like a mob of worms. Then they diverted the river, that snake is still there, nobody can change that snake, but when they diverted the river, they cut that snake dreaming. Bad things happen when you cut the dreaming. Bad things like people getting sick. I think some people have got sick from the mine. We're frightened all the time.”

Jack Green described the open pit as “the guts of the Snake” and said that “when the Mine dug the open cut, they dug right into the Davey Snake… When they moved the River and dug up the country around it, they took the spirit away from the country… The spirit of the country is important to Aboriginal people; it‘s like our wealth. It‘s what we pass on to the next generation.”Ibid, [1610]. The extensive and impactful evidence, Justice Banks-Smith concluded, “viewed collectively paints a profound picture of the harm done by the compensable acts in a number of ways: some relating to the Dreamings; some to the physical country; some to the inability to pass on knowledge; and some related to shame from disempowerment and the inability to take care of country.”Ibid, [1107].

The community-standards test

To determine the appropriate quantum of cultural loss, Justice Banks-Smith adopted the community-standards test established in Timber Creek, a “social judgment” of what the Australian community would consider a fair or just award.Ibid, [934].Her Honour acknowledged that “where there is no algorithm, no tariff and little precedent, forming a reasoned view as to a figure that the Australian community would rightly regard as an appropriate award is complex,”Ibid, [1386].  and that “reasonable judicial minds might differ, on the same evidence, as to the appropriate level of compensation.”Ibid. Any figure arrived at can be only artificial, but it must be accepted by the Australian community as appropriate, fair or just, providing a principled basis for appellate review.

The Applicants proposed mathematical scaling from Timber Creek on a per-hectare basis, which would have yielded approximately $133.79 million. Justice Banks-Smith treated this as, at best, a rough check on parameters, holding that “cultural loss is not dependent upon size.”Ibid, [1391]. Her Honour did find, however, that “the Australian community would readily accept that the impact of the compensable acts the subject of this proceeding greatly exceeds that considered in Griffiths [Timber Creek].”Ibid, [1394].

Her Honour noted that “[w]here there is no algorithm, no tariff and little precedent, forming a reasoned view as to a figure that the Australian community would rightly regard as an appropriate award is complex. Reasonable judicial minds might differ, on the same evidence, as to the appropriate level of compensation”.Ibid, [1386]. Ultimately, the Court concluded that the appropriate award for cultural loss to the Applicants was $60 million (which was adjusted to $54 million for the reasons discussed below).Ibid, [1420].

The ILUA

A novel feature of Davey was the treatment of the ILUA executed between the Claim Group and McArthur River Mining in December 2025, before judgment was handed down.

The Court found that certain benefits in the ILUA, specifically the establishment of Gudanji Rangers, funding for a cultural artefacts keeping place, enhanced access to sacred sites and improved consultation frameworks, would to a small extent diminish the ongoing cultural loss. However, the Court rejected the Northern Territory’s submission that the ILUA amounted to “consent” to the mine or a “complete answer” to cultural loss.Ibid, [1566].

Instead, Justice Banks-Smith held that “the fact that the Claim Group, faced with the (partly) irreversible presence and effects of a mine, entered into a commercial agreement whereby they ‘consent’ to mineral leases that must be renewed, in consideration for certain payments and other benefits, does not to my mind transform the history of loss and diminution of rights by way of the compensable acts.”Ibid, [1531].

The quantification of the diminution of cultural loss caused by the ILUA was determined to be a 10 per cent reduction in the award for cultural damages, producing the final award of $54 million.Ibid, [1567].

The Court rejected the Northern Territory’s arguments that the 1994 Commonwealth Agreement, a 2007 Community Benefits Trust, or employment at the mine, constituted benefits that should reduce cultural loss.Ibid, [1555]. Notably, in relation to the 2007 Community Benefits Trust, the Court was influenced by the express statement in the Chief Minister’s letter that the benefits “[were] not intended and did not address native title compensation,”Ibid, [1403]. holding that “it would be wrong, in the face of this statement…to diminish the liability of the Northern Territory because of these benefits.” Ibid, [1498].

Economic loss

Davey affirmed the Timber Creek economic loss methodology, applying the principle that the economic value of affected Native Title land is determined by reference to its freehold value, discounted to reflect the limited nature of the specific Native Title rights held. The Court rejected the Claim Group’s alternative “hypothetical comparable bargain” based on mining royalties as inconsistent with the statutory purpose and risking double recovery.Ibid, [558].

Justice Banks-Smith assessed the native title rights at 55 per cent of freehold value, slightly above the 50 per cent in Timber Creek, recognising that the Claim Group’s rights were somewhat broader, including the right to exercise native title for commercial purposes. A further 35 per cent discount was applied to the non-pastoral use permits for temporal limitations. The total economic loss was assessed at $743,408, with an entitlement to statutory interest.

Implications

Davey is a landmark decision for native title compensation in Australia, with significant implications for Native Title holders, governments and private industry. Below are some of the primary implications following the decision, which are likely to impact how future compensation claims are brought before the Courts:

  • Compensation for cultural loss is uncapped and scalable. The amount of the cultural loss award demonstrates that the community-standards test can produce vastly different outcomes depending on the nature, scale and severity of the compensable acts. The decision confirms that the statutory cap on compensation linked to freehold value (s 51A of the NTA) does not limit the cultural loss award, and that awards in the tens of millions of dollars are within the permissible range where the impact on connection to country is severe.
  • Extension beyond the NTA. The application of Timber Creek principles to a claim under project-specific legislation broadens the reach of those principles. Compensation frameworks in analogous statutory regimes may now be interpreted consistently with Timber Creek.
  • The Timber Creek framework has now been applied. Davey affirms the compensatory principles of Timber Creek, the bifurcated approach, freehold-value benchmark for economic loss, and the community-standards test for cultural loss.
  • ILUAs and third-party benefits may reduce, but not eliminate, liability. The treatment of the ILUA in Davey establishes that agreements between native title holders and third parties may only result in a modest reduction in liability, where specific benefits address the same cultural loss. Further, benefits that are expressly stated as not directed at compensation, or general commercial payments, will not reduce the award. This has practical significance for the structuring of future ILUAs and the negotiation posture of government respondents.

The NTA’s compensation provisions were enacted to rectify the consequences of the progressive dispossession of Aboriginal peoples and Torres Strait Islanders. Davey shows that the statutory promise of compensation on just terms can mean compensation of a significant quantum, having regard to the extent of cultural loss suffered by native title holders. As Justice Banks-Smith found, the connection to country “has been compromised for over 30 years and will be forever compromised.”Ibid, [1289].

Contact