Reproduced from Practical Law with the permission of the publishers. For further information visit www.practicallaw.com.

In NextEra Energy Global Holdings BV and another v Kingdom of Spain [2026] SGHC 43, the Singapore High Court upheld the registration of an Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) award under the ICSID Convention, rejecting state immunity and intra-EU objections raised by the respondent state.

The Singapore High Court has dismissed an application to set aside the registration of an Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) award for enforcement under the ICSID Convention, rejecting state immunity and intra-EU objections raised by the respondent state.

The ICSID tribunal issued the award in favour of Dutch investors against the Kingdom of Spain. Spain's efforts to annul the award before an ad hoc ICSID committee and to resist enforcement in several jurisdictions had found no success.

When the Dutch investors sought enforcement in Singapore pursuant to the Arbitration (International Investment Disputes) Act 1968 (AIIDA), which implements Singapore's obligations under the ICSID Convention, the state raised three objections primarily based on state immunity.

The court rejected all three objections.

First, the state argued that it retained immunity under section 4 of the State Immunity Act 1979 (SIA) because it had not submitted to the jurisdiction of the Singapore courts in relation to recognition or enforcement. In line with various other jurisdictions, the court held that a state's accession to the ICSID Convention amounts to a waiver of adjudicative immunity and submission to the jurisdiction of the courts of other contracting states in relation to recognition or enforcement of ICSID awards.

Second, the state argued that it retained immunity under section 11 of the SIA because there was no valid arbitration agreement that gave rise to the award. The court held that article 26 of the ECT did give rise to a valid arbitration agreement between the state and the Dutch investors. The state's intra-EU objection, that there cannot be a valid arbitration agreement between an EU member state and the national of another EU member state, was also rejected by the court.

Finally, the court rejected the state's invitation to set aside the registration order in the interests of justice because the award contravened EU law and the state's constitutional arrangements with the EU. This was not a recognised ground for challenging an ICSID award, and doing so would be contrary to the ICSID Convention and the AIIDA.

This decision affirms Singapore's enforcement-friendly stance in relation to investor-state awards. It is the second investor-state enforcement case in recent months (following DNZ v DOA [2026] SGHC(I) 1) in which state immunity and intra-EU objections have not found favour in the Singapore courts (see Legal update, Singapore International Commercial Court upholds ECT award against Poland in favour of UK investors in intra-EU dispute).

Case: NextEra Energy Global Holdings BV and another v Kingdom of Spain [2026] SGHC 43 (24 February 2026) (Maniam J).

Contact