In September 2025 the consumer advocacy group Which? submitted a super-complaint to the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) regarding home and travel insurance (the Complaint) (see our earlier briefing). We set out below our thoughts on considerations for firms in light of the FCA’s response followed by a deeper dive on the response including: action the FCA is taking; what this signifies in terms of the FCA’s approach to the Consumer Duty (the Duty); and what this means for firms beyond the home and travel insurance sector.

Consumer Duty considerations for firms

The FCA's response is a reminder that the Duty is not merely a compliance exercise but an ongoing supervisory framework through which the FCA will assess – and intervene – on outcomes firms deliver to their consumers. Firms should be prepared for increased supervisory scrutiny in this area, as the FCA is increasingly focussing on its assertive supervision tools to address harm more quickly either in preference to or in combination with enforcement action.

In light of the FCA's response to Which?, firms across retail financial services should consider taking steps to:

(a) review their Duty implementation to ensure outcomes monitoring is robust, particularly in claims, complaints and post-sale customer support journeys;

(b) assess third-party and outsourcing arrangements to confirm that oversight frameworks enable delivery of good customer outcomes;

(c) evaluate consumer understanding at key touchpoints - including digital sales journeys - and test whether communications are enabling informed decision-making;

(d) prepare for potential senior manager attestations where the FCA identifies concerns – who might be best placed and do they have access to relevant management information (MI); and

(e) monitor the FCA's cross-sector Duty work and anticipate findings and good/ poor practice examples which may inform supervisory expectations in their own sectors.

Further information to inform such consideration is set out below.

What action is the FCA taking?

The Complaint alleged that the UK retail home and travel insurance markets were delivering persistently poor outcomes in breach of FCA rules and the Duty, causing avoidable financial and emotional harm, eroding trust in insurance and “significantly damaging the interests of consumers”.

The FCA has pointed to work already carried out in the three areas identified by Which? (which culminated in the publication of its July 2025 “Roadmap for retail insurance”) as well as ongoing and planned activity:

(a) Claims handling: Ongoing and planned actions include progressing firm level investigations and remediation; monitoring outcomes and considering further market wide action; expanding planned outsourcing oversight to cover delegated authority models and remuneration arrangements; conducting a claims service quality analysis focused on home and travel insurance; reviewing how the FCA captures claims outcomes as part of its post implementation review of its General Insurance value measures rules; and supporting the Association of British Insurers’ work on storms, cash settlements, and governance/ MI.

Having previously identified persistent weaknesses in firms' oversight of outsourced claims handling providers, including limited control over third-party arrangements, the FCA had already planned to carry out work to understand the extent of outsourcing in the market focussing on Managing General Agents. In response to the Complaint, the FCA will now broaden the scope of this work to include wider consideration of different delegated authority models, remuneration arrangements and how firms manage any resulting conflicts, with a focus on claims handling.

(b) Sales processes/ consumer understanding: The FCA has provided feedback to the four largest price comparison websites. Ongoing and planned actions include: targeted analysis of how different sales processes affect consumer outcomes; a review of how home and travel insurers are improving consumer understanding and sharing best practice with the industry; and working with industry and consumer groups to find new ways to improve consumer understanding of insurance cover.

Having recently reviewed the home and motor insurance sales journeys of the four largest price comparison websites, the FCA identified opportunities for firms to continue to deliver good outcomes to customers and shared feedback letters to firms. This included for example providing additional support to those customers who are seeking a rebuild cost for their home.

The FCA is undertaking a cross-sector review into firms' approaches to consumer understanding, focusing on testing how, and if, the changes firms have made to communications are affecting the way consumers are making decisions. As part of this review, the regulator plans to share good and poor practice examples so firms can see how the Duty is driving change and help them deliver good consumer outcomes. As a result of the Complaint the FCA will expand this review to cover home and travel insurance firms with the findings to inform further innovation or intervention where needed. The work will also inform its analysis of sales practices.

(c) Application and enforcement of rules and law: The FCA says it has continued to uphold regulatory and legal standards “with appropriate tools”. In terms of supervisory and enforcement activity, the FCA confirms that it has:

  • opened two enforcement investigations into two insurers in the home and travel markets without naming them;
  • commissioned three section 166 skilled person reviews into firms’ claims systems and controls;
  • required senior managers at three firms to attest to strengthened systems and controls;
  • asked 13 of 15 sampled home insurers to review storm and/or cash settlement handling; and
  • imposed a voluntary requirement on one firm to restrict parts of its business pending improvements.

As at December 2025, the FCA was progressing more than 100 whistleblowing cases concerning insurance firms.

Ongoing and planned actions include following up with firms on specific policy terms flagged by Which? to ensure compliance with FCA rules and consumer protection legislation and a public consultation in Q1 2026 to reflect the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 in the FCA Handbook.

The FCA’s commitment to continuing scrutiny in this area has been further emphasised by the FCA's first Regulatory Priorities report, published in February 2026, which focused on the insurance sector and confirmed that one of this year’s priorities was to "continue supervisory and enforcement investigations on home and travel insurance claims and monitor outcomes of interventions", signalling this is now an area which is firmly embedded within the FCA’s forward-looking strategic agenda.

What does the FCA’s response signify in terms of its approach to the Consumer Duty?

The FCA’s response flagged that firms “must do more” to meet the standards set by the Duty in these markets, highlighting that, compared to other insurance products, home and travel have persistently lower claims acceptance rates. In this section we summarise what the response tells us about the FCA’s expectations by reference to each of the three key areas of concern.

(a) Claims handling: Regarding the consumer support outcome, support must meet consumer needs by being accessible, timely and flexible, including for vulnerable customers, with support that is as strong post sale as pre sale and without unreasonable barriers to help, claims, switching or cancellation. Firms must interpret the requirement to focus on customer support outcomes in the context of their own business models and make changes where they identify harm.

Firms must act in good faith, communicate clearly, make sure their products and services meet consumer needs and offer fair value, and provide effective support, especially for customers in vulnerable circumstances.

(b) Inappropriate sales practices: On the consumer understanding outcome, customer communications must be clear, timely and easily understood; tailored to different needs; tested for effectiveness (including for vulnerable consumers); and responsive to buying behaviour throughout the sales process. The lower claims acceptance rates in home and travel markets may indicate lower levels of consumer understanding which may be in part due to the complexity of these policies compared to other products such as motor insurance (citing for example the lack of consumer understanding that home insurance cover does not include wear and tear). In addition, as firms innovate (including through the use of AI) firms must still meet customers’ information needs to enable them to make effective, timely and properly informed decisions.

(c) Application, enforcement and sufficiency of FCA rules: The FCA agreed there may be potential concerns around some of the policy wordings raised in the analysis by Which?, including where they may potentially be unclear, inaccurate, or out-of-date. The Duty specifically requires firms to avoid foreseeable harm and to support consumer understanding.

The range of supervisory and enforcement action being taken by the FCA underlines the FCA’s appetite to take action and intervene in the event of concerns arising regarding compliance with the Duty. The FCA has also confirmed in its first Enforcement Watch that it is investigating 6 potential Duty breaches by firms particularly in relation to fair value for consumers. Two of these investigations concern insurance firms and they were “the most serious cases” identified in its multi-firm work. In some Duty cases, the FCA has used supervisory tools, including voluntary or own initiative requirements to protect consumers whilst investigations are ongoing. You can read more about Enforcement Watch 1 here.

What does this mean for firms outside the home and travel insurance sector?

While the FCA's response to Which?'s super-complaint focuses specifically on the home and travel insurance markets, the regulatory principles, supervisory approach and Duty expectations articulated by the FCA have clear relevance across the broader retail financial services landscape and it is clear that the FCA is taking supervisory and enforcement action in respect of Duty compliance.

  • Outcomes-focused regulation and supervisory approach: The FCA's response reaffirms its commitment to outcomes-focused supervision: actively monitoring markets to identify potential consumer harm, carrying out reviews on identified issues, and using a proportionate range of tools to intervene where necessary. Firms across all sectors should expect the FCA to assess not merely technical compliance with rules, but the actual outcomes consumers are experiencing, and to deploy statutory and non-statutory tools (including skilled person reviews, attestations from senior managers, and risk mitigation plans) where outcomes fall short.
  • Consumer support and the treatment of vulnerable customers: The FCA’s expectations in this area are directly transferable to sectors such as consumer credit (where borrowers in financial difficulty require sensitive support), banking (where complaints handling and account servicing are critical touchpoints), and investment services (where retail investors may need assistance withdrawing funds or switching between products, for example). The FCA's focus on how firms identify, record and support vulnerable customers, including through the claims or complaints journey should prompt firms in all sectors to review their own vulnerability frameworks and ensure they meet Duty standards.
  • Avoidance of foreseeable harm: The Duty puts the onus on firms to be proactive and avoid causing foreseeable harm, requiring them to consider risks of harm and implement strategies to mitigate them. This obligation is sector agnostic: a mortgage lender approving an unaffordable loan or a consumer credit provider failing to identify signs of financial distress for example, face the same expectation: they must anticipate and mitigate foreseeable harm before it crystallises.
  • Outsourcing and third-party oversight: The FCA’s concerns have significant read-across to other sectors where outsourcing is prevalent – mortgage administration, debt collection, payment services and investment services for example. Firms should expect heightened scrutiny of their third-party arrangements to assess whether their outsourcing is in line with Duty expectations.
  • Consumer understanding and sales process: The FCA’s cross sector review of approaches to consumer understanding will be informative for firms in other sectors and firms should consider whether any lessons learnt can be drawn from this to inform their own sales journeys, disclosure documents and customer demand and needs assessments. The FCA’s focus on price comparison websites also has implications for distributors and aggregators in other sectors such as mortgage, credit brokers and motor finance.
  • Senior management accountability and attestations: The FCA’s use of senior manager attestations to confirm systems and controls have been strengthened is nothing new but does reiterate the FCA’s willingness to use these tools to leverage the SMCR to drive regulatory compliance, including in relation to the Duty. The tool can be used across all financial services sectors so all regulated firms should expect the FCA to hold senior managers personally accountable for delivering good outcomes (see our recent briefing on lessons learnt for senior managers from recent FCA enforcement decisions).
  • Industry collaboration and working groups: The FCA is convening a working group comprising insurance trade bodies and consumer groups to identify and test solutions to the challenges consumers face. A similar collaborative supervisory model may be replicated in other sectors. Firms should be prepared to participate in and respond to the outputs of similar supervisory initiatives. The FCA's expectation that any industry guidance developed must be consistent with the Duty indicates that any voluntary codes should be assessed against the standards of the Duty.

Contact