The situation in the Middle East has created a landscape of uncertainty for businesses with interests in the Gulf States and beyond. Supply chains are under pressure, energy markets are volatile, and the continued uncertainty presents challenges to businesses with operations in the region. For commercial parties, a number of significant legal and practical issues arise that demand careful consideration.

We have previously considered the kinds of issues that may arise from this disruption, and how they can be dealt with as a matter of English law here. We have also considered these issues from a matter of UAE law (onshore, DIFC and ADGM) (here).

In this blog, we consider those same issues from the perspective of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (“KSA”), which is a civil law system rooted in the Civil Transaction Law (“CTL”).

Frustration and Force Majeure

Under Saudi law, concepts broadly equivalent to frustration and force majeure are now codified in the Civil Transactions Law (Royal Decree No. M/191 of 2023). The CTL distinguishes between supervening events that render performance impossible and those that render performance excessively onerous. Under Article 294, where a supervening event beyond the parties’ control results in the impossibility of performing the contractual obligation, the CTL provides a mechanism for the affected obligation to be brought to an end, either in whole or in part depending on the nature of the impossibility. Where impossibility is partial, Article 110 allows the counterparty to elect either to accept partial performance with a corresponding adjustment in consideration, or to seek to terminate the contract. A court may, pursuant to Article 110, dismiss the petition for termination if the impossible part performance is insignificant compared to the overarching obligation. This represents the Saudi law framework for what, in common law systems, would be characterised as frustration. Performance must be genuinely impossible, not merely more difficult or more expensive.

In parallel, the CTL recognises a doctrine of exceptional circumstances, often described as hardship, in Article 97. Where extraordinary and unforeseeable events occur that render performance excessively onerous, the court may ultimately intervene to rebalance the contract, including by reducing the burden of performance to a reasonable level. Crucially, unlike the impossibility regime, this provision does not require performance to be impossible, only significantly more onerous than the parties could reasonably have contemplated at the time of contracting.

In this regard, the Saudi law position departs meaningfully from English law, under which mere hardship or increased cost does not relieve a party of its obligations, and aligns more closely with the civil law approach adopted in the UAE Civil Code. The statutory framework provides a potentially valuable avenue of relief for businesses facing conflict related or supply chain disruption, whether because performance is impossible or because it has become economically unsustainable.

However, the presence of these statutory mechanisms does not diminish the importance of contractual force majeure clauses. The CTL gives effect to the parties’ express contractual arrangements on force majeure, and Saudi courts will generally apply such clauses alongside the statutory provisions, provided they do not contravene public order. Businesses operating in the KSA should therefore assess whether current disruptions fall within the statutory protections afforded by the CTL and review their contracts to determine whether any express force majeure provisions are triggered by ongoing events.

Liquidated Damages

There is already significant disruption to shipping routes, energy supplies, and broader supply chains across the region. Businesses that depend on the transit of goods through the Strait of Hormuz or other affected areas face the prospect of delays, increased costs, and interruption to their operations.

Under Saudi law, liquidated damages provisions are expressly recognised under the CTL. Pursuant to Article 178, parties may agree in advance a specified amount of compensation payable in the event of non performance or delay. However, unlike the English law position, which generally enforces liquidated damages unless they constitute a penalty, Saudi law empowers the courts to increase or reduce the agreed amount to reflect the actual harm suffered, on the application of a party. In particular, Article 179(2) provides that a court may reduce (or not order) the liquidated damages award if the debtor demonstrates that the pre-agreed amount of damages was excessive to the loss actually suffered, or that the underlying obligation was partially performed. Conversely, Article 179(3) allows a court to increase the agreed amount in order to match its actual loss. This right of recourse is however limited, given that the creditor must show that the debtor’s breach which caused the harm to exceed the agreed-upon compensation was wilful or grossly negligent. As such, while liquidated damages clauses are enforceable under Saudi law, they remain subject to judicial oversight to ensure that compensation corresponds fairly to the actual harm suffered, reflecting the broader Sharia based principle that damages must be compensatory rather than punitive.

Insurance

Regardless of the particular governing law of any parties’ commercial contracts, parties operating in the region with insurance policies should review our previous note (here) to determine key issues that may affect claims and premiums.

Conclusion

The Middle East crisis presents a complex and rapidly evolving set of legal challenges for commercial entities. In response to the disruption in the region, businesses should conduct a comprehensive review of all contracts, paying particular attention to their governing law clauses, and considering how the above issues may affect their obligations under those contracts.

Businesses that act swiftly to understand their legal position under the applicable regime, engage with counterparties, and take proactive steps to mitigate risk will be best placed to navigate the uncertainty ahead.

Contact