In its March 20th decision in ProSlide Technology Inc. v WhiteWater West Industries, Ltd., 2026 FCA 59, Canada’s Federal Court of Appeal (FCA) addressed principles of patent invalidity on the grounds of overbreadth and lack of utility.

On overbreadth, the FCA found that the patent’s specification is the most reliable indicator of what the inventor contemplated. As a result, if the specification sets out variations and alternatives of a feature of the invention, it may be possible to omit that feature from the claims without making them overbroad. On utility, the FCA confirmed the low bar for establishing utility (“a mere scintilla”) and that the disclosure of embodiments reflecting informed design can provide a factual basis for a sound prediction of utility.

This article focuses on the invalidity-related aspects of this decision. For the patent infringement issues addressed by the FCA, see our previous article here.

Background

ProSlide Technology Inc. and WhiteWater West Industries, Ltd. are the largest competitors in the global water slide market. ProSlide sued WhiteWater for infringement of Canadian patents, including three patents known as the “552 Patent Family,” all entitled “Water Ride.” At trial (2024 FC 1439), the Federal Court found numerous claims were invalid for being broader than what was actually invented. The claims were not, however, invalid for lack of utility.  ProSlide appealed this decision to the FCA, while WhiteWater cross-appealed on the issue of utility.

Overbreadth

The FCA reversed the Federal Court’s finding that the 552 Patent Family claims were overbroad.

First, the FCA rejected ProSlide’s argument that there is no legal basis for invalidating a claim for being broader than what was actually invented. The FCA stated this principle was supported by its own past decisions and ProSlide had not met the threshold for overriding settled precedent.  The FCA reaffirmed that overbreadth flows from the “bargain theory” of patent law: if a patent claims more than it describes or more than the inventor has made, the patentee receives more than the bargain entitles them to.

However, the FCA reversed the Federal Court's application of the overbreadth doctrine to the facts. The trial judge had identified four “key aspects” of the invention made – each absent from one or more asserted claims – based on the inventor's testimony about what he contemplated during product development and on expert evidence as to how a skilled person would understand that work. The FCA found this approach flawed because it determined what the inventor “contemplated” without reference to the patent specification itself. The FCA noted the specification is “an explicit and carefully written statement [...] of what the inventor had in mind.”

Critically, each of the four allegedly essential features that the Federal Court had found missing from the claims was in fact explicitly described in the specification as having alternatives and variations. For instance, while the Federal Court found that the combination of a non-zero roll angle with a pitch angle of zero was an essential feature of the invention and so should have been included in the patents’ claims, the FCA noted from the specification that other combinations of these parameters were contemplated. The finding of invalidity for overbreadth was thus reversed.

Utility

The FCA then turned its attention to the utility of the asserted claims, as WhiteWater had cross-appealed, arguing the Federal Court had misapplied the disclosure requirement for a sound prediction of utility. The FCA rejected WhiteWater’s arguments and maintained the claims as valid.

As detailed by the Federal Court, utility can be established by either demonstration or sound prediction. Sound prediction requires three components: a factual basis, an articulable and sound line of reasoning, and proper disclosure. WhiteWater asserted the Federal Court had failed to recognize that testing was needed to satisfy the disclosure requirement and had erred in concluding there was adequate disclosure of the factual basis for a sound prediction.

The FCA found no palpable and overriding error in the Federal Court's conclusion that the patent specifications disclosed both the factual basis – computer-aided designs simulating ride paths – and the line of reasoning supporting utility. The FCA stated the threshold for sound prediction is not high – in this case, the utility that must be soundly predicted was limited to a rider entering, traversing, and then exiting the claimed slide feature.

Key takeaways

This FCA’s decision provides guidance for those preparing patent applications and litigating patents:

The specification helps define what was actually invented: The FCA treated the specification – not testimony from the inventor or experts – as the most reliable indicator of what the inventor had contemplated at the filing date. As such, where a feature is not intended to be essential to the claimed invention, it is advisable to include in the patent’s description variations and alternatives of the feature (e.g., “in other embodiments”) and/or other language indicating the feature is non-essential (e.g., “may be”).

The bar for sound prediction of utility is low: Only a “scintilla” of utility is required to meet the legal threshold. In this case, what mattered was that the claimed features were not “fanciful, inoperable, or speculative.” Where relevant, the specification should disclose that the embodiments reflect informed design work, but it may not be necessary to disclose every testing methodology.

Contact