Inflation and price shocks test commercial resilience - but competition and consumer law does not relax in times of crisis. If anything, the ACCC’s focus intensifies when markets are under stress, consumers are paying elevated prices, and the temptation to coordinate is at its greatest.
With penalties increasing and enforcement momentum building, the safest course remains clear: make pricing and capacity decisions independently, document the commercial rationale carefully - including by reference to external cost benchmarks - be transparent in price claims, and resist the temptation to seek comfort from competitors. That comfort can come at a very high price.
Global price shocks arising from the conflict in the Middle East have driven volatility in input costs across the economy and resulted in price increases, the imposition of fuel surcharges, shifts in output and capacity, and customer demand. Supply chains in industries as diverse as fuel, fertiliser, aviation and groceries are grappling with the same question: how long can we absorb rising costs, and how do we remain profitable?
The way that businesses answer that question - and with whom - raises real competition law considerations under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) (CCA).
The Australian Government has recently doubled the maximum penalties for breaches of anti-competitive conduct, cartel behaviour and misleading or unfair practices from $50 million to $100 million.1 The reforms were framed as measures to tackle price gouging and empower the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) with substantially stronger enforcement tools to act decisively against companies that exploit periods of conflict or economic stress.
Moreover, ACCC scrutiny of key sectors is likely to be heightened.
It is therefore a good time to revisit the key competition law guardrails.
Cartels and concerted practices: The legal backdrop
Australian competition law prohibits cartel conduct and concerted practices.
Cartel conduct includes agreements or understandings between competitors to:
- Fix prices (including through fuel surcharges, freight levies or pricing formulas)
- Control or restrict output
- Allocate markets or customers
- Rig bids
Even where conduct does not amount to a cartel, the CCA prohibits concerted practices that have the purpose, effect or likely effect of substantially lessening competition. A concerted practice does not require any agreement at all. It captures situations where competitors knowingly substitute cooperation for independent competition, often through the exchange of strategically sensitive commercial information. This can arise from price or capacity signalling, information shared at industry forums, through trade associations or even in casual conversations between operations or commercial staff of competitors.
The CCA provides a way for businesses to seek authorisation for conduct that would otherwise amount to a breach where the public benefit of the conduct outweighs the detriment. In view of the Middle East conflict, the Australian Institute of Petroleum and its members have sought authorisation to coordinate management of the supply chain of fuel products2 and the mining industry is reportedly also considering seeking authorisation to collaborate in relation to fuel security strategies.
Why inflationary shocks heighten risk
Inflationary environments - particularly those driven by significant price shocks - create conditions where the risks of illegal coordination are amplified:
- Input costs rise across an entire industry simultaneously.
- Pricing, capacity or output decisions become commercially imperative
- Businesses are acutely aware of how competitors are responding and scanning for “signals” about next moves.
A justifiable levy or price adjustment will not give rise to competition law risks if adopted unilaterally, based on a business's own assessment of its cost base - even if competitors later move in parallel because they face the same economic pressures.
The risk arises when competitors communicate - explicitly or implicitly - about:
- Whether price increases or capacity changes will be implemented.
- How large they should be.
- When they should take effect.
Even seemingly 'innocent' exchanges - such as a brief call with an industry contact or a comment at a trade event seeking an indication of their approach to cost pressures - can be problematic, because they reduce the strategic uncertainty that competition law is designed to preserve.
ACCC scrutiny: lessons from past enforcement
The ACCC has repeatedly warned that businesses must not use supply chain disruptions or volatile input costs as a pretext for exchanging forward‑looking pricing information or signalling intended pricing or capacity responses to competitors.
In the ACCC v BlueScope Steel matter, the conduct under scrutiny was an attempt to induce downstream customers and rivals to align on price increases. The Federal Court confirmed that even where price rises are economically rational, seeking assurance (directly or indirectly) that competitors will move in the same direction crosses the line. The matter resulted in then record penalties of $57.5 million.
In the ACCC’s Air Cargo Cartel case against 15 international airlines, the Federal Court confirmed that various airlines had engaged in unlawful price fixing conduct by imposing agreed surcharges on the carriage of air cargo. The Federal Court accepted that the airlines faced economic pressures and the same increases in fuel and security costs, but this did not justify aligning their prices. Total civil penalties (including settlements) amounted to $98.5 million.
Practical guardrails
| High‑risk conduct | Lower‑risk conduct |
|---|---|
| 'Check‑ins' with competitors about whether price rises or surcharges are 'sticking' | Independent, unilateral price or capacity adjustments based on internal analysis |
| Sharing non‑public cost data, margins or pricing intentions | Public communications genuinely directed at customers or investors (not rivals) |
| Coordinated timing, structure or framing of surcharges or rate increases or capacity changes | Reliance on observable, publicly available market data, without interaction with competitors |
| Public or private signalling designed to reassure competitors rather than genuinely inform customers or the market | Seeking legal advice before participating in industry body discussions about cost pressures or pricing trends |
Truth in pricing and communications
Where a decision is taken to increase prices, it is important that the reasons for the price change are truthful and accurate. Whilst a subject deserving of its own article, truth and clarity in pricing communications is also a major focus for the ACCC in the current environment. Any conduct by organisations that blames rising fuel costs, for example, for price hikes, when that is not the genuine or only reason for the price increase, may be seen by the ACCC as a false or misleading misrepresentation that can attract the very significant penalties of the order set out above.
Fair trading expectations do not relax in times of crisis
Inflation and price shocks test commercial resilience - but competition and consumer law does not relax in times of crisis. If anything, the ACCC’s focus intensifies when markets are under stress, consumers are paying elevated prices, and the temptation to coordinate is at its greatest.
With penalties increasing and enforcement momentum building, the safest course remains clear: make pricing and capacity decisions independently, document the commercial rationale carefully - including by reference to external cost benchmarks, be transparent in price claims - and resist the temptation to seek comfort from competitors. That comfort can come at a very high price.
Footnotes
-
While maintaining alternative penalty calculations based on the benefit obtained or a proportion of turnover.
-
The ACCC has granted interim authorisation to the Australian Institute of Petroleum and its members solely for the purpose of efficiently managing potential impacts on the fuel products supply chain in light of the Middle East conflict but excluded any coordination concerning pricing and contracting with fuel retailers and end-users. The ACCC is currently considering whether to grant final authorisation for a period of 12 months.