Overview
Over the past few years, Delaware courts have seemingly been more reluctant to enforce noncompete covenants. What has changed is not the underlying legal standard so much as the rigor with which Delaware courts are applying that standard. This means that businesses, now more than ever, need to pay close attention to how their noncompete covenants are drafted and entered into. This caution applies both to service-based noncompete covenants (such as in an employment agreement) and sale-of-business noncompete covenants.
Delaware courts have made clear that loosely drafted or overreaching noncompete covenants will face heightened judicial skepticism, and, just as importantly, that employers should not expect courts to salvage deficient provisions. For businesses that utilize broadly worded noncompetes as a matter of course, this development warrants a close look at existing agreements and drafting practices going forward. One practical takeaway: more often than not, a noncompete that is slightly too narrow will be more protective than one that is slightly too broad.
Key themes from recent decisions
Courts are more reluctant to rewrite defective covenants
Delaware courts are growing reluctant to "blue-pencil" or judicially modify overbroad covenants. Instead, they are striking them down in their entirety. Courts have said that allowing for judicial modification places the employer in a “no lose” situation with no real incentive to draft a proper noncompete covenant. Delaware’s more recent approach places the burden squarely on the drafter to get it right at the outset. Acknowledging this change in Delaware’s judicial approach may be the most important take away here, as it explains the renewed focus on precise drafting of noncompete covenants.
Geographic and functional scope must match reality
A noncompete's geographic and functional reach must bear a reasonable relationship to the scope of the business as it actually exists either at, as applicable, the time the individual sells the business or the time the individual’s employment is terminated. It must also match the individual’s involvement with the business. For example, even though a business offers various products and services to its customers and operates nationwide, if the individual at issue is only involved in certain aspects of that business (or certain subsidiaries), or only has access to information about certain customers or geographic markets, then a nationwide covenant as to all of the business’ products and services would likely be found to be overbroad. Even within the same business, a noncompete covenant that may be appropriate for one executive may not be appropriate for another executive or for a customer-facing sales representative. Careful consideration should be given to the scope of each individual’s noncompete covenant.
A legitimate business interest must be present to support the scope
While not a new development, keep in mind that courts require businesses to point to a specific, protectable interest—such as trade secrets, confidential information or customer goodwill—to justify a noncompete covenant against an individual. Generalized assertions will not suffice. This means that not all employees should be asked to sign a noncompete covenant. If an individual does not have unique talents, does not have access to trade secrets or other critical, proprietary information and is not customer facing, then a noncompete for that individual is probably unenforceable and not appropriate.
Benefits provided in exchange for the noncompete cannot be an afterthought
Delaware’s Supreme Court recently held that, as a matter of contract formation, an award of incentive equity units will be sufficient consideration in exchange for a noncompete covenant even if the benefit under the award is “somewhat contingent” as long as the award is not illusory. Lower courts had previously questioned whether certain types of profits interests, such as those that require the individual to remain employed through a sale of business to receive any economic benefit, could serve as adequate consideration. While the Supreme Court seems to have answered that question, it remains to be seen whether the “somewhat contingent” nature of an award will play into the reasonableness analysis of the noncompete covenant. Put another way, a court could decide that, the more “contingent” an award is, the narrower and shorter the noncompete covenant needs to be to be enforceable.
A note on other jurisdictions
Delaware's trajectory is not an isolated phenomenon. The general legal trend across the United States appears to be moving toward stricter application of existing noncompete law—even where the formal statutory or underlying common law framework has not changed—meaning that the practical enforceability of broadly worded covenants is eroding in many jurisdictions simultaneously. Florida has been a notable outlier in maintaining a more employer-friendly environment for noncompete covenants.
Importantly, even where a contract designates Delaware or another state as the governing law, courts will typically apply their own state's law if that law provides greater protection to the individual. This means that, when drafting noncompete covenants, the law of the jurisdiction where the employee is expected to live and work should not be ignored. Sometimes noncompete covenants should be drafted to comply with the lowest common denominator across multiple state laws.
Practical guidance for businesses
- Review existing noncompetes in active employment and acquisition agreements to assess exposure under the evolving standards.
- Narrow rather than broaden when drafting new covenants—a restriction that is modestly underinclusive may be strategically preferable to one that risks invalidation entirely.
- Tailor geographic, temporal and business scopes to the business’ protectable interests and legitimate needs and to the individual’s involvement in the business.
- Ensure that the consideration and benefit provided in exchange for the covenant is meaningful and traceable—particularly where “contingent” equity forms the sole basis for the covenant.