On 30 September 2025, the Supreme People’s Court released the draft Interpretation on Several Issues on the Application of the Company Law of the People’s Republic of China (in Chinese: 《关于适用〈中华人民共和国公司法〉若干问题的解释(征求意见稿)》, the "Draft Judicial Interpretation"), seeking public feedback. The deadline for submitting feedback was already due in October 2025 but the Draft Judicial Interpretation has still not yet been officially issued.
By way of background, the Company Law of the People’s Republic of China (the "Company Law") came into effect on 1 July 2024, introducing significant revisions and establishing multiple new legal frameworks relating to, inter alia, shareholders’ capital contribution obligations and related liabilities, corporate governance structures, and directors’ duties and liabilities. Against this backdrop, the Draft Judicial Interpretation seeks to enhance the effectiveness of the Company Law, unify judicial practices, and supersede the existing Judicial Interpretations on Several Issues Concerning the Implementation of the Company Law (I)–(V). This marks the first comprehensive update to China’s judicial interpretations of the Company Law since their initial rollout in 2006.
In this article, we focus on some key provisions relevant to the governance of limited liability companies ("LLCs"), which is a common form of corporate entity used by foreign investors in China, and how the Draft Judicial Interpretation applies the concept of piercing the corporate veil in different circumstances.
1. Resignation or Removal of Legal Representative
Position under the Company Law
Article 10 of the Company Law stipulates that when a director or manager serving as the legal representative of a company resigns as a director or manager, such resignation shall be deemed a simultaneous resignation from their position as legal representative. The LLC must then appoint a new legal representative within thirty days.
Issues in practice
After a director or manager serving as the legal representative resigns, the LLC often fails to update the company’s registration records with the Administration for Market Regulation (the "AMR"). Consequently, the individual who has already resigned and left the company still remains on the AMR records (and therefore known to the public) as the legal representative of the LLC. This falls outside of the control of such legal representative.
Solutions provided under the Draft Judicial Interpretation
Under the Draft Judicial Interpretation, the resigned legal representative may directly file a lawsuit against the LLC requesting a confirmation that the resignation has taken effect and requiring the LLC to change or remove the AMR registration information accordingly.
The Draft Judicial Interpretation further provides that:
- The effective date of the legal representative’s resignation is the date when the LLC receives the written resignation notice; and
- During the period from the effective date of such resignation to the update of the AMR records, all civil activities conducted by the resigned legal representative in the name of the LLC should be legally binding on the LLC, unless the LLC can prove that the counterparty already knew or should have known about the legal representative’s resignation.
The Draft Judicial Interpretation provides a remedy for the legal representatives who have resigned and left to remove their names from the AMR records. It confirms the LLC’s obligation to update the registration following the legal representative’s resignation and indicates that this position may remain temporarily vacant if there is no immediate successor. However, how this provision will interact with the AMR’s current registration system and be implemented in practice remains to be seen.
2. Related party guarantees
Position under the Company Law
Article 15 of the Company Law requires that when an LLC provides a guarantee for the obligations of another party, it shall be approved by the board of directors or the shareholders meeting in accordance with the provisions in the articles of association ("AOA") of the LLC. The AOA may set limits on the amount of a single guarantee or the total amount of guarantees to be provided by the LLC. Furthermore, any guarantee provided for the LLC’s shareholder or actual controller must be approved by the shareholders meeting, and the interested shareholder must abstain from voting. Resolutions of the shareholders meeting in breach of the aforesaid requirements will not qualify as due internal approval or authorisation for the subject transaction.
These provisions intend to protect the interest of minority shareholder(s).
Issues in practice
In practice, an LLC may provide a guarantee for the obligations of entities directly or indirectly controlled by the LLC’s shareholder(s) or actual controller(s). Such arrangements currently fall outside the scope of Article 15 of the Company Law but may nonetheless cause the same level of risk or damage to the LLC and/or its minority shareholders which is the risk which Article 15 of the Company Law seeks to address.
Solutions provided under the Draft Judicial Interpretation
Under the Draft Judicial Interpretation, when an LLC provides a guarantee for another entity directly or indirectly controlled by the LLC’s controlling shareholder or actual controller, the same rules applicable to the provision of guarantees for the LLC’s shareholders or actual controllers under Article 15 of the Company Law shall apply by reference, meaning that the guarantee may be regarded as being given without due approval or authorisation. The exception to this is where, after conducting reasonable due diligence during the execution of the guarantee, the beneficiary of the guarantee remains unaware of the affiliated relationship between the obligor and the LLC’s controlling shareholder or actual controller.
In addition, the Draft Judicial Interpretation also provides that the same requirement shall apply by reference when an LLC provides a guarantee for a third party’s acquisition of equity in the LLC itself or in the LLC’s parent company.
3. Piercing the corporate veil – between an LLC and its shareholder(s)
Position under the Company Law
Article 23 of the Company Law provides that, if an LLC’s shareholder abuses the independent legal personality of the LLC and the shareholders’ limited liability to avoid debts, thereby causing serious damage to the creditors of the LLC, such shareholder should bear joint and several liability for the debts of the LLC.
Issues in practice
What constitutes a shareholder’s abuse of the independent legal personality of the LLC and the shareholders’ limited liability has long been controversial, leading to inconsistent judicial practices in China. In 2020, the Ninth Civil Minutes sought to address this issue by establishing a framework. However, such framework has not been formally codified in higher-level judicial interpretations, leaving its legislative authority uncertain.
Solutions provided under the Draft Judicial Interpretation
The Draft Judicial Interpretation allows courts to hold shareholders jointly and severally liable when they abuse the LLC’s separate legal personality and cause serious damage to the LLC’s creditors in various specific circumstances (each a "Noncompliant Conduct"), including:
- Excessive control, which refers to situations where several companies are effectively controlled by the same shareholder, causing them to lose independent will, engage in improper benefit transfers, and use such transfers to avoid debts;
- Commingling of assets, which arises where the shareholder’s assets cannot be distinguished from the LLC’s assets and the shareholder uses the LLC’s assets without compensation or even misappropriates the LLC’s assets, or where there is commingling of personnel, business operations, or premises; or
- Undercapitalisation, which refers to situations where the actual capital contributed by the shareholder is apparently disproportionate to the risks inherent in the company’s operations, or where the shareholder maliciously shifts investment risks to creditors by, for example, causing the LLC to incur excessive debts or to incur debts maliciously.
These specific factors set out in the Draft Judicial Interpretation generally reflect the guiding opinions on piercing the corporate veil previously set out in the Ninth Civil Minutes.
4. Piercing the corporate veil – between an LLC and its sister companies
Position under the Company Law
Article 23 of the Company Law stipulates that where a shareholder uses two or more companies under its control to engage in any Noncompliant Conduct, each company shall be jointly and severally liable for the debts of the other companies.
This provision enables creditors to pursue not only the relevant shareholder of the indebted LLC but also the sister companies of the LLC.
Issues in practice
The Company Law has expanded the application of the concept of piercing the corporate veil to an LLC’s sister companies. In practice, however, instead of establishing control through equity investment, a shareholder may use other means (such as appointment of directors or general managers, or VIE structures) to gain control over other entities. In these circumstances, local courts may be reluctant to apply Article 23 of the Company Law.
Solutions provided under the Draft Judicial Interpretation
The Draft Judicial Interpretation confirms that “control” may be established directly or indirectly through equity investment or other means. According to the two approaches proposed in the Draft Judicial Interpretation, the actual controller may either be liable pursuant to Article 23 of the Company Law (as explained above) or be liable under the Company Law for breaching the duties of loyalty and diligence owed to the LLC.
5. Piercing the corporate veil – between an LLC and its sole shareholder
Position under the Company Law
Article 23 of the Company Law provides that for an LLC with a sole shareholder, namely, a one-person company, if the shareholder cannot prove that the LLC’s assets are independent from the shareholder’s own assets, the shareholder shall bear joint and several liability for the company’s debts.
Issues in practice
Various contentious issues have arisen from this provision, including the following:
- How can an LLC or its sole shareholder discharge its burden of proof when there is a claim of piercing the corporate veil?
- If the shareholders are a married couple, should the LLC be regarded as a one-person company hence subject to the scope of this provision?
- If the sole shareholder of an LLC is also solely owned by another person, shall such ultimate controller also be held jointly and severally liable for the debts of the LLC?
Solutions provided under the Draft Judicial Interpretation
The Draft Judicial Interpretation clarifies that:
- If the LLC’s sole shareholder can prove that the LLC has compiled its annual financial statements in compliance with the applicable laws, or otherwise can provide complete and continuous accounting records of the LLC for a special audit, which can prove the independence of the LLC, then the burden of proof should be regarded as having been fulfilled;
- A company jointly founded by spouses is not automatically treated as a one-person company; and
- The general rule is that the doctrine of piercing the corporate veil relating to one-person companies only applies to the direct shareholder of the LLC, unless it can be proved that the direct and indirect shareholders of the LLC are all subject to excessive direct or indirect control by the same ultimate controller, or that their assets are so commingled from one another that the interest of the creditors is seriously harmed.
The clarity provided by the Draft Judicial Interpretation on these specific points would certainly help to guide the judicial practice and provide more clarity to investors in China.