On March 25, 2026, the Quebec Court of Appeal allowed the appeal of the Attorney General of Quebec and dismissed the class action brought by taxi owner permit holders following the legislative reform that opened the market to Uber and abolished the supply management system.
The court therefore dismissed any claim based on expropriation, meaning group members will have to settle for the $873 million already voluntarily paid by the Government of Quebec.
Taxi owner permit holders argued the abolition of their permits by Act respecting remunerated passenger transportation by automobile (2019) and the loss of market value of those permits constituted a disguised expropriation.
The Quebec Superior Court had partially allowed the taxi drivers’ action and found there had been a disguised expropriation. The Superior Court had therefore ordered the state to pay an expropriation indemnity of nearly $144 million.
The Quebec Court of Appeal overturned the lower court’s judgment and concluded there had been no disguised expropriation. Three distinct tenets underpin this conclusion.
1. A taxi owner’s permit is not a property right
The court reiterated that a permit is first and foremost an administrative authorization issued by the state, strictly regulated and inseparable from the applicable legislative framework. As such, a taxi owner’s permit does not have the classic characteristics of property rights. More specifically, the permit is not “absolute, exclusive and perpetual.”
Rights arising from a permit are therefore not subject to expropriation, even if that permit has acquired significant economic value. The state may therefore abolish such a scheme without expropriating a property right in the legal sense.
2. Permit holders have not been deprived of all reasonable use
Even after the abolition of taxi owner permits, holders could continue operating their businesses, using their permits and generating revenue under a new legislative framework. The reform impacted the economic value of the permits without, however, eliminating their usefulness.
The court therefore concluded that there was no total destruction or absolute denial of the exercise of a property right – an essential condition for recognizing an expropriation.
3. No state appropriation
Finally, the court noted the abolished permits were not transferred to the state and the state derived no direct property benefit from their abolition. It is therefore not an expropriation, but rather the abolition of an economic monopoly in the legitimate exercise of legislative power.
The takeaway
A taxi owner’s permit is more akin to a right of use or a special privilege conferred by the state than to a true property right.
The sole economic injury resulting from a change in scheme cannot form the basis of an expropriation claim, unless there is a genuine confiscation of the property by the state.