On February 13, 2026, Quebec’s public inquiry into managing the modernization of the Société de l'assurance automobile du Québec’s computer systems (the Commission) released its report (Gallant Report) (in French only).

The Gallant Report makes recommendations aimed, inter alia, at strengthening the integrity, transparency, and effectiveness of public contracts relating to information technology (IT) and providing oversight bodies with the necessary powers to fulfill their mandates. Several recommendations, if adopted, will lead to significant legislative changes.

Here are three Gallant Report recommendations for legislative changes that deserve particular attention.

1. Amendments to limit the size of projects and contracts

According to the Commission, technology megaprojects are “rarely a winning option,” as they lock in IT requirements over time and limit technology solutions to those known when they are defined. Digital transformation requires a gradual approach, involving trial and error and adjustment. That is why the Commission recommends updating the legislative framework to encourage smaller-scale projects.

  • Capping the cost of projects at $50 million: The Commission recommends amending the regulations made under the Act respecting the governance and management of the information resources of public bodies and government enterprises1 to set a maximum threshold of $50 million for technology projects, unless an exemption is granted by Cabinet. The Commission emphasizes that an even lower threshold would be desirable. Currently, there is no cost cap for projects. However, since 2022, any project with an estimated cost of $50 million or more must be approved by Cabinet.2
  • Capping the term of contracts at less than five years: There is currently no general limit on IT contract terms in Quebec. Only delivery order contracts and task order contracts3 are limited to five years under the Regulation respecting contracting by public bodies in the field of information technologies, adopted under the Act respecting contracting by public bodies (LCOP)4. The Commission therefore recommends establishing a limit of five years (or less) for professional services contracts and reducing the maximum term of delivery order contracts and task order contracts.

These recommendations aim to encourage modular projects, where development is incremental, allowing the public body to adapt its requirements as its needs evolve. A waiver mechanism would remain available, but the objective would be to ensure accountability for government members who authorize an exemption.

For large-scale projects requiring a long-term contractual relationship, the Commission recommends entering into partnership contracts. This collaborative model, provided for in the LCOP, notably allows for a mutual sharing of risks, savings or losses between the public body and its co-contractor. These contracts, more common today in the infrastructure sector, could extend to IT projects by amending the LCOP and its regulations.

2. Amendments aimed at promoting transparency and accountability within the SEAO

The Commission proposes to improve accountability within the Système électronique d’appel d’offres (SEAO), the platform where government tenders and information on public contracts are published. It recommends, in particular, the following changes:

  • Reducing the threshold for publishing cost overruns: Currently, a public body must publish on the SEAO any additional expenditure exceeding more than 10% of the initial contract amount.5 For high-value contracts, this threshold may represent several tens of millions of dollars before the obligation is triggered. Moreover, this single threshold may encourage public bodies to divide their amendments in order to delay publication, even where a more significant amendment is required to bring the project to completion. To address these shortcomings, the Commission recommends a dual threshold whereby the disclosure obligation would be triggered as soon as the excess reaches the lower of 10% of the initial amount and $1 million.
  • Publishing transactions and out-of-court settlements: The LCOP does not explicitly govern out-of-court settlements (also known as transactions) reached between a public body and its co-contractor in the performance of a contract. This gap may result in certain contractual amendments, such as a reduction in the scope of a contract, not being subject to any publication requirement. The Commission therefore recommends that the LCOP explicitly detail the circumstances where the conclusion of a transaction carried out in the performance of a contract should be made public, and specify the information it believes should be published, including the existence, date and monetary value of that transaction.

These amendments aim to promote transparency in managing public contracts and ensure the public is informed in a simple, reliable, understandable and accessible manner.

3. Amendments aimed at strengthening the Autorité des marchés publics’ powers

The Autorité des marchés publics (AMP) is the oversight body for public contracts in Quebec. Its mandate covers two areas: compliance with the contractual processes of public bodies, governed by the Act respecting the Autorité des marchés publics (LAMP)6, and the integrity of enterprises contracting with the state, governed mainly by the LCOP.

However, according to the Gallant Report, certain legislative gaps hinder fulfilling this mandate. To address this, the Commission recommends the following amendments:

  • Waiving professional secrecy and other privileges vis-à-vis the AMP: Currently, public bodies may refuse to respond to AMP requests by invoking professional secrecy or other legal privileges, where applicable. The Commission recommends removing this option for compliance checks of contractual processes. According to the Gallant Report, an example of this approach reportedly exists in the City of Montreal, which is said to have waived solicitor-client privilege with respect to its lawyers, both in-house and external, vis-à-vis the Bureau de l’inspecteur général, the body responsible for overseeing the awarding and performance of city contracts. The Commission also recommends waiving privilege over settlement discussions arising during contract performance, on the grounds, among others, that any expenditure of public funds entered into without a call for tenders requires neutral and impartial oversight.
  • Protecting the confidentiality of investigations: Currently, the AMP has no power to require confidentiality undertakings during its investigations to prohibit a witness, for example, from discussing the content of an interview meeting with a third party. According to the Gallant Report, this situation may lead to a cross-contamination of witness statements. However, several bodies with similar public protection mandates are covered by legislation providing for such protections. For example, the Autorité des marchés financiers (Quebec’s securities regulator) may prohibit a person from disclosing any information relating to an investigation to anyone.7 The Commission therefore recommends granting similar authority to the AMP.
  • Issuing subpoenas regarding integrity: The LAMP8 allows the AMP to investigate any matter relating to its mandate to oversee public bodies in respect of public contracts. For these purposes, the AMP has the powers of commissioners appointed under the Act respecting public inquiry commissions, including the power to summon witnesses.9 However, in the context of an integrity review of a business under the LCOP, the AMP does not have this power. Although it has broad powers to carry out this aspect of its mandate, such as the power to request documents and information, to enter an establishment and to access any computer equipment on site10, the Commission recommends expanding the power to summon witnesses to integrity files to correct what it considers an inconsistency.

These recommendations pursue a clear objective: to equip the AMP with all the necessary tools to ensure compliance with contracting rules and sound management of public funds. They are, in fact, consistent with Bill 12 (An Act mainly to promote Québec-sourced and responsible procurement by public bodies, to reinforce the integrity regime of enterprises and to increase the powers of the Autorité des marchés publics), which notably strengthened the AMP's powers regarding the integrity review of enterprises.11

Conclusion

The Gallant Report’s recommendations are part of the past decade’s reforms aimed at improving the governance of public bodies, both for technology projects and public procurement contracts in general.

Some of these recommendations could, however, raise significant issues, in that they relate to solicitor-client privilege and privileges relating to settlement discussions, protections recognized as fundamental under Quebec law. Their implementation would therefore require a rigorous legislative framework and clear guidelines to precisely define the protected information and that which may be excluded from protection. It remains to be seen, from a practical point of view, how all of this will materialize.

Enterprises dealing with public bodies would therefore be well advised to closely monitor the legislative and regulatory developments resulting from these recommendations, in order to anticipate new requirements and adapt their practices accordingly.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    The Act respecting the governance and management of the information resources of public bodies and government enterprises, CQLR c G-1.03, was adopted in 2011 and significantly amended in 2017, to establish the governance framework for public bodies in relation to IT, including rules concerning the planning, management, approval, monitoring and assessment of information resource projects.

  2. 2

    Règles relatives à la gestion des projets en ressources informationnelles, Order in Council 1159-2022, June 22, 2022.

  3. 3

    Delivery order contracts (goods) and task order contracts (services) are contracts where the essential terms and conditions (price, terms, duration) are established in advance for recurring needs without, however, specifying the quantity or timing of goods to be acquired, or the number of requests or frequency of service delivery, as these elements remain uncertain.

  4. 4

    The Act respecting contracting by public bodies, CQLR c C-65.1, is the main law governing public contracts in Quebec.

  5. 5

    Article 22, paragraph 2 of the LCOP.

  6. 6

    The Act respecting the Autorité des marchés publics, CQLR c A-33.2.1, is the law that establishes the AMP and confers upon it the powers necessary to monitor and regulate the procurement processes of public bodies in Quebec.

  7. 7

    See, in particular, article 14.1 of the Act respecting the regulation of the financial sector, CQLR, c. E-6.1 and article 245 of the Securities Act, CQLR, c. V-1.1).

  8. 8

    Article 26, paragraph 3 of the LAMP.

  9. 9

    Article 10 of the Act respecting public inquiry commissions, CQLR, c.C-37.

  10. 10

    See our update on the expanded powers of the AMP since June 2022: Bill 12: Important changes to the legislative framework governing the integrity regime of enterprises and the AMP’s powers | Canada | Global legal practice | Norton Rose Fulbright.

Contact