We start this April edition of Tax Insights with our thoughts on the Supreme Court’s important decision in Gunfleet Sands. It is disappointing for renewable and major infrastructure projects, demonstrating (again) the difficulties taxpayers can face in obtaining tax relief for their expenditure and the need for real, investment-friendly reform. With the decision now final, perhaps the government will publish its consultation on the tax treatment of predevelopment costs and consider what the long term regime should be. The progress of this case illustrates the unpredictable and very fact dependent nature of the current rules.
With the increased focus internationally on PE and TP, we have also taken more time to digest and comment further on the Finance Act 2026 reforms to the UK regimes, developments which coincide nicely with the strengthening of our transfer pricing practice with the arrival of Dr Stephanie Pantelidaki, an economist by background, who has joined the firm as Partner (non legal) and Head of Transfer Pricing for EMEAPAC, based in London.
Events in the Middle East have brought back into focus questions of tax residency and PE risk due to relocation and travel issues and we include a summary of key considerations and our understanding of HMRC’s current approach.
Finally, we consider a couple of recent decisions that caught our interest, the first clarifies the scope of the “imported loss restriction”; we consider its relevance for multinational groups. The second, Coopervision, asks whether, on the sale of a company, a disposal of management shares for a higher price than that obtained by the private equity holder, gave rise to employment tax on the difference. This is an area that comes up fairly frequently in practice. The facts were not straightforward and we take the opportunity to work through some key questions.
Capital allowances – expenditure on plant and machinery
On any infrastructure project, it is crucial to understand what expenditure qualifies for tax relief. One of the most discussed UK tax topics in recent years has been the extent to which the cost of preliminary studies or surveys for a major project qualify for tax depreciation. The UK Supreme Court has delivered its judgment (based on the facts in front of it) that the cost of preliminary studies and surveys relating to specific offshore windfarms did not qualify for capital allowances. It is however yet to be seen how widely the judgment applies.
In Ørsted West of Duddon Sands (UK) Limited & Ors v HMRC [2026] UKSC 12 (Ørsted), the UK Supreme Court applied a narrow interpretation of the term ‘on the provision of plant’, to deny relief for capital allowances on surveys and studies as being expenditure “on” the plant itself. The judgment provides a final conclusion to what has been a long running saga1 and will be of particular interest to those operating in the offshore energy and windfarm industries. It may also have wider relevance to other infrastructure projects. Taxpayers should consider whether their facts can be distinguished or any alternative tax relief is available.
The decision
The respondents in Ørsted were four companies that operated windfarms off the coast of the UK. During the planning and design of these windfarms, each company incurred significant expenditure on preliminary studies and surveys relating to the environment in which these windfarms were to be constructed, many of which were required to be obtained to satisfy various environmental and planning laws. HMRC did not dispute that the wind turbines and their connecting cabling were ‘plant’ such that capital allowances would be available under section 11(4) of the Capital Allowances Act 2001 (CAA 2001) in respect of capital expenditure “on” their provision. The Supreme Court was also in no doubt that the respondents had been required to conduct these studies and surveys in order to design and build the windfarms. However, the question was broadly whether this was enough to say that this necessary expenditure on studies and surveys was incurred “on” the provision of the windfarms.
The Supreme Court looked at the ordinary meaning of the words used in section 11(4)(a) of CAA 2001 and held that the statutory wording of “on” the provision of plant was deliberately narrow so as to require a “close connection” between the expenditure and the plant provided. Lady Rose contrasted this wording to other phrases adopted in statutes such as “in connection to”, “relating to”, or “with a view to”, each establishing a looser nexus than “on”.
Lady Rose referred to historical capital allowances case law to support a narrow interpretation of “on” the provision of plant. In Inland Revenue Comrs v Barclay, Curle & Co Ltd [1969] 1 WLR 675, the excavation and concrete lining of a dry dock qualified as expenditure “on” the provision of plant because the plant physically included this concrete basin and could not exist without it. In Ben-Odeco Ltd v Powlson [1978] 1 WLR 1093 (Ben-Odeco), capital expenditure “on” the provision of plant was held not to extend to commitment fees and capital interest incurred on loans used to finance the acquisition of plant. Lady Rose noted that Ben-Odeco concerned the lack of proximity between the expenditure and the provision of the plant itself. Attention was brought to the “limiting curve” delineated by Lord Wilberforce in Ben-Odeco which captured only those payments made around the plant and the provision of it. In Ørsted, Lady Rose held that the costs of studies and surveys which provide a company with advice on how to choose or design plant fall “well outside” the limiting curve. A practical distinction appears to have been drawn between those costs attributable to the direct provision of plant and those attributable to studies and surveys, which may be informative but are not sufficiently close such as to be expenditure “on” the plant.
Practical implications
This result reminds us that the courts, ultimately, cannot stretch statutory words beyond their natural meaning in the context of the legislation other than in very specific circumstances, however much that may be arguably contrary to the overall policy behind the Act. It displays the currently unsatisfactory nature of the UK tax regime in sometimes denying relief for capital expenditure on infrastructure projects the value of which will in fact depreciate over time. In the context of energy transition, where enormous amounts are being invested to construct new and innovative projects, this leads to a mismatch between the economic outcome and the tax position. In the UK, taxpayers face the difficulty that capital expenditure can qualify for tax relief under a variety of piecemeal regimes, including giving capital allowances, research and development allowances, structures and buildings allowances and relief for depreciation of intangible assets (as well as situations where capitalised expenditure is in fact revenue in nature). The conditions that have to be satisfied for these different regimes are not always aligned, so that the boundaries between them inevitably lead to gaps where expenditure may not qualify for tax relief, despite being validly and often necessarily incurred on the infrastructure project. It is to be hoped that the Government will take a further look at this position as there does not appear to be a valid policy reason for denying relief in such circumstances, particularly where the studies and reports are required by law.
Lady Rose did (rightly) acknowledge that the question of whether a certain item of expenditure is “on” something (the required condition) is “very fact sensitive”; the judgment did not (and could not) comment on other types of design work. Accordingly, it should be stressed that the result delivered in Ørsted will not be the result in all cases as, depending on the fact pattern, capital allowances may be available on surveys and reports, or they may instead qualify for relief under one of the other regimes. Clients who are concerned about the implications of this decision and how it may apply to them are welcome to discuss the implications with our experienced tax practitioners.
Finance Act 2026 — The UK transfer pricing reforms
The Finance Act 2026 introduced significant updates to the UK's transfer pricing regime, forming part of HMRC's wider effort to bring the UK's international tax rules into closer alignment with OECD principles. The reforms sit alongside the new PE rules, which are summarised in our separate article on the wider PE reforms. See our article, Reforms to definition of Permanent Establishment in the UK from January 2026 in this April edition of our Newsletter.
The key practical message is that groups with structures that may have been designed to fall outside the scope of UK transfer pricing rules should revisit the assumptions on which those structures have been set up, particularly where they relied on particular interpretations of the UK statutes that may not have been reflected in wider OECD principles. Several changes are worth flagging:
- The rules have been widened so that more arrangements will result in parties being regarded as connected for the purposes of applying the transfer pricing rules. The new rules capture structures such as private equity consortiums and joint ventures where parties may not hold majority equity but exercise collective governance (the “participation condition”). It may also apply to certain types of financing arrangements. Companies should review any arrangements where influence arises collectively and where this has previously been considered not to give rise to a sufficient link for transfer pricing purposes, as these new rules may, from 1 January 2026, affect those existing structures. Any changes in the association analysis of parties should be evidenced in the transfer pricing documentation.
- There is a relaxation of “UK-to-UK transfer pricing for domestic transactions” where there is no risk of tax loss. The exemption is subject to conditions, such as requiring that both parties must be subject to UK corporation tax at the same rate and use the same functional currency. The rules include a detailed list of regimes where the UK corporation tax regime applicable to companies within a group may differ, and in those cases, transfer pricing rules will still apply. This means that groups involving upstream or decommissioning oil and gas companies, BLAGAB companies, shipping companies within tonnage tax, banks, securitisation companies, UK REITs, QAHCs, patent box arrangements, investment trusts, property developers, or other special cases should check their position carefully. Companies that wish to elect out of the exemption may do so, but equally should document their rationale for relying on the exemption.
- The new rules on intangible fixed assets are amended so that connected party transfers are valued on a single arm's length basis, removing the historical friction between different "market value" tests. This alignment ensures that the transfer or licensing of intellectual property is treated consistently under both general transfer pricing rules and specific intangible asset regimes. Companies should consider their IP portfolios to ensure that profit allocation accurately reflects where the underlying value is truly created and managed. In practice, the new rules increase the emphasis on the economic valuation of intangibles to have followed the correct standard i.e. arm’s length.
- The new rules integrate the concept of "implicit support," requiring companies to account for the credit enhancement a subsidiary receives simply by being part of a wider group – put differently, the implicit support becomes an economically relevant characteristic of the borrower in the credit risk analysis. This shift moves away from viewing individual entities in isolation, instead mandating that intercompany loans and guarantees reflect the economic reality of the group's collective strength. In turn, this leads to an additional step that would need to be undertaken in the credit rating analysis of the subsidiary before the interest rate in the intercompany loan (or the fee in a guarantee) can be determined.
- The new rules also replace the Diverted Profits Tax (DPT) regime with a new charge on Unassessed Transfer Pricing Profits (UTPP) housed within corporation tax. The move resolves longstanding concerns about access to double tax treaty protections, and essentially operates as a tool to allow HMRC to challenge an existing transfer pricing arrangement by providing the ability to impose an increased rate of corporation tax should HMRC's view prove to be correct. In the same way as DPT, this is likely to put increased focus on transfer pricing methodologies and policies and require early engagement with HMRC to avoid the risk of higher tax rates applying to adjusted profits.
- The reforms (applicable to accounting periods on or after 1 January 2026) sit alongside the planned introduction of the International Controlled Transaction Schedule, a new reporting obligation intended to support HMRC's compliance work from accounting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2027.
Notwithstanding these changes, small and medium-sized enterprises will continue to benefit from an exemption from transfer pricing. Taken together, these reforms signal a decisive shift towards a more OECD aligned approach to UK transfer pricing. In light of these developments, companies would be well advised to review their intercompany pricing arrangements and domestic structuring at the earliest opportunity, with a view to ensuring continued compliance and identifying any areas of potential exposure.
Reforms to the definition of permanent establishment in the UK from January 2026
The Finance Act 2026 introduces reforms to the UK provisions relating to permanent establishments. These changes have effect from 1 January 2026. Considering these changes, non-UK resident companies operating in the UK, even in ways that have not historically amounted to a UK permanent establishment (UK PE) may wish to review previous positions taken.
What has changed?
The UK domestic definition of a permanent establishment has now been aligned with the definition set out in Article 5 of the OECD Model Tax Convention. The UK has for some time retained a definition of permanent establishment that reflected previous OECD principles, but which had not been updated to reflect the changes brought to the OECD Model following the outcome of the OECD’s BEPS project. These changes bring the UK more into line with many other jurisdictions; the changes to the UK domestic position however mean that companies should assess whether their existing arrangements may now give rise to a UK PE. There are particular areas of change that may give rise to this risk, and the main changes are summarised below.
Dependent agent permanent establishment
A particular consequence of the changes is that structures which previously may not have resulted in a UK dependent agent permanent establishment under the previous rules may now be vulnerable. In particular, the UK has now adopted the concept that an agent can create a UK PE even where it does not habitually contractually bind the company. Instead, it will now be sufficient that the agent (which may for example be an employee) habitually concludes contracts or plays “the principal role leading to the conclusion of contracts that are routinely concluded without material modification by the non-UK resident company”. The UK has also now adopted the concept that an agent that may be independent in terms of its ownership structure may not be treated as independent where its business is highly dependent on that of its principal. These changes are wide enough to capture a range of activities in respect of which there may previously have been a debate as to the creation of a UK PE. Activities that may now fall within the scope of the new rules include arrangements where:
- employees of a subsidiary company play an active role in convincing clients to buy products of the parent company, explain standard terms and fixed pricing (which they cannot modify), even if subsequently the contracts are eventually finalised online directly with the non-UK resident company (e.g. through a CRM platform).
- a commission agent not only sells goods of the non-UK resident company in their own name but also habitually acts as an agent having authority to conclude contracts on behalf of a non-UK resident company.
- a person appears to be an independent agent in a commercial sense, but on the basis of the facts and circumstances, is found to act in the UK exclusively or almost exclusively on behalf of the non-UK resident company or, a combination of the non-UK resident company and other companies to which the person is closely related.
This needs to be taken together with the UK’s decision to repeal its diverted profits tax (DPT) rules (see our article, Finance Act 2026 – The UK Transfer Pricing Reforms in this April edition of our Newsletter), as the changes, together with other changes to the UK’s transfer pricing regime, are seeking to fill in part the gap left by the repeal of DPT.
Changes to profit allocation methodology
Revisions have been made to the current UK legislation which determines how profits are allocated to, and taxed in, a UK PE. These changes formally align the UK domestic law provisions with the OECD principles (i.e. Article 7 of the OECD Model Convention and the Authorised OECD Approach). As a result, the methodology for application of the “separate enterprise” principle of allocating profits to a UK PE, including the Significant People Functions, attribution of assets, risks and capital and the arm’s length pricing of dealings, is now largely contained in the OECD rules. In the future, there is likely to be more congruity between the position adopted between the UK and other major jurisdictions in relation to the taxation of permanent establishments, although it remains to be seen whether that will reduce any friction in practice. Profit attribution to a UK PE will still require a functional and factual analysis, as before, taking into account the functions performed, assets used and risk assumed by the non-UK resident enterprise through its UK PE, and through the other parts of the enterprise.
Ambulatory approach to rules
Where UK domestic statutory provisions are in substantially the same terms as those in Article 7(2) of the OECD Model Tax Convention (as recently approved in November 2025), the UK domestic provisions are now to be interpreted, so far as possible, in a way consistent with and by reference to relevant guidance documents published by the OECD, as those guidance documents may be amended or replaced from time to time. Although the new rules contain provisions reserving the UK’s right to disapply any future changes made by the OECD to the relevant guidance documents, the current default status of these OECD documents and any further amendments will be that they apply in the UK. This results in the UK rules potentially being subject to constant change. For example, the current OECD guidance on cross-border working arrangements contains a summary of situations where the OECD consider a remote worker could create a permanent establishment of their employer in another jurisdiction (and contrastingly, circumstances in which a permanent establishment would not arise). That interpretative guidance now has effect in the UK. If that guidance were to be amended or replaced in the future, it would in effect result in a change in the UK’s interpretation of the permanent establishment provisions unless the Government chose to disapply the relevant amendments or replacement. This reversal of the historic UK approach to enacting international tax rules will assist in ensuring alignment with other countries that adopt the OECD approach. However, it does mean that groups will need to keep a watch not only on the UK rules but any relevant OECD developments.
Investment manager exemption (IME)
The IME is a long-standing statutory safe harbour, ensuring that non-UK based funds that have UK based investment managers are not treated as having a UK PE where certain conditions are met. The revised legislation in the Finance Act 2026 includes changes to the IME which are generally seen as beneficial in the context of the wider changes to the UK PE rules. Key changes include: the revision of the scope of the IME to cover a wider range of transactions undertaken by a fund; the widening of the definition of the “investment manager” such that the IME now applies equally to investment managers, as well as other persons providing investment advice; and the removal of ‘the 20% rule’, which previously caused certain practical difficulties in its application. These changes are welcome.
Conclusion
The alignment of the UK’s domestic definitions and interpretation with the OECD’s international standard provides helpful guidance and greater operational clarity for businesses. However, these changes also mean business will have to review their current operations to screen for an increased UK PE risk. To the extent you think your current business structure could be caught by some of the scenarios described above, or alternatively if you have any questions regarding the reforms to the UK’s permanent establishment rules and how these changes may affect your business, please do get in touch with one of the contacts listed below.
A reminder of tax residence considerations when people re-locate to the UK
On-going events in the Middle East have thrown back into focus questions of tax residency and permanent establishment risk for both individuals and companies.
Individuals who work away from their usual home base need to be mindful of the tax consequences for both their own personal tax position, potentially becoming tax resident while abroad, as well as the consequences for the companies that they act for or represent, particularly when acting in the capacity as director (for corporate tax residence) or as someone involved in the negotiation of contracts (for permanent establishment risk).
Individuals
While certain Gulf states are exploring concessions to support those who are displaced by the conflict (for example, relaxed residency day requirements and more flexible visa rules), the same is not yet true for the UK tax residency rules. Individuals returning to the UK from the Middle East need to consider the potential implications for their personal tax residence. UK individual tax residence is determined by the statutory residence test. In its most basic form, if an individual spends 183 days or more in the UK in a tax year, this would trigger UK tax residency. However, this threshold can be reduced to as little as 16 days where the individual maintains considerable ties to the UK, such as through work, family, a home and has only recently left the UK. If an individual becomes UK tax resident, they would be liable to pay UK tax on their worldwide income and gains, and will need to consider whether they breach the “temporarily non-resident” rule. This could also have consequences for UK inheritance tax, which (in very simple terms) now contains a test that a person must have been tax resident outside the UK for a continuous period of 10 years.
It is unclear whether those returning to the UK due to the current situation in the Middle East could benefit from the UK’s “exceptional circumstances” relief, allowing a taxpayer to exempt up to 60 days from their day-count where exceptional circumstances beyond their control meant that they had no choice but to be in the UK, and they can show that they intended to leave the UK as soon as circumstances permit. While HMRC have not yet issued any guidance on whether this exception could be applicable to those returning to the UK from the Middle East, they have previously stated that exceptional circumstances will not generally apply to events which bring an individual back to the UK, unless the FCDO advice is to avoid all travel to the region. It is therefore important for individuals to keep clear records of days spent in the UK and it may be that they should spend time outside the UK (although care should be taken that time elsewhere does not itself trigger tax there).
Corporates
In the UK, non-UK incorporated entities may be regarded as UK tax resident if the company’s place of central management and control (CMC) is the UK. The CMC test is derived from case law and seeks to identify where the key strategic decisions of a company are taken. Crucially, the CMC test will assess the decision-making procedures of a company over time. The participation of directors in the UK in occasional board meetings by a long-established non-UK resident entity in the UK – or elsewhere but with UK-based directors joining remotely – should, therefore, not of itself bring the company into the scope of UK tax. However, where CMC is exercised is a question of fact and will be sensitive to more prolonged changes in behaviours and procedures. Care should be taken to ensure that the position is monitored going forwards.
In the event that a non-UK company is found to have a UK CMC, this does not automatically result in UK corporate tax residency as it would then be key to look to the tiebreaker provisions in any double tax treaty between the UK and the company’s existing country of residence.
In addition to the tax residence of a non-UK entity moving to the UK, non-UK resident companies should also be aware of the UK’s permanent establishment rules. The term “permanent establishment” is derived from the language of double tax treaties and captures companies with:
- a fixed place of business in the UK; or
- a UK-based agent acting on behalf of the company having and habitually exercising authority in the UK for the non-UK resident company. See our article, Reforms to definition of Permanent Establishment in the UK from January 2026 in this April edition of our Newsletter.
By requiring either a fixed place of business or the habitual exercise of an agent’s authority, temporary employee relocations to the UK may not initially create a permanent establishment. However, were the arrangements to later reflect a degree of permanence, companies should recognise that they may give rise to a UK permanent establishment. Where a UK permanent establishment is formed, profits directly attributable to that UK permanent establishment would be charged to UK corporation tax.
Lastly – but certainly not least, the relocation of an employee to the UK may trigger UK employment and social security (NIC) obligations – again depending very much on the facts.
Imported losses on early redemption of loan notes: lessons from UK Care No. 1 LTD V HMRC
The Upper Tribunal's (UT) decision in UK Care No. 1 Ltd v HMRC [2026] UKUT 00090 (TCC) clarifies the scope of the "imported loss" restriction with important consequences for multinational groups migrating entities to the UK, where the entity has pre-existing debt (including securitization debt).
The Tribunal held that the restrictions can apply to a "loss" that includes expenses and upheld the disallowance of the compensatory element of an early redemption premium where it reflects pre-migration changes in market conditions on the basis it was an imported loss. On the other hand, it allowed relief for financing costs that as a matter of commercial reality were referable to the post-migration period of the loan relationship.
UKC1 was a Guernsey-incorporated SPV that had issued fixed-rate loan notes in February 2000 with a total face value of £235 million, and accounted for them on an amortised cost basis. The care homes were operated by a UK group. UKC1 was not part of the UK tax group; its voting shares and equity interests were held by Guernsey trustees for the benefit of two charities. In 2016, wishing to sell certain care homes forming part of the security package, the UK tax group acquired UKC1, migrated it to the UK, and redeemed the notes early under a Spens (make-whole) clause, producing an accounting loss of c. £150.7 million. This loss comprised unamortised issue costs and discount (c. £4.1 million), a compensatory element (c. £89.8 million) and a penalty element (c. £56.8 million). HMRC sought to disallow the unamortised issue costs and discount and the compensatory element as an imported loss under s.327.
The decision of the Tribunal had two principal parts.
The first half dealt with the early redemption loss; the second part was the treatment of the post-migration penalty. UKC1 argued that s.306A CTA 2009 distinguishes "losses" from "expenses" such that the loss on early redemption was made entirely of expenses falling within section 306A(1)(c) and reviewing the language of s.327 in the context of s.306A would indicate that s.327 has no application in relation to expenses.
The Tribunal accepted that the compensatory element could, on balance, be characterised as an expense under s.306A, but held that this did not make a difference: "loss" under s.327 is a broad, compound concept, and may include items that are treated as expenses under s.306A. The Tribunal noted that Parliament signalled its intention to give the restriction a wide ambit by using the words "in connection with" in s.327, which are wider than the words "arising from" in s.306A. The Tribunal agreed with HMRC’s contention that Parliament would want to block relief for imported losses comprising expenses where they are referable to a period when the company was not UK resident, and companies cannot sidestep s.327 merely by characterising an outflow as an "expense" rather than a "loss".
The Tribunal reaffirmed that referability requires an objective, hindsight-based assessment of commercial reality and is not only determined by when an amount was recognised in the accounts. The question is whether the loss already existed economically before migration, even if it only crystallised later. The Tribunal distinguished between the three elements:
Unamortised issue costs and discount- allowable. Overturning the FTT, the Tribunal held that although these costs were incurred pre-migration, they as a matter of commercial reality related to the entire life of the notes and were being amortised accordingly. Early redemption simply accelerated their recognition. Treating the mere date of incurrence as determinative was an error since the costs were "referable to the post-migration period" as a matter of commercial reality.
Compensatory (Spens) element- disallowed. Upholding the FTT, the Tribunal held that changes in market conditions in the pre-migration period, including movements in interest rates and credit spreads, gave rise to the compensatory element of the loss to which it was therefore referable. Early redemption merely crystallised the loss; the compensatory element would have been nil had market conditions remained unchanged since the date of issue. The Tribunal rejected UKC1's argument that the compensatory element was in substance an acceleration of future interest payments: the obligation to compensate arose because fixed rates exceeded current market rates at the time of redemption, a state of affairs which was attributable to pre-migration market movements.
Penalty element- allowable. The penalty arose solely from the post-migration decision to redeem early and created an additional loss rather than merely crystallising a pre-existing one; HMRC accepted it was not an imported loss.
Key Takeaways
Refinancing asymmetry. A borrower migrating to the UK with above-market-rate debt can in principle (and subject to any other restrictions that may apply – such as the corporate interest restriction – CIR) continue deducting the “excess” interest while the debt remains in place, because no loss is realised and s.327 is not engaged. However, if the borrower refinances post-migration and pays a make-whole (Spens) premium, the compensatory element will be disallowed under s.327 because it reflects pre-migration market movements. Groups considering refinancing shortly after migration should factor this asymmetry into their planning.
Not all pre-migration obligations produce imported losses. The treatment of unamortised costs confirms that commercial reality, not the timing of an historic obligation, determines referability.
Application to both creditor and debtor relationships. HMRC's Corporation Tax Manual had previously suggested that s.327’s application to debtor relationships was "unlikely to arise in practice” - the present case is therefore a notable instance of precisely such an application. The decision is though equally relevant for corporate lenders migrating to the UK with loan portfolios that may embed unrealised losses attributable to pre-migration market movements or deterioration in borrower creditworthiness.
For any group considering UK migration, the judgment underscores the need to analyse debt structures holistically, modelling not only accounting outcomes, but also the economic history embedded within financial instruments before the company enters the UK tax net.
Management shareholdings disposed of for more than market value
Sale proceeds in respect of employment-related securities are typically subject to capital gains tax in the same way as sale proceeds relating to other shares. This is key not only for the management sellers, but also the buyer, given the (much higher) rates of employment tax and national insurance. At the same time, HMRC are conscious that a higher price paid to an employee could be used as a reward for past or future services – in effect a form of value shift from employment to capital gains tax. There are certain anti-avoidance provisions in ITEPA which management teams, financial sponsors and their advisors routinely have to consider. Key amongst those provisions is Chapter 3D which provides that where shares are disposed of for more than market value, the excess above market value is subject to employment tax.
One situation that can frequently occur is where for what may be seen as commercial reasons, an employee (especially a founder or key management shareholder) demands to be paid more for their shares because they are unwilling to sell unless there is this price differential; the other investors may be however be willing to exit the investment because it suits them. The buyer needs to acquire 100 per cent of the business and equally does not want to alienate the management team.
How does Chapter 3D work in these circumstances? This in very abbreviated form was what the Tribunal had to decide in Coopervision; two founders of a business were paid much more for their shares than the private equity fund seller.
The FTT Decision – Application of Chapter 3D
The first question for the FTT was whether the fact that the management team had received more, meant that they had received more than the “market value” (using the tests set out in sections 272 and 273 TCGA 1992. The FTT derived its approach to the TCGA tests from case law (including Grays Timber Products Ltd v HMRC [2010] UKSC 4) and concluded that it should determine the highest price reasonably obtainable by the hypothetical seller and the highest price a reasonably prudent purchaser would pay for the shares in question.
After a thorough examination of the circumstances leading up to the sale, the FTT found that the negotiations which produced the price differential could not be said to have taken place between parties who might be expected to act as independent willing seller and buyer. The purchaser had agreed to buy the entire issued share capital of the target company for an aggregate purchase price negotiated with the two principal management shareholders with no direct negotiations with other shareholders. Instead, the price differential was negotiated among the shareholders and so, the FTT found, the factors which were taken into account in agreeing the allocation of the aggregate purchase price between the shareholders were not of interest to a hypothetical willing purchaser of the shares in the open market. Viewed through the prism of the case law test for “market value”, the FTT found that the factors which determined the shareholders’ respective entitlements were all personal to the sellers, with no enuring benefit for the purchaser from, and immediately after, the purchase. Therefore, the FTT found that the sales by the management shareholders took place for a price more than market value and HMRC was correct to determine that the price differential should be subject to employment tax under Chapter 3D.
The FTT Decision – Categorisation as Employment-Related Securities; Carelessness
For Chapter 3D to apply, the shares held by management shareholders had to be employment-related securities. The deeming provision in s.421B ITEPA and recent case law (Vermillion, Charman) has made it increasingly difficult for managers to argue that shares they hold in their employer are anything other than employment-related. In Coopervision, while three of the four tranches of management shares were found to be employment-related, the FTT did find that the fourth tranche did not, on the facts, have an employment nexus. As such, while it will require robust factual justification, the decision highlights that shares held by managers are not automatically employment-related.
HMRC’s case also relied on being able to extend their enquiry window from four years to six years by proving that the appellant had failed to take reasonable care in not accounting for employment tax on the price differential. The decision on this point demonstrates that it will be difficult for companies to prove that they have not been careless if they have not taken appropriate specialist advice.
Impact and Significance
While the facts of this case are more complicated than some, it does examine an issue that comes up relatively frequently. Here, the buyer had set the overall budget and was not concerned in the long run as to how it was allocated. That was a matter for the sellers. In effect, one could argue that in commercial terms, the benefit as such in these sorts of situations was being provided not by the employer (or by reason of employment) but the other sellers, to procure the minority’s agreement to the overall sale. In these circumstances, it may seem harsh to tax the price differential paid to the minority as employment income, just because it was paid to an employee. Much should depend on the individual facts. It is yet to be seen whether the decision of the FTT is appealed to the Upper Tribunal.