Focus on the fashion and luxury industry: Key developments regarding antitrust, unfair commercial practices and privacy laws in Italy.

EU General Court confirms €3.5 million fine on Ahlers parent company: Insolvency does not reduce the 10 per cent turnover ceiling

On 28 November 2024, the European Commission fined Pierre Cardin and its licensee, Ahlers Group, €5.7 million for restricting cross-border sales and limiting access to certain customer groups, in breach of EU competition rules.

According to the Commission, the companies entered into agreements to block other licensees and their customers from selling Pierre Cardin products outside allocated territories and to prevent sales to discount retailers. This would have granted Ahlers territorial exclusivity in breach of EU internal market rules.

On 6 February 2025, Ahlers appealed to the EU General Court (Case T-87/25), seeking the annulment of the Commission’s decision or, in the alternative, a reduced fine. However, on 6 May 2026, the General Court (Third Chamber) dismissed in its entirety the action brought by Ahlers against the €3.5 million fine that the Commission had imposed on it for breaching Article 101 TFEU and Article 53 of the EEA Agreement in the market for Pierre Cardin-branded clothing and accessories.

Ahlers challenged the fine on a single ground. Ahlers AG (the largest Pierre Cardin licensee in the EEA) had filed for insolvency in April 2023, and its business was sold to a third-party investor on 15 July 2023. As a result, by the time the Commission adopted its decision in November 2024, Ahlers AG was no longer part of the Ahlers group. Ahlers argued that, as a result of this corporate restructuring, its group no longer had the same composition or economic capacity, and that the Commission should therefore have used a lower turnover figure as the basis for calculating the 10 per cent ceiling for its fine, in other words, taking into account only the turnover of companies that remained in its group.

Crucially, the General Court ruled that if an undertaking were allowed to reduce the ceiling for any fine by transferring certain activities to a third party before the adoption of the Commission’s fining decision, the effectiveness of competition sanctions under Regulation 1/2003 would be seriously undermined. This principle applies irrespective of whether the transfer results from voluntary restructuring or involuntary insolvency proceedings. Ahlers’s argument that it had no control over the insolvency process under German law was therefore immaterial.

The General Court further observed that the Commission's approach was favourable to Ahlers: whereas the Commission used turnover for Ahlers’ 1 December 2022 to 30 November 2023 business year, it could have used the previous business year (1 December 2021 to 30 November 2022), when the group was still fully intact, which would have resulted in higher consolidated turnover and therefore a higher fine ceiling. On the other hand, excluding Ahlers AG’s turnover entirely would have reduced the ceiling to a negligible amount, producing a fine devoid of any deterrent effect for an infringement lasting thirteen years.

This judgment reinforces an important principle for the fashion and retail sector (and all sectors in general): involuntary corporate restructuring or insolvency during a pending investigation does not provide a “safe harbour” to exclude turnover of entities that exit the group when calculating the ceiling for any fine. The Commission is entitled to consider the economic reality of the undertaking throughout the infringement period, and undertakings under investigation should be aware that the 10 per cent ceiling will be assessed by reference to consolidated accounts reflecting their real economic weight during the infringement, regardless of subsequent corporate events.

To read more about this case, see: Key takeaways from the EC’s Pierre Cardin case.

EU sweep finds one in three online traders incorrectly displayed discounts during Black Friday and Cyber Monday

(Link to source: EU sweep finds one in three online traders incorrectly display discounts during Black Friday and Cyber Monday)

On 26 March 2026, the European Commission and consumer protection authorities from 23 EU Member States, as well as Iceland and Norway, released the results of a coordinated screening ("sweep") of online discounts during Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales. The sweep assessed whether discounts and pricing practices during these major sales events complied with EU consumer law. Consumer protection authorities checked 314 online traders and found that 30 per cent referenced discounts incorrectly. Under the Price Indication Directive (Directive 98/6/EC), when a business announces a discount, the reference price must be the lowest price applied in the past 30 days.

As well as incorrect discount reference prices, the sweep identified several additional problematic sales tactics.

  • 36 per cent of the traders screened attempted to add optional items to consumers' baskets, and four in ten of those did so without clearly requesting consent.
  • 34 per cent displayed price comparisons, but six in ten of those did not clearly explain the reference for their price comparison.
  • 18 per cent used pressure-selling techniques, such as claiming a product was running out or using countdown timers, with more than half of these cases found to be misleading.
  • Finally, 10 per cent used "drip pricing", where extra fees – such as shipping or service charges – are added late in the purchasing process.

The Commission confirmed that adding items without consumer consent, displaying prices in a misleading way, falsely claiming that a product is running out, and hiding extra fees until the end of the process are all unlawful practices under EU consumer law.

Following the sweep, national consumer authorities may act against the businesses concerned. The sweep was carried out within the framework of the Consumer Protection Cooperation (CPC) network, which brings together national authorities responsible for enforcing EU consumer protection laws. Traders' obligations regarding price reductions are governed by the Price Indication Directive as mentioned above, while the promotion of prices is also regulated by the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (2005/29/EC).

This sweep is a timely reminder for online retailers across the EU, including those active in the fashion, luxury and consumer goods sectors, that the correct display of price reductions and transparency of online sales tactics remain key enforcement priorities for the Commission and national consumer authorities. The finding that nearly one in three traders incorrectly referenced discounts, combined with the widespread use of additional problematic practices – such as adding items without consent, opaque price comparisons, misleading pressure-selling and drip pricing – all of which the Commission has confirmed to be unlawful under EU consumer law, suggests a potentially significant number of businesses are at risk of sanctions for failing to rigorously apply the Price Indication Directive's 30-day rule and the standards set by the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive.

With national authorities now in a position to take action against the businesses concerned, online retailers operating in the EU should carefully review their promotional pricing practices and sales tactics to ensure full compliance, including ahead of future major sales events.

ICA opens proceedings against Benetton for non-compliance with binding commitments regarding its franchise relationships

On 21 April 2026, the Italian Competition Authority (ICA) opened proceedings against Benetton Group S.r.l., the main operating company of the Benetton Group, and its parent holding company Schema Eta S.r.l., one of the world’s most well-known fashion operators with a commercial network of approximately 2,700 stores. The proceedings concern non-compliance with binding commitments regarding Benetton’s relationships with its franchisees entered into regarding a previous ICA decision.

According to the ICA, Benetton has failed to comply with commitments relating to Decision No. 30472 of 31 January 2023, with the alleged non-compliance occurring from 1 February 2023 onwards. Under the commitments, the ICA required Benetton to introduce a series of contractual modifications aimed at restoring a fair commercial dynamic between the franchisor and its franchisees, including the elimination of purchase budgets, the recognition of franchisees' full autonomy in defining purchase orders, the removal of automatic restocking mechanisms, and the introduction of a buyback obligation for store furnishings upon termination of the franchise relationship.

The investigation into Benetton’s compliance with the commitments was triggered by a complaint filed on 30 July 2025 by the Primavera group (twenty-eight stores in Puglia and Basilicata) and corroborated by two additional franchise groups (Gruppo Ventitré in Lombardy and Gruppo Venturato in Sicily). The ICA found that Benetton had complied with its commitments only in form, while continuing the same practices that gave rise to the original proceedings.

The ICA identified two categories of non-compliance. The first concerns Benetton's breach of specific contractual obligations introduced under the commitments. On 20 June 2024, Benetton sent an identical communication to multiple franchise groups, unilaterally terminating all product supplies. No prior complaint or warning had been raised with the relevant franchisees, and the three-step formal notice procedure required under Article 11.6 of Benetton’s standard franchise agreement, a clause introduced to implement the commitments, was entirely disregarded. Benetton then went further, imposing a complete block on its IT management systems that prevented franchisees from uploading any orders, effectively causing total operational paralysis of the franchisees’ stores.

Benetton also invoked franchisees’ total debt exposure, including legacy debts from prior relationships, as grounds for termination, despite having committed to keeping legacy debts separate from current supply obligations. Benetton further failed to comply with Commitment No. 6, which required it to repurchase store furnishings at market value upon termination of the franchise relationship, and refused to take back its own business branches (rami d'azienda) and employees. This left franchisees without any recovery mechanism, forcing some to resort to extraordinary wage subsidies (CIGS) and dismissals.

Second, Benetton circumvented the commitments safeguarding franchisees' commercial autonomy. These required the elimination of contractual purchase budgets (Commitment No. 2), the recognition of franchisees' full autonomy in defining their own purchase orders (Commitment No. 3), and the removal of the automatic restocking system (Commitment No. 4). However, in practice, Benetton continued to operate as before. Although Benetton removed the term “budget” from its contracts, it continued to impose seasonal purchase targets under the new label “forecast”. These were binding objectives uploaded into Benetton's IT system (Lighthouse); failure to meet them triggered reminders or requests for additional purchases. Budgets were planned centrally by Benetton's Commercial Directorate through an internal file (the PRC), with no regard for actual store performance, and communicated via emails, phone calls and Teams meetings, at times deliberately avoiding written records. The composition of purchase orders was also defined unilaterally through predefined “Master Orders” and mandatory product clusters, leaving franchisees with no genuine discretion over what to buy. Also, the automatic restocking system was replaced by a “Stop & Go” mechanism, allowing franchisees only to accept or reject algorithmically generated proposals, with rejections systematically met with pressure from Benetton's area managers.

The ICA concluded that the evidence from the three franchise groups – managing over one hundred stores across four Italian regions – demonstrated a systematic pattern of non-compliance, not isolated incidents. Franchisees had no effective decision-making autonomy, with Benetton unilaterally imposing commercial choices through contractual provisions, internal guidelines, operational manuals, circulars and IT system constraints.

This case underscores the ICA's willingness to look beyond formal contractual compliance and scrutinise the practical implementation of binding commitments. Benetton introduced the required contractual amendments while simultaneously maintaining, through informal communications, internal guidelines and IT constraints, the same practices it had pledged to eliminate.

For parties that are subject to commitments, the message is clear: commitment decisions are not merely formal exercises, and operational workarounds will be met with enforcement action. Authorities will assess real-world conduct, not contractual language alone.

Contact