This alert highlights recent developments in the case filed by X.AI LLC (X.AI) seeking to enjoin enforcement of Colorado's Senate Bill 24-205 (SB-24-205), often referred to as the Colorado AI Act (the AI Act).1 The AI Act was set to go into effect on June 30, 2026, and purports to, among other things, prevent “algorithmic discrimination.”

X.AI filed suit challenging the AI Act in early April. On April 24, 2026, the US Department of Justice (DOJ) moved to intervene in the case to also oppose the law.2 Notably, this is the first time that the DOJ has sought to intervene in a lawsuit challenging a state AI law, marking the first practical illustration of the executive branch’s recent directive, promulgated in Executive Order 14365, for the DOJ to become actively involved in challenges to state AI laws.

The same day DOJ moved to intervene, X.AI and the Colorado Attorney General filed a joint motion to suspend enforcement of the AI Act until:

  1. the 2026 Regular Session of the Colorado General Assembly and any subsequent rulemaking related to the AI Act concludes and
  2. X.AI’s forthcoming motion for preliminary injunction is decided.

On April 27, 2026, the Court granted the Parties’ joint motion, temporarily suspending enforcement of the AI Act. This alert examines the law at issue, X.AI’s claims, and what might happen next.

Colorado’s AI Act

The AI Act was signed into law on May 17, 2024, and was initially scheduled to take effect on February 1, 2026. Due to the rapidly evolving nature of the AI industry and concerns that the law “inadvertently imposes high costs on the State, local governments, and covered businesses,” Colorado postponed the law’s effective date to June 30, 2026.3

Under the AI Act, developers and deployers of “high-risk artificial intelligence systems” would be required to exercise reasonable care to protect consumers against algorithmic discrimination.4 The AI Act defines “algorithmic discrimination” as unlawful differential treatment that disfavors an individual or a group on the basis of a protected characteristic. The AI Act excludes, however, the use of high-risk AI systems to expand a participant pool “to increase diversity or redress historical discrimination” from the definition of “algorithmic discrimination.”5

The AI Act’s potential applicability spans several industries, as it defines high-risk AI systems as systems making “consequential decisions” relating to education, employment, financial services, government services, health care, housing, insurance or legal services.6 The law also includes certain disclosure requirements, including the obligation to disclose to individuals that they are interacting with an AI system, even if the system is not categorized as high-risk.7

The AI Act also applies higher standards to AI systems it defines as high-risk. Under the law, developers and deployers of high-risk AI systems are required to conduct an impact assessment, the content of which is prescribed by the AI Act.8 Developers and deployers of high-risk AI systems are also required to make specific disclosures to other developers and deployers, as well as to the public through statements published on their websites.

The AI Act applies to developers and deployers of AI systems where a consequential decision may affect any Colorado resident, regardless of where that resident is located or where the AI system is developed or used. The AI Act does not provide for a private right of action for enforcement; the Colorado Attorney General has exclusive authority to enforce it.9

X.AI’s lawsuit and claims

As X.AI designs and deploys its AI model “Grok,” the company expected to be subject to the obligations and requirements of the AI Act after the law went into effect. X.AI filed a complaint against the Colorado Attorney General to challenge the law before its effective date, seeking declaratory and injunctive relief and alleging a number of claims against the AI Act on constitutional grounds. In short, X.AI filed suit to prevent the AI Act from being enforced.

First Amendment rights

In support of its request to enjoin enforcement, X.AI argues that designing an AI model constitutes protected speech and that the AI Act unlawfully compels the company to redesign Grok to reflect Colorado's views on fairness and equity rather than X.AI's own editorial judgment. X.AI argues that it is engaging in speech when it designs and trains its model, which it argues is similar to the protected expressive activity of video game creators, social media platforms and search engines.

X.AI also challenges the law's mandatory disclosure requirements on free speech grounds, contending that compelling X.AI to create, maintain and disseminate information about its efforts to identify and mitigate algorithmic discrimination, as that term is defined by the AI Act, violates X.AI’s First Amendment right to refrain from speaking.

X.AI further argues that the law’s mandatory disclosure requirements do not compel commercial speech, which it defines as speech that “does no more than propose a commercial transaction” and which generally receives less First Amendment protection. Instead, X.AI asserts that the compelled speech is private speech, subject to more First Amendment protection, because it concerns X.AI's internal practices for evaluating and mitigating possible model biases. Thus, X.AI maintains that the compelled speech is entitled to full First Amendment protection and cannot be subjected to the reduced scrutiny applicable to commercial speech.

Extraterritorial reach and interstate commerce

X.AI also asserts that the AI Act improperly regulates activity and entities outside of Colorado. On that basis, X.AI argues that the law amounts to an unconstitutional extraterritorial state regulation.

Further, X.AI argues that the burden on X.AI of complying with the AI Act is substantial because compliance would require X.AI to alter its products on a nationwide basis and would require significant economic and engineering investment to achieve compliance at that scale. X.AI argues that “any local benefit” of the AI Act is outweighed by the burden it imposes on interstate commerce and is “speculative” because there is no evidence that AI systems like “Grok” are causing algorithmic discrimination as that term is defined under the AI Act.

Fourteenth Amendment Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses

X.AI also alleges the AI Act fails to give developers and deployers subject to its requirements and obligations fair notice of what “algorithmic discrimination” means. X.AI argues that certain terms that are critical to determining applicability and compliance are undefined in the AI Act, rendering the law unconstitutionally vague.

For instance, X.AI notes that undefined terms like “perceived”—when used in combination with certain individual attributes like age, national origin or disability—“differential treatment,” and “impact” could all affect who the law applies to and how. Because the Colorado Attorney General holds exclusive enforcement and rulemaking authority under the AI Act, X.AI claims that this alleged vagueness “invites arbitrary enforcement.”

Finally, X.AI challenges the AI Act’s carveout exempting AI outputs aimed at increasing diversity and redressing historical discrimination from the AI Act's definition of “algorithmic discrimination.” X.AI argues that this constitutes “codified discrimination” in violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the US Constitution.

Next steps and key takeaways

Now that the Court has stayed relevant deadlines and formalized the parties’ agreement that the Colorado Attorney General will temporarily suspend enforcement of the law, there are two potential next steps. First, Colorado may choose to amend, repeal or replace the AI Act during the current legislative session and via subsequent rulemaking. Second, X.AI has indicated that it will move for a preliminary injunction of the law as currently structured. These steps, whether one or both occur, could significantly alter the analysis of X.AI’s claims regarding the AI Act and whether it is ultimately enforceable. Because the Court has not expressed any view on the merits of the case, that ultimate outcome is difficult to predict at this time. We will continue to monitor this litigation and provide updates as events occur.

In the meantime, companies should continue to closely monitor the law’s evolution and any related rulemaking initiatives undertaken by the Colorado Attorney General. More broadly, they should also be aware of other transparency and accountability requirements for AI developers and deployers that remain part of a growing regulatory trend, even as lawmakers continue to grapple with the practical challenges of legislating in a rapidly developing technological domain. Companies should also be aware of recent federal initiatives to assume an active, leading role in AI rulemaking (initiatives like those reflected in Executive Order 14365) and should anticipate other efforts to address a fragmented, state-by-state approach to regulating the AI industry. In light of the fast-moving regulatory environment, companies should consider proactive preparation over waiting for further regulatory or judicial clarification. For advice regarding this law’s or this lawsuit’s practical implications, or for representation related to the AI Act or other state AI laws, please contact us.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    See X.AI LLC v. Weiser, Case No. 1:26-cv-01515 (D. Colo. Apr. 7, 2026)

  2. 2

    See Compl. X.AI LLC v. Weiser, Case No. 1:26-cv-01515 (D. Colo. Apr. 24, 2026)

  3. 3

    See Executive Order D 2025 009, August 6, 2025.

  4. 4

    See C.R.S.A. § 6-1-1702(1).

  5. 5

    See C.R.S.A. § 6-1-1701(1).

  6. 6

    See C.R.S.A. § 6-1-1701(3).

  7. 7

    See C.R.S.A. § 6-1-1704.

  8. 8

    See C.R.S.A. § 6-1-1703 (3).

  9. 9

    See C.R.S.A. § 6-1-1706.

Contact