With thanks to Elizabeth Brednya.
On 29 May 2026, the New South Wales Supreme Court delivered judgment in Dexus Capital Investors Limited v Australia Pacific Airports Corporation Limited [2026] NSWSC 600 (Dexus v APAC). Hammerschlag CJ in Eq held that “Dexus committed a material Irremediable Breach of the Shareholders’ Deed” by “clandestinely” disclosing APAC’s confidential information as part of an attempted share sale process code-named Project Mercury. His Honour also examined Dexus’ conduct after the disclosure came to the attention of APAC’s management and Board, finding that Dexus “wholly or partially concealed” its conduct. Its approach reflected a “deliberate and disingenuous withholding of information” from APAC.
The decision, and the circumstances which gave rise to the dispute, provide important insights for directors, general counsel and fund managers – particularly those involved in the ownership and management of major infrastructure assets.
It is also just one in a growing number of disputes over large infrastructure and commercial assets in which Norton Rose Fulbright has acted. These disputes expose the position that many of these assets are held under outdated agreements that may no longer be fit for purpose, or as quasi-joint ventures, and that infrastructure assets are increasingly traded. Dexus v APAC shows that even where a dispute focuses on a particular contractual issue – here, the unauthorised disclosure of confidential information belonging to APAC – a raft of other corporate issues and considerations can find their way into a court room.
Facts
As part of Project Mercury, and unbeknownst to APAC or other shareholders, Dexus distributed information to a range of advisors and prospective purchasers. That information included highly confidential and commercially sensitive information that a witness described as APAC’s “crown jewels”. When APAC learned of the disclosure, management and the Board took several steps to assess its scope and consequences. The Board concluded that the disclosure and the nature of Dexus’ conduct was such that it had committed a “material Irremediable breach” of the restrictions on information sharing under the Shareholders’ Deed and issued a “Default Notice” initiating a compulsory sale of Dexus’ shares to the non-defaulting shareholders.
Dexus challenged the validity of the Default Notice on several grounds, including:
- Dexus did not breach the Shareholders’ Deed or its breach was neither material nor irremediable;
- If Dexus itself breached, the non-selling shareholders within the Dexus bloc did not do so and the Default Notice was therefore wholly ineffective;
- The directors’ exercise of their discretion to confirm the default and to give a Default Notice was in breach of their obligation to act justly and faithfully and in the best interests of APAC because they were improperly motivated (by desire to rid APAC of the Dexus bloc, avoid future operation of affiliate transfer provisions and enable other shareholders to acquire more shares in APAC).
His Honour rejected all of Dexus’ claims, vindicating the Board’s process and finding the Default Notice valid and effective.
Key takeaways
Director insights
- Directors must adopt a careful and considered approach to decision-making and understand the legal framework in which the exercise of a contractual discretion by a Board will be judged. The decision confirms the well-established principle that directors must exercise their powers in good faith and for the purpose for which they were given. However, the validity of the Board’s confirmation of breach was not otherwise subject to review by the Court. The Board’s determination was found to be valid unless Dexus could prove the equivalent of fraud or bad faith on the part of those without whose participation the resolution would not have been adopted. This provides comfort to directors whose decisions may be subject to court scrutiny but also emphasises the importance of sound governance and robust and well-documented decision-making processes.
- Nominee directors must be alert to potential conflicts between the interests of their nominating shareholder and the company. This includes understanding the circumstances in which they can have regard to the interests of their nominated shareholder and carefully managing the flow of information to the shareholder they represent. Getting conflicts wrong can have serious consequences. His Honour found that there was “tension between Dexus’ entrepreneurial urges to sell APAC shares for the benefit of its constituents at the highest achievable price and its duty not to act contrary to APAC’s interests by disclosing its Confidential Information so as to achieve the sales outcome”.
- Clear communication and information-sharing protocols, especially in relation to sensitive company information, are essential for effective governance and risk management. Bespoke protocols tailored to whether the information is going to directors, shareholders, or external recipients are needed to maximise clarity and certainty regarding the circumstances in which sensitive information can be shared.
General counsel insights
- There is no substitute for robust independent legal advice that clearly identifies potential risks and is prepared to interrogate convenient assumptions. The judgment provides a salient lesson to in-house counsel regarding the dangers of ceding independence and robust risk management in the face of commercial drivers.
- Any share sale transaction must be carefully evaluated for compliance with the applicable legal agreements and legal counsel should maintain oversight of information sharing. In this case, Dexus’ clear failure to comply with the express requirements on information sharing in the Shareholders’ Deed not only resulted in a ‘technical’ breach but denied other shareholders the real and substantive protections to which they were entitled. It was no answer to (incorrectly) claim the disclosure would not result in any harm to APAC or that alternative confidentiality arrangements were adequate. It is essential for legal oversight to be built into the structure of the sale process and to cover the nature of information to be shared at each stage and the terms on which that will occur.
- There is no ‘market standard’ confidentiality regime. Any disclosure of confidential information must be in accordance with the applicable legal agreements and restraints, which need to be drafted having regard to the nature of the information, the nature of the recipient and the purpose for which it is being disclosed. Dexus’ management of the sale process departed from good practice in a few respects. The Court held that the confidentiality deeds used by Dexus did not offer sufficient protection for APAC’s confidential information. It also found that Dexus disclosed information to its advisors when it did not have any deed poll in place, did not require confidentiality deeds from the advisors to buyers and gave three parties access to a virtual data room without any confidentiality agreements.
- Maintain records and document management hygiene. General Counsel should ensure that corporate records are maintained in an organised manner. Failure to do so can give rise to disputes where past practice is relied on but cannot later be verified by reference to company records. Dexus' reliance on an alleged historical approval was futile when no record of the approval could be located. Company policies regulating the use of email, text and internal chat channels should be in place and regularly reviewed as those communications are likely to be interrogated as part of any dispute.
- The cover up can be worse than the crime. How a company responds to allegations of misconduct or breach can determine whether that breach leads to dispute. The Court found that Dexus had obfuscated, misled the Board and was not honest in its dealings with APAC and the other shareholders. This behaviour destroyed APAC’s trust in Dexus and was an important consideration in finding a material and Irremediable breach.
Fund insights
-
A company acting as trustee does not have multiple legal “capacities” or limited liability to external parties due to its position as “trustee”. A trustee does not have separate legal personality in respect of different beneficiaries. If the interests of beneficiaries diverge, trustees need to carefully manage resulting conflicts, including as a party to litigation.
-
Fund managers need to be aware of their (potentially conflicting) duties and obligations. Corporate fund managers often simultaneously act as manager, trustee, shareholder and director and the duties and obligations of these roles may come into tension. The potential for conflict can be exacerbated in sales processes and by other commercial drivers. Robust, documented conflict management systems are a “must-have” and great care should be taken where an employee holds multiple roles. Conflict management systems should be regularly reviewed by legal officers.
-
Trust instruments and contracts must be reviewed to understand obligations and how liability is allocated. His Honour rejected any distinction between “selling shareholders” and “non-selling shareholders”. The definition of “Shareholder” in the Shareholders’ Deed was such that Dexus’ conduct could be sheeted home to all members of the Dexus bloc. The operation of management and bloc arrangements should be carefully examined from a risk perspective.
Conclusion
The decision in Dexus v APAC casts a spotlight on corporate governance and contract management practices and highlights the scrutiny that can apply to decision-making in high stakes corporate stoushes. It offers important lessons for directors, legal counsel and funds on how to manage risk and ensure robust and defensible decision-making.