In this case, the Technology and Construction Court held that a landlord’s ‘good condition’ covenant required removal and replacement of cladding on a multi-storey hotel building, displacing the general presumption that a good condition covenant does not require remediation of inherent defects. The court also held that the landlord’s ‘legal obligations’ covenant imposed a positive duty to carry out the works required by the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 (“FSO”). In a post-Grenfell context, landlords may now face liability for remedying serious fire safety defects, including cladding, and should be proactive in assessing and addressing such risks.
Factual background
The case concerned the purpose-built 16-storey Ibis London Wembley Hotel. The claimant tenant, Essendi UK Hotels 2 Ltd (“Essendi”), leased and operated the hotel and the defendant, London Property Co Ltd (“LPC”), owned the freehold of the building.
In 2005, Essendi (as then owner of the freehold) engaged contractors to replace the solid aluminium cladding with a new lightweight cladding. Neither Essendi nor its professional advisers were aware at the time that the new cladding comprised aluminium composite material with a highly combustible polyethylene core (“category 3 ACM”), the same type of cladding that was a principal cause of the Grenfell Tower fire. This was consistent with the knowledge of the construction sector at the time. In 2007, Essendi entered a sale and leaseback arrangement, selling the freehold to LPC’s predecessor in title and taking an original lease for 12 years. The original lease placed responsibility for cladding defects on Essendi until May 2017, after which the landlord assumed liability for any repairs required to the cladding.
LPC purchased the freehold in April 2018 and Essendi entered a new lease in March 2019 on substantially the same terms as the original lease, except for the bespoke cladding provisions. Under the lease the landlord’s obligations included:
- a covenant to ‘put and keep’ the building (including the cladding) ‘at all times in good and substantial repair and condition’ (the “good condition covenant”); and
- a ‘legal obligations’ covenant requiring the carrying out of works to comply with legal obligations relating to the building (the “legal obligations covenant”).
Following the Grenfell Tower fire in June 2017, investigations by LPC’s agents raised concerns about the core of the cladding. However, an external report instructed by LPC confirmed that the panels were solid aluminium. In late 2024, Essendi undertook its own invasive survey which confirmed that the cladding was category 3 ACM. In 2025, faced with inaction from LPC, Essendi closed the hotel following advice from its independent fire safety expert that there was an unacceptable risk to guests.
Legal issues
Both parties’ fire safety experts agreed that the category 3 ACM cladding represented an ‘intolerable risk’ of fire and required removal. The principal issue was responsibility for the works to remove and replace the cladding.
Essendi contended that LPC was responsible for removing the cladding pursuant to either the ‘good condition covenant’, the ‘legal obligations covenant’ or the obligation not to derogate from its grant of the lease. LPC’s defence rested on the cladding provisions of the original lease placing responsibility on Essendi to remedy any cladding defects prior to May 2017.
Decision
In relation to the ‘good condition covenant’, the court held that LPC was in breach by failing to remove and replace the category 3 ACM cladding. The court acknowledged that there was a general presumption that a good condition covenant does not require remediation of an intrinsic defect which has not caused physical damage. However, the court held that this was a rebuttable presumption, displaced in this case by the relevant circumstances. These were namely (i) the use of the building as a hotel, (ii) the height of the building, (iii) the significance of category 3 ACM post-Grenfell, (iv) both parties’ awareness of the importance of cladding integrity shown by the original bespoke cladding provisions, and (v) the absence of service charge provisions meaning that the parties had allocated financial risk to the landlord.
The court found that LPC was also in breach of the ‘legal obligations covenant’ by reference to its obligations under the FSO. LPC was the ‘responsible person’ under the FSO and its obligations under such required removal and replacement of the category 3 ACM panels. Notably, while Article 39 of the FSO precludes a direct civil action for breach, the court held that the ‘legal obligations covenant’ in the lease was sufficiently clear and explicit to make the statutory duties actionable as a contractual obligation.
In addition, the court held that:
- Essendi had not been liable to remove the cladding under the original lease, as Essendi had not been aware that the panels were category 3 ACM during this period (its liability had ended a month prior to the Grenfell Tower fire);
- LPC had not breached its obligation not to derogate from grant;
- Essendi’s decision to close the hotel was caused, in fact and law, by LPC’s breaches and was a reasonable step to take in the circumstances;
- Essendi was entitled to an order for specific performance requiring LPC to remove the category 3 ACM cladding within 6 months and replace it within 18 months; and
- Essendi was entitled to proceed to an assessment of damages (to be the subject of a further trial).
Key takeaways
The decision in this case confirms that a covenant to keep a building in good condition can, depending on the circumstances, include remedying intrinsic defects that have not yet caused physical damage. In the post-Grenfell context of high-rise buildings used for accommodation for residential uses (including hotels), the presence of category 3 ACM cladding falls within the scope of a landlord’s obligation to put and keep a building in good and substantial condition. The covenant also imposes strict liability on landlords; it is irrelevant if a landlord has actual knowledge of the defect at the time of the lease. Furthermore, landlords should take prompt action to investigate suspected fire safety defects.
In addition, parties should be mindful of the following considerations. Firstly, despite the FSO excluding civil claims, sufficiently clear and explicit contractual provisions can render FSO duties contractually enforceable between landlord and tenant. Secondly, the absence of service charge provisions is a material factor in allocating risk, as it is deemed that financial risk has been allocated to the landlord. Finally, common law and contractual claims can be used to achieve what is in substance a building safety remediation order in respect of buildings (like hotels), despite them being excluded from the Building Safety Act 2022.