The Federal Court has released new guidelines on summary judgment and summary trials in complex proceedings. These guidelines will apply to most patent actions and many copyright and trademark actions before the court. The stated aim of the new guidelines is “to provide greater clarity and assistance to parties contemplating motions for summary judgment or summary trial.” The new guidelines do so by listing issues suitable for early determination and providing a new framework where procedural disputes are addressed before the motion for summary judgment or summary trial is even brought.
Background on the Guidelines
On June 22, 2026, the Federal Court added new guidelines on summary judgment and summary trials to its Case and Trial Management Guidelines for Complex Proceedings, Proceedings under the PM(NOC) Regulations, and Appeals under Subsection 56(1) of the Trademarks Act (Guidelines). As the name suggests, the Guidelines are primarily for complex proceedings, such as actions expected to require at least five days of trial and actions brought under the Patented Medicines (Notice of Compliance) Regulations (PM(NOC) Proceedings).
Suitable issues for early determination
The new Guidelines clarify when summary judgment and summary trial may be “suitable.” Specifically, summary judgment may be suitable for deciding issues with no expert evidence and no significant credibility issues, whereas summary trial may be suitable for deciding issues with expert evidence and that “involve issues where credibility will need to be assessed” (e.g., by live cross-examination before the court). The non-exhaustive list of presumptively suitable issues is:
- Summary judgment: threshold issues (estoppel, res judicata, abuse of process, limitation periods); pure questions of law; patent non-infringement where prior construction exists and in the absence of expert evidence or significant credibility issues; and
- Summary trial: patent claims construction, non-infringement, inventorship, narrow validity issues, authorship, ownership and ability or status to claim rights.
New procedural path to summary judgment or summary trial
The new Guidelines set out a two-step process leading up to a motion for summary judgment or summary trial. In the first step, the nature of the proposed motion is considered by the court and procedural disputes—including whether the motion may be brought—determined. Specifically:
- Early notice: Parties are to advise the court of any intended motion for summary judgment or summary trial as early as possible and before a trial date is set. In PM(NOC) Proceedings, parties must advise the court of such an intention within three months of the action starting or the close of pleadings, whichever is later. A PM(NOC) trial date will not be set until after this period ends.
- First CMC: Before the motion is brought, a case management conference (CMC) will be held to discuss: whether the parties agree to the procedure contemplated (summary judgment or summary trial), the nature of the issues and evidence, credibility concerns, whether the motion is likely to resolve the proceeding in whole or in part, and a proposed schedule.
- Procedural disputes: Where the CMC identifies key procedural disputes between the parties, these disputes will be decided before the motion for summary judgment or summary trial is brought. Specifically, the presiding judge (i.e. the judge who would hear the eventual motion) will determine disputes over (i) “whether a summary proceeding may be brought,” and (ii) whether summary judgment or summary trial is the more appropriate procedure. These decisions will typically be made based on written submissions and a proposed notice of motion and will be made within 30 days of submissions being completed.
In the second step, the actual motion for summary judgment or summary trial is brought, following the ordinary course in the Federal Courts Rules. This will require the moving party to prepare a motion record, which, depending on the issue, may contain extensive fact and expert evidence. For motions for summary trial, the new Guidelines add a CMC with the presiding judge to discuss a schedule, whether there will be live cross-examination, and the nature of the records to be filed.
Comments
The new Guidelines provide more structure to, and facilitate, motions for early determination of potentially dispositive issues in IP cases in Canada and may lead to more parties bringing such motions.
A key impediment to parties doing so in the past has been the risk of incurring substantial legal/expert fees to prepare a motion record without knowing whether the court will find the matter appropriate for summary judgment or summary trial. The new Guidelines reduce this risk, but may not eliminate it.
First, the new Guidelines identify certain issues that may be suitable for summary judgment or summary trial. Second, the two-step process in the new Guidelines provides more certainty by determining the motion’s procedure early, before the motion record is prepared. Of particular interest here is the court’s willingness to determine early “whether a summary proceeding may be brought.” It remains to be seen how the court will decide “may be brought,” for example, if the court will determine, at this early stage, whether a proposed issue can be efficiently and justly decided in a summary proceeding and if so, on what basis it will make such determinations.