The Alberta Court of King’s Bench recently denied a company’s application to enjoin alleged breaches of a non-solicitation provision on the basis that the provision was ambiguous and overbroad. The decision is a reminder of the risks of imprecise drafting and the importance of context in assessing the enforceability of restrictive covenants, particularly non-solicitation covenants.
In Intellimedia Limited Partnership v Jawad, Marion J. found that a non-solicitation covenant framed in the present tense when referring to “customers,” without clarification, was too ambiguous to justify injunctive relief, even where the accompanying non-competition provision did justify injunctive relief.
Background
The defendant, Ahmad Jawad, was a co-founder and CEO of a software company focused on the education sector. In 2020, he sold his company’s assets to the applicant and was hired as the applicant’s CEO. The Asset Purchase Agreement (APA) contained non-competition and non-solicitation restrictive covenants.
Mr. Jawad was employed by the applicant until 2024. During that time, he formed another company that also developed software for educational institutions in largely the same market, with many similar core features, but that leveraged artificial intelligence (AI). When the applicant became aware that Mr. Jawad and his new company were developing an arguably competing product, it commenced an action and sought injunctions restraining breaches of the non-competition and non-solicitation covenants.
Decision
While the court granted injunctive relief on other grounds, including the non-competition clause in the APA, it declined to grant an injunction to enjoin breaches of the non-solicitation clause because of its ambiguity.
Non-solicitation clause enforcement
The court reiterated several established principles for determining whether a non-solicitation covenant is enforceable, including that:
- Its meaning must be ascertainable.
- It must be possible to determine when it is breached.
- It must apply to a “reasonably knowable group of people.”
The subject clause provided that Mr. Jawad would not “solicit the business of any Person who is a customer of Buyer for services materially similar to those offered by Buyer” (emphasis added). The restriction applied to customers in the present tense, without limiting it to persons the applicant had a connection with during Mr. Jawad’s employment. This proved fatal in the court’s view, since Mr. Jawad could not know whether any given person later became a customer after his employment ended. As a result, the court declined to enforce the non-solicitation clause.
This highlights that the failure to limit a non-solicitation covenant to a defined and knowable group, such as customers during the period of employment, creates ambiguity and overbreadth that will defeat enforceability.
Non-competition clause enforcement
In contrast, the court upheld the non-competition clause. In doing so, it applied the following established principles to determine that the clause was reasonable and enforceable:
- A non-competition covenant must be reasonable in scope, duration, and geography, having regard to the interests it protects.
- The reasonableness of the geographic scope of the covenant is assessed with reference to the geographic scope of the business that was sold.
- Where the covenant forms part of a commercial transaction akin to the sale of a business, it is presumed enforceable unless proven unreasonable.
The court considered the scope of activities, geographic reach, and duration (five years) and found the clause reasonable. It noted the restriction targeted the creation or licensing of education software products for educational institutions that directly compete with any software products of the applicant. Given this clear and narrow focus within a defined market, Justice Marion held that the non-competition clause was appropriately tailored to the assets sold under the APA and it was reasonable and enforceable on its face.
Takeaways
This decision reinforces that Alberta courts will enforce a well-targeted non-competition covenant within a defined market. By contrast, non-solicitation covenants that rely on present-tense language and fail to confine the restricted group to a clear, knowable set may be found unenforceable.
It is also notable in the context of the rapidly expanding market for AI-driven software. Practitioners should be cautious in assuming that existing restrictive covenants will clearly capture emerging technologies. While the non-competition clause in this case was found to extend to AI-enabled software, that conclusion appears tied to the overlap in functionality and the relatively narrow market at issue. As technologies evolve in less predictable ways, similar assumptions may not hold.
Precision as to “who,” “when,” and “where” is not merely formalism; it is the price of enforceability.