The finer details of how DB pension schemes can release surplus to employers are out for consultation. The new statutory framework is expected to come into force in April 2027. The focus is now shifting from whether surplus can be released to how to do it.

We set out the seven key steps trustees and employers will need to follow to release surplus funds, consider the scope for members to share in the surplus and flag what is still to come.

The seven steps to surplus release

There is a consultation on draft regulations to set out the process trustees and employers would need to follow to release surplus funds from a defined benefit pension scheme while the scheme is ongoing. The Pensions Regulator has also set out its own expectations, including the factors scheme trustees will need to consider when making decisions on surplus.

While the detail may still change before the regulations are finalised, the overall structure is unlikely to shift significantly. The steps below reflect the process as we currently expect it to operate.

1. Check scheme rules

Trustees must ensure the rules allow surplus to be paid to employers. If the rules block payment or are overly restrictive, trustees will be able to use their new unilateral resolution-making power under the Pension Schemes Act 2026 either to introduce a new power or to amend an existing power. This unilateral power only covers payments to employers and can’t be used for a scheme already in winding-up.

2. Carry out an actuarial assessment

The trustees need an actuarial assessment from the scheme actuary that the value of the scheme’s assets is greater than the amount of its liabilities. To do that, the trustees must also take investment advice to give the actuary the value of the scheme’s assets and the date on which they were valued.

The actuary’s assessment must be on a low dependency funding basis, and can be done as part of the scheme’s triennial valuation or at any other time.

3. Agree provisional amount of surplus to release

The trustees must consult employers before deciding on a provisional amount of surplus to be paid to the employers and a target date for payment, ensuring the scheme will keep an appropriate buffer above 100 per cent funding on a low dependency basis after the payment.

The trustees must take actuarial advice on both points, and may also wish to take covenant, investment and legal advice at this stage.

No payment can be made unless the employers agree to it, so this is also the point to consider and discuss with the employer any proposed member benefit enhancements or member surplus payments.

4. Give members three months’ notice

Members must be given written notice at least three months before the target date. The notice must set out the proposed payment to the employer, timing of the payment and any planned member benefit enhancements or member surplus payments.

5. Obtain final actuarial certificate

The actuary must confirm the scheme remains in surplus on a low dependency funding basis and is at least as likely as not to stay above that level for three years after the surplus release. Providing this forward-looking confirmation may be challenging in practice, and the Financial Reporting Council intends to issue guidance to support actuaries giving this confirmation.

6. Make the surplus payment to the employer within five working days

The trustees must pay the agreed surplus amount to the employer within five working days of the date of the actuarial certificate.

7. Notify the Pensions Regulator within one week

Within one week of the surplus payment to the employer, trustees must report to the Pensions Regulator with full details of the payment, including any associated member benefit enhancements or member surplus payments.

Can members share in the surplus?

The draft regulations assume surplus can be paid to members, and refer to trustees choosing to enhance benefits or make payments to members alongside any payment to the employer.

We expect next year’s Finance Bill to authorise a new type of member surplus payment to allow one-off lump sum payment to members.

However, there is currently no overarching statutory power for trustees to pay surplus directly to members. Trustees will therefore need to rely on existing rules and discretionary powers, or seek a new power. In either case employer consent will often be needed.

Employer consent is already a pre-condition to any use of the surplus release power. That creates a potential impasse if trustees wish to use surplus for the benefit of members: the employer can block that use unless it is satisfied with the surplus allocation between the employer and members.

What happens next?

We expect surplus release to be possible from April 2027. Further detail is still to come before the regime is fully operational, with guidance and tax legislation expected to provide more detail on how the framework will work in practice.

  • Draft regulations – the consultation on the draft regulations closes on September 2, 2026.
  • The Pensions Regulator guidance – a consultation on draft guidance is expected, with final guidance due to be in place by April 2027.
  • HMRC framework for authorised member surplus payments – a consultation and subsequent legislation is expected in the Finance Bill 2026 – 2027.
  • Actuarial guidance – the Financial Reporting Council will issue technical actuarial guidance to support the actuarial certification required for surplus release. The Financial Reporting Council has already invited stakeholders to a roundtable on July 28, 2026, to discuss this.

Contact