The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has issued a proposed rule to implement section 71115 of Public Law 119-21, commonly known as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), and referred to by CMS as the Working Families Tax Cut (WFTC) legislation. Beginning October 1, 2026, section 71115 replaces the long-standing 6 percent indirect hold harmless threshold with state- and provider-class-specific applicable percentages generally based on taxes that were enacted and imposed as of July 4, 2025. Because 49 states and the District of Columbia rely on provider taxes to finance Medicaid, this is fundamentally a Medicaid financing rule with direct implications for provider reimbursement and access to care, particularly where Medicaid payment rates, supplemental payments or other funding mechanisms depend on provider tax revenue. Regardless of whether you reside in an expansion or non-expansion state, the provisions of this proposed rule will impact future Medicaid funding in your state.

Statutory framework: Overview

Section 1902 requires that states share in the cost of Medicaid expenditures, with financial participation by the state of not less than 40 percent. Non-state government units may contribute to the state share of medical assistance expenditures up to 60 percent of the non-federal share of financial participation meant to draw down the additional matching dollars used to run Medicaid programs. As a result, the use of non-state government units has grown as states have leveraged their ability to draw down additional Medicaid dollars.

Section 1903(w) of the Social Security Act and its implementing regulations govern healthcare-related taxes used to finance the non-federal share of Medicaid. To qualify for federal Medicaid matching funds, a tax must apply to a permissible class of items or services and generally must be broad-based and uniform. States also may not hold taxpayers harmless for the cost of the tax, either directly or indirectly.

The hold harmless rule is intended to prevent assurances to providers that they will recover the tax through increased Medicaid payments or other state-funded payments. If a tax arrangement effectively guarantees repayment of the tax burden, it is disqualified under Section 1903(w), regardless of how the arrangement is structured.

Indirect hold harmless arrangements are currently evaluated under a two-part test. The first prong examines whether the tax, as a percentage of net patient revenue, exceeds the applicable threshold. The second prong, commonly known as the 75/75 test, examines whether 75 percent or more of taxpayers in the class receive 75 percent or more of their total tax costs back through Medicaid or other state payments, a circumstance that may indicate an impermissible indirect hold harmless arrangement.

As a practical matter, section 71115 generally prevents new provider taxes and caps existing taxes at July 4, 2025, levels. This freeze carries meaningful implications even in non-expansion states, where it narrows a long-used mechanism for financing the non-federal share of Medicaid.

For states that adopted Medicaid expansion under the Affordable Care Act, section 71115 phases down provider tax thresholds for most provider classes beginning October 1, 2027, or federal fiscal year (FFY) 2028. The threshold for each expansion state will be the lower of its applicable percentage or 5.5 percent of net patient revenue. It will decrease by 0.5 percentage points annually until it reaches 3.5 percent in FFY 2032. The phase-down does not apply to nursing facility taxes or taxes on intermediate care facilities for individuals with intellectual disabilities (ICF/IID) that were in effect as of July 4, 2025. However, those classes remain subject to their own existing thresholds.

The proposed rule: Key highlights

Sunset of the 75/75 alternative test

CMS proposes to sunset the 75/75 test as a compliance pathway beginning October 1, 2026. Under current rules, a tax that exceeds the applicable percentage threshold may still qualify if it satisfies the second prong of the hold harmless test. The proposed rule would eliminate that regulatory flexibility going forward. Although section 71115 establishes new indirect hold harmless thresholds, CMS's proposal to sunset the 75/75 pathway reflects an exercise of regulatory discretion rather than an express statutory directive. Going forward, the indirect hold harmless threshold would serve as the sole compliance test.

New provider tax class: Services of health insurers

CMS proposes to add “Services of Health Insurers” as a new permissible provider tax class. This proposal warrants attention because section 71115 references permissible classes in effect on May 1, 2025, and CMS therefore separately explains why the same indirect hold harmless framework should apply to a class added later by regulation. States that impose taxes on health insurers, and the health insurers subject to them, should evaluate whether those arrangements would satisfy the proposed requirements if this new class is adopted.

Interaction with the 2026 provider tax final rule

The proposed rule should be read alongside CMS’s February 2026 final rule (CMS-2448-F) implementing section 71117, which addresses when non-uniform provider taxes can qualify for waiver treatment and limits the use of certain differential rate structures tied to Medicaid volume or Medicaid business. The two rules address distinct parts of the provider tax framework: section 71115 caps the amount of provider tax revenue states may raise, while section 71117 and the February 2026 rule determine whether certain tax structures remain approvable. Compliance with one does not establish compliance with the other. States with approved uniformity waivers remain subject to the transition periods in the February 2026 final rule.

Definitions

The proposed rule defines “net patient revenue” as revenue tied to the applicable class of healthcare items or services, regardless of payer, which CMS characterizes as a clarification of longstanding interpretation rather than a new policy direction. It also codifies the section 71115 definition of “expansion state” and would formalize positions that CMS previewed in its November 2025 Dear Colleague Letter regarding the meaning of “enacted” and “imposed.” Under the proposed rule, a provider tax generally is considered “enacted” only if the authorizing legislative process was completed by July 4, 2025. A tax generally is considered “imposed” only if it was in effect on that date, and where federal approval was required, the approval was effective by July 4, 2025.

Threshold calculations and reporting

The proposed rule also establishes implementation and review mechanics for the new class-specific thresholds, including a nonbinding interim review process for states. Although procedural in form, that process may affect how states assess available provider tax capacity during the transition and, in turn, could have practical implications for Medicaid payment levels and other funding supports tied to provider tax revenue. The methodology ultimately determines the amount of provider tax capacity available within a particular class and therefore may affect Medicaid financing flexibility over time.

Implications for provider organizations

The proposed rule has direct implications for providers with significant Medicaid volume. The central risk is not merely whether a state can preserve an existing provider tax, but whether it will have enough financing flexibility to sustain the Medicaid payments supported by that revenue. Because states often use provider taxes to finance Medicaid spending, reductions in provider tax revenues are likely to result in lower Medicaid benefit expenditures, potentially affecting provider payment rates, covered services or both. Medicaid-dependent hospitals, including children’s hospitals, may be especially exposed where limits on provider tax capacity affect base rates, supplemental payments, directed payment pools and other funding streams. Providers in non-expansion states also should not assume they are unaffected, because even without the phase-down, their existing tax thresholds generally would be frozen at July 4, 2025, levels.

Comments are due September 21, 2026; organizations considering comments should align legal, operational and financial teams early given the implications for both Medicaid financing structure and downstream provider payment effects. A well-supported comment that includes concrete operational, financial or compliance information may be most useful where it addresses implementation choices and the practical effects of the proposed rule on Medicaid financing and provider payments. Our firm has experience developing and submitting comments on CMS proposed rules on behalf of hospital and health system clients and would welcome the opportunity to assist.

Contact