Overview
A trio of recent decisions has brought renewed focus to the threshold eligibility requirements for recognition under Chapter 15 of the US Bankruptcy Code.
In re Siu-Fung Ceramics Holdings Limited, a decision of the US Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Texas, held that Section 109(a) of the US Bankruptcy Code (“Section 109(a)”) applies in Chapter 15 cases and denied recognition where the foreign debtor did not have property in the US as of the petition date. The court declined to consider a retainer deposited with US counsel after the filing.1
That decision followed in re Geden Holdings, Ltd., an earlier decision of the Texan court, which denied recognition of a Maltese liquidation proceeding based on the absence of sufficient activity to establish Center of Main Interests (COMI) as of the petition date.2 By contrast, in re Venus Capital Management, a decision of the US Bankruptcy Court for the District of Rhode Island, held that Section 109(a) does not apply to Chapter 15 cases, but found that the debtors would have satisfied Section 109(a) in any event based on pre-petition retainers and granted recognition.3
Taken together, these decisions underscore that—even where courts disagree on the applicability of Section 109(a)—Chapter 15 recognition may turn on whether threshold eligibility requirements are satisfied as of the petition date, with limited ability to cure deficiencies post-filing.
Section 109(a) and Chapter 15 of the US Bankruptcy Code
Chapter 15 generally provides that a US bankruptcy court shall recognize a foreign proceeding that is pending in a country where the debtor has its COMI or an establishment. Although not part of Chapter 15, Section 109(a) provides that only a “person that resides or has a domicile, a place of business, or property” in the US may be a debtor under the US Bankruptcy Code.4
In re Barnet, a decision of the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, which includes New York, held that Section 109(a) applies in Chapter 15 cases, reasoning that Section 103(a) of the US Bankruptcy Code makes Chapter 1 applicable to Chapter 15. Thus, in jurisdictions that follow in re Barnet,5 courts also require that the debtor satisfy Section 109(a)—meaning that it must reside or have a domicile, a place of business, or property in the US. Other courts, including the US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit,6 which includes Florida, have reached the opposite conclusion, holding that Section 109(a) does not apply to Chapter 15 cases. Despite the doctrinal split, courts in both camps have converged on a practical expectation that some US nexus must exist as of the filing date.
At the bankruptcy court level, decisions reflect this divide. In Siu-Fung, a bankruptcy court in the Southern District of Texas adopted Barnet and held that Section 109(a) applies to Chapter 15. In Venus Capital, a bankruptcy court in the District of Rhode Island followed Al Zawawi and held that Section 109(a) does not apply. The court in Venus Capital further observed, however, that the debtors would have satisfied Section 109(a) through pre-petition retainers in any event. Thus, the reasoning in Venus Capital is consistent with Siu-Fung in emphasizing the practical importance of identifying a US asset as of the Chapter 15 filing date.
Petition-date or recognition-date measurement of COMI and Section 109(a)
In re Geden Holdings, Ltd. (Bankr. S.D. Tex. 2025)
In re Geden Holdings, Ltd. addressed whether COMI was established as of the Chapter 15 petition date.
Geden, a Maltese-registered shipping enterprise, was placed into liquidation in 2017. After a prolonged period of inactivity, a Chapter 15 petition was filed in April 2025, seeking recognition of the Maltese proceeding.
The court denied recognition. Under applicable law in the Fifth Circuit, which includes Texas, COMI is assessed as of the Chapter 15 petition date, not the date the foreign proceeding was commenced.7 The absence of substantive liquidation activity over a multi-year period therefore weighed against recognition. No liquidator served from 2018 to 2023, and the subsequently appointed liquidator had not undertaken material steps typically associated with a liquidation, such as engaging creditors, conducting investigations, or administering assets.
The court concluded that these circumstances were insufficient to establish COMI or an establishment in Malta as of the Chapter 15 petition date. The court did not separately address Section 109(a); the petition was denied solely on COMI and establishment grounds, and the Section 109(a) question was not reached. The decision also reflects that a presumption of COMI based on a registered office may be rebutted where the underlying proceeding lacks meaningful activity.
The court’s analysis highlights that a foreign proceeding that becomes dormant may not maintain its presumptive COMI if the foreign representative does not take substantive steps in the proceeding prior to the filing Chapter 15.
In re Siu-Fung Ceramics Holdings Ltd. (Bankr. S.D. Tex. 2026)
In Siu-Fung, the US Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Texas addressed whether Section 109(a) was satisfied where the debtor’s only alleged US asset was a retainer deposited after the Chapter 15 filing.
Courts applying Section 109(a) in Chapter 15 cases generally interpret the property requirement broadly. Even nominal assets—such as an undrawn retainer held in a US account—may be sufficient.
Although there was a retainer in Siu-Fung, the dispositive issue was timing. The foreign representative relied on a $1,200 retainer held in a US counsel’s IOLTA account, but the retainer was not deposited until approximately nine months after the Chapter 15 petition was filed.
Section 109(a) uses the present tense, requiring that a debtor “have” property in the US Courts have therefore generally assessed eligibility as of the petition date. Because the retainer, the only US property the debtor held, did not exist as of the petition date, the court held that Section 109(a) was not satisfied and denied recognition. The decision illustrates that post-petition efforts to manufacture US assets will not cure eligibility defects.
In re Venus Capital Management (Bankr. D.R.I. 2026)
In Venus Capital, the Bankruptcy Court for the District of Rhode Island considered five simultaneously filed Chapter 15 petitions seeking recognition of foreign proceedings in Mauritius and the British Virgin Islands. The court held that Section 109(a) does not apply to Chapter 15 cases, adopting the Eleventh Circuit’s approach in Al Zawawi and reasoning that Section 1517’s enumerated requirements for recognition are exclusive. The court added, however, that the debtors would have satisfied Section 109(a) in any event through pre-petition retainer accounts held with US counsel in Rhode Island, confirming that—even where Section 109(a) is deemed inapplicable—courts may still consider similar indicia in assessing the overall propriety of recognition. Recognition was granted.
In re British American Insurance Company Limited (Bankr. S.D. Fla. 2010)
In contrast to Geden and Siu-Fung, a minority approach has reached a different conclusion. In re British American Insurance Company Limited, a bankruptcy court held that Section 109(a) eligibility should be assessed as of the recognition hearing rather than the Chapter 15 petition date, focusing on Section 1517(a)’s directive that a court “shall” enter an order recognizing a qualifying foreign proceeding after notice and a hearing, meaning at the time the court acts and not at the time the Chapter 15 petition is filed.8 The petition date approach, however, remains the prevailing framework and the recognition hearing approach has not been adopted to date by any Circuit Court of Appeals.
Key Takeaways and Filing Considerations
Although Siu-Fung, Geden, and Venus Capital reflect a continuing divergence in authority as to whether Section 109(a) applies in Chapter 15 cases, these decisions collectively reinforce a common practical constraint: eligibility for recognition is highly sensitive to the conditions that exist as of the petition date. Courts have consistently declined to give effect to post-petition efforts to establish US property or otherwise cure deficiencies in COMI or establishment.
As a result, the risk of denial may arise not from the substantive difficulty of meeting the statutory requirements—given the relatively low threshold for US property or activity—but from failure to ensure that those requirements are satisfied at the correct point in time. In this respect, the petition date operates as a hard boundary for both Section 109(a) eligibility (where applicable) and COMI analysis in most jurisdictions.
These decisions therefore underscore that Chapter 15 filings require careful pre-filing structuring, including confirmation that any US nexus—whether in the form of retainer funds or other minimal property—and sufficient ongoing activity in the foreign proceeding are established prior to filing and can be substantiated as of the petition date.
The following are several practical considerations that foreign representatives and their advisors should consider before filing a petition under Chapter 15:
- Applicability of Section 109(a): Treat Section 109(a) as a threshold requirement in jurisdictions that follow Barnet, including the Southern District of Texas.
- Satisfying the US property requirement: Ensure that at least minimal US property exists prior to filing. Courts have held that even nominal assets—such as a pre-petition retainer maintained in a US account—may be sufficient.
- Timing of eligibility: Both Section 109(a) and COMI are typically assessed as of the Chapter 15 petition date. Confirm that all eligibility criteria are satisfied as of the petition date.
- Ongoing activity in foreign proceedings: As reflected in Geden, a foreign proceeding may not support recognition where there has been an extended absence of substantive activity prior to the Chapter 15 filing.
In practice, advance coordination with US counsel to establish a qualifying US asset prior to filing may be a low-cost but critical step in mitigating recognition risk.
Footnotes
-
In re Siu-Fung Ceramics Holdings Ltd., No. 24-33299, 2026 WL 382424 (Bankr. S.D. Tex. Feb. 10, 2026). \
-
In re Geden Holdings, Ltd., 674 B.R. 732 (Bankr. S.D. Tex. 2025).
-
In re Venus Capital Management, Case No. 25-10709 (Bankr. D.R.I. Mar. 2, 2026).\
-
11 U.S.C. § 109(a). \
-
Drawbridge Special Opportunities Fund LP v. Barnet (In re Barnet), 737 F.3d 238 (2d Cir. 2013).
-
In re Al Zawawi, 97 F.4th 1244 (11th Cir. 2024).
-
Lavie v. Ran (In re Ran), 607 F.3d 1017, 1025 (5th Cir. 2010).\
-
In re British American Insurance Company Limited, 425 B.R. 884, 909–10 (Bankr. S.D. Fla. 2010).