Overview

The English High Court has confirmed the robustness of recognition under the Cross Border Insolvency Regulations 2006 (CBIR), the British enactment of the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency 1997 (the Model Law).

Dismissing an attempt by Mr Shahzad (the Bankrupt) to set aside recognition of their Danish bankruptcy proceedings, the court in Shahzad v Bramhelft [2026] EWHC 1039 (Ch) ruled that the Danish bankruptcy qualified for recognition under CBIR because it was a legitimate, collective insolvency proceeding under the Danish court’s supervision, and not (as the Bankrupt had argued) merely a vehicle to enforce Danish tax liabilities, contrary to public policy.

Recognition of insolvency proceedings and the public policy carve-out

Article 17 of CBIR requires recognition of foreign insolvency and bankruptcy proceedings where the process is collective, pursuant to a law relating to insolvency, subject to the foreign court’s supervision and for the purposes of reorganization or liquidation. Where the debtor has their Centre of Main Interests (COMI) or an ‘establishment’ in the jurisdiction in which the insolvency proceedings have been opened, the proceedings should be recognized in all three constituent parts of Great Britain (England, Wales and Scotland) as ‘foreign main proceedings’ or ‘foreign non-main’ proceedings, respectively. There are strict exceptions where recognition may be refused, even though the above conditions are satisfied.

Article 6 allows the court to refuse recognition if it would be “manifestly” contrary to British public policy. As the Model Law is a voluntary, template piece of legislation, jurisdictions which choose to enact domestic laws based on the Model Law have autonomy and flexibility over how they do so. The Model Law itself envisages that individual states may wish to refuse recognition or assistance where it would be inconsistent with their national public policy. The Model 11Law text also contemplates states choosing whether the public policy exception should be adopted in broader or narrower terms, as deciding whether or not to include the word “manifestly” in the exception is left to the discretion of adopting states.

Great Britain chose to include the (arguably, stricter) word such that, under CBIR, recognition of foreign proceedings can only be rejected where they are considered ‘manifestly’ contrary to public policy:

“Nothing in this Law prevents the court from refusing to take an action governed by this Law if the action would be manifestly contrary to the public policy of Great Britain or any part of it” (Article 6, CBIR).

Nevertheless, there has been relatively little guidance from Parliament or the courts on the circumstances in which the exception might apply. In 2024, the UK Supreme Court in Kireeva v Bedhamova clarified that the exception is a narrow one. In that case, the issue before the court was whether a Russian trustee should be granted assistance in relation to real property owned by the Russian bankrupt in London, England. The Supreme Court primarily was concerned with public policy principles under the English common law, specifically in relation to immovables such as land. The ‘immovables principle’ provides that any questions relating to interests in land (and other immovable property) should be governed solely by the laws and courts of the country in which the property is situated. However, the Supreme Court also took the opportunity to comment on CBIR, observing that provided the relevant insolvency proceeding satisfies the prerequisite conditions and does not fall within the public policy exception, the court is obliged to recognize the proceedings.

In a unanimous judgment, the Supreme Court concluded that the immovables principle was a creature of public policy:

“…to enable courts in [the UK] to assist a foreign trustee in bankruptcy by appointing a receiver with a power of sale over immovable property [in the UK] must be a matter for [the UK] Parliament and not for the courts. It would not involve an incremental development of the common law but a substantial departure from the existing law and the principles of public policy to which it gives effect. In particular, the considerations of national sovereignty which underpin the immovables rule require that such a development should have the approval of Parliament.”1 (Emphasis added).

Matters of national sovereignty are perhaps an obvious area where one would expect public policy considerations to be engaged. The Shahzad v Bramhelft decision has provided the High Court with the opportunity to consider the role of public policy in cross-border insolvencies in a different context; in this case, the scope of the public policy exception to recognition of foreign bankruptcy proceedings under CBIR.

Facts of Shahzad v Bramhelft

On the petition of the Danish tax authority, the applicant was adjudged bankrupt by the Danish Commercial and Maritime Court on December 16, 2022. The Danish trustee, Mr Bramhelft (the Trustee), obtained recognition in England on January 31, 2025 on the basis that the Danish proceedings were ‘foreign main proceedings.’ The Bankrupt, who had not attended the recognition hearing, then applied to set aside the recognition order on public policy grounds.

The Bankrupt argued that the bankruptcy was effectively a tool to collect Danish tax liabilities and that the Trustee was acting in the interests of the Danish tax authority. Article 13 of CBIR modifies the traditional bar on enforcing foreign tax laws by providing that foreign tax authorities may prove for the tax debt, just like any other creditor.

By contrast, the Trustee argued the bankruptcy was a qualifying insolvency proceeding, with independent oversight, and diverse creditors involved. The Danish tax authority was not the only creditor, and the Trustee submitted that there was no evidence of any control or improper influence in the bankruptcy proceedings by the tax authority.

Decision of the English Court

The High Court dismissed the Bankrupt’s challenge to the recognition order. The evidence demonstrated a genuine, collective process governed by Danish bankruptcy law, with the Trustee owing duties to the Danish court and to the general body of creditors on a pari passu basis. The judge, Insolvency and Companies Court Judge Agnello KC, distinguished previous cases where the foreign state entity was the sole beneficiary of proceedings. In the present case, the Danish tax authority was not the only creditor, or even a dominant creditor: the aggregate proved claims were almost DKK32.5 million, of which the Danish tax authority was owed approximately DKK3.18 million. In other words, the tax claims accounted for less than 10 percent of the total debt.

Arguments that tax collection was the dominant purpose of the proceedings therefore lacked any clear evidential basis. The judge determined that the Trustee acted in the interests of all creditors and the fact that the Danish tax authority had provided funding for the bankruptcy proceedings was not evidence of impropriety or direct enforcement of tax claims by the Danish tax authority. There was simply no evidence that the Danish bankruptcy was for the benefit of only the Danish tax authority.

Conclusion: Three key takeaways for cross-border recognition applications

  • Recognition under CBIR will sustain challenge where the foreign process is demonstrably collective, court supervised and insolvency law-based.
  • The public policy exception to recognition and assistance is narrow; in a similar case, a challenger must produce evidence that the proceeding is in substance a revenue enforcement exercise. It is insufficient merely to assert that a tax authority has petitioned for the insolvency, funded the proceedings or is a large creditor.
  • Debtors contemplating challenges to recognition on public policy grounds under CBIR should anticipate the high evidential burden.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    [2024] UKSC 39 at [para 103]

Contact