Professional advice will not, by itself, provide a reasonable excuse for failing to comply with HMRC information notices and the resulting penalties. Those relying on adviser advice must take care that it is reasonable to do so, including asking obvious questions and checking key information where appropriate.

Two pension scheme administrators were largely unsuccessful in their appeal against HMRC’s information notices and the resulting penalties after the Upper Tribunal agreed that they did not have a "reasonable excuse" defence for non-compliance with the notices.

The administrators argued that they did have a reasonable excuse because a tax adviser, engaged by the scheme operator, had advised that there was no need to respond to the information notices because the schemes had been wound-up. The Upper Tribunal accepted that while the administrators (and taxpayers in general) are not expected to second-guess professional advisers or seek multiple opinions, they must take reasonable care in relying on that professional adviser's advice.

Here, the administrators did not do enough. They accepted advice relayed through the scheme operator without asking obvious follow-up questions or requesting copies of correspondence with HMRC. The Upper Tribunal also noted that they failed to check key facts underpinning the advice, including matters relating to the schemes' winding-up. It therefore agreed with the First-tier Tribunal that the administrators did not have a reasonable excuse for non-compliance with the information notices.

The appeal was allowed on the quantum of penalties, which will be reconsidered.

The full judgment is here.

Contact