The High Court has approved a negotiated compromise in a pension age equalisation dispute. The parties agreed on an intermediate normal retirement age of 61.7 years for the disputed period and asked the Court to approve that outcome, rather than determine whether the correct age was 60 or 65 years. The Court concluded that the compromise represented a fair and practical resolution.
The dispute concerned whether a 1992 trust deed and rules had successfully equalised normal retirement ages at 65. If it had not, the more favourable normal retirement age of 60 would have continued to apply until a later amendment in 1999, resulting in additional liabilities for the scheme.
The parties reached a compromise: normal retirement age would be 60 for service between May 17, 1990, and May 12, 1992, 61.7 for service between May 13, 1992, and April 5, 1999, and 65 thereafter. The compromise reflected the parties' 66:34 assessment of the merits that equalisation had not been achieved in 1992.
Having reached a compromise, the parties asked the High Court to approve it. To do so, the Court had to be satisfied that the compromise was for the benefit of all represented groups and that it struck a fair balance between the differing interests of the represented groups.
The judge held that it did: the compromise delivered certainty, avoided the cost and risk of litigation, provided clarity on the benefits payable and reflected the parties' carefully negotiated 66:34 assessment of the merits.
The full judgment is available here.
Comment
The most interesting aspect of this case is that the outcome was a normal retirement age of neither 60 nor 65. Instead, the parties agreed an intermediate normal retirement age of 61.7 years that reflected their assessment of the merits, and the Court was prepared to approve that compromise. The decision shows that, where there is genuine uncertainty and competing interests, a negotiated middle ground may provide a practical alternative to the cost, delay and risk of pursuing an all or nothing outcome at trial.